Demonstrative Reference and Cognitive Space: A Memory Game on Mandarin-Speaking Children

Lu Zhao, Lu ZouInternational Journal of Linguistics 2021 · DOI

Abstract

The development of pragmatic ability is an essential topic in language acquisition, among which demonstratives are significant to reflect human’s cognition of the relation between language and the environment. The purpose of this research is to investigate the acquisition of spatial demonstratives “zhe” (this) and “na” (that) of Mandarin-speaking children through experimental design (different tool use, e.g. participants pointed at the objects with their finger or a laser pen), exploring the influence of perceptual distance on children’s choice of spatial demonstratives. Through comparison with adults’ data, results supported the view that 5- to 6-year-old children have already developed adult-like cognitive space when it comes to the use of spatial demonstratives, which produced an effect on the use of spatial demonstratives, proving speaker’s subjective involvement in choosing the proximal or distal demonstrative in the process of communication, and rendering more evidence on children’s early development of pragmatic ability.

Introduction

In the field of linguistics, a long-standing debate exists regarding spatial demonstratives—words like "this" (zhe) and "that" (na). The traditional view posits that speakers choose these words based on objective physical distance. In contrast, the "mental space" view suggests that these choices are subjective, influenced by a speaker's psychological perception of reach and control.

While this phenomenon is well-documented in adults, the developmental timeline for children has remained less clear. This study specifically examines Mandarin-speaking children to determine if they see the world through the same "perceptual lens" as adults, or if their spatial language is strictly tied to physical boundaries. By age five, are children capable of the complex cognitive mapping required to treat tools as extensions of their own bodies?

Experimental Design and Methods

To investigate these questions, researchers employed a "Memory Game" design involving 60 participants: 30 native Mandarin-speaking adults (average age 23.2) and 30 preschool children (ages 5 to 6).

The Setup

Participants were seated at a long table featuring five colored dots placed at 30cm intervals. The first two dots were positioned within a standard arm's reach, while the remaining three were physically distal.

Experimental setup showing the five colored dots spaced at 30cm intervals.

The Task

An experimenter placed toy animals on the dots and then removed them. Participants were asked to tell a puppet where a specific animal had been by pointing and saying a phrase like "The pig was on this (zhe) red dot."

The Variable: Tool Use

The primary variable was the tool used for pointing. In half of the trials, participants used their finger. In the other half, they used a laser pen. The logic behind this manipulation is that if word choice is purely about physical distance, the tool should not matter. However, if using a laser pen "extends" the speaker's perceived reach into "near space," they should use the proximal term (zhe) for further distances than they would when using only a finger.

Key Results and Insights

The "Extended Reach" Effect

The most striking finding was that the laser pen acted as a cognitive extension of the body for both groups. When participants used the laser, their perceived "near space" expanded. They began using zhe (this) for objects that were physically far away but "reachable" via the laser beam.

Tool Influence and Switch Points

  • Proximal Space: For the first two dots (within 60cm), participants used zhe almost 100% of the time, regardless of the tool.
  • Distal Space: Starting at the third dot (90cm), the tool made a massive difference. When pointing with a finger, participants switched to na (that). When using the laser pen, they continued to use zhe (this) much more frequently.

Adult vs. Child Performance

Statistical analysis (Cochran and McNemar tests) revealed that children’s data was highly similar to that of adults. Both groups showed a significant interaction effect between distance and tool use (p < 0.001). This suggests that the cognitive "hardware" for mapping psychological space onto linguistic labels is fully operational by age five.

Discussion and Conclusion

The results confirm Fauconnier’s (1985) Mental Space theory: language is not a direct mirror of the physical world, but a reflection of how the human mind perceives and interacts with it. The study proves that 5- to 6-year-old children have already developed adult-like cognitive space, showing early pragmatic maturity in their ability to involve subjective perception in communication.

Limitations and Future Work

While the study establishes a baseline for 5-year-olds, it remains unclear if younger children (ages 3-4) would show the same mapping or if they are more strictly tied to physical distance. Future research could also explore whether this cognitive space is an instinctive human trait or a learned linguistic behavior, and how individual physical traits like arm length correlate with specific linguistic "switch points."

Summary updated

Abstract

The development of pragmatic ability is an essential topic in language acquisition, among which demonstratives are significant to reflect human’s cognition of the relation between language and the environment. The purpose of this research is to investigate the acquisition of spatial demonstratives “zhe” (this) and “na” (that) of Mandarin-speaking children through experimental design (different tool use, e.g. participants pointed at the objects with their finger or a laser pen), exploring the influence of perceptual distance on children’s choice of spatial demonstratives. Through comparison with adults’ data, results supported the view that 5- to 6-year-old children have already developed adult-like cognitive space when it comes to the use of spatial demonstratives, which produced an effect on the use of spatial demonstratives, proving speaker’s subjective involvement in choosing the proximal or distal demonstrative in the process of communication, and rendering more evidence on children’s early development of pragmatic ability.
BibTeX
@article{zhao2021demonstrative,
  author = {Lu Zhao and Lu Zou},
  title = {{Demonstrative Reference and Cognitive Space: A Memory Game on Mandarin-Speaking Children}},
  journal = {International Journal of Linguistics},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.5296/ijl.v13i2.18371},
}
Figure