Democracy and Growth in the 21st Century

Yusuke NaritaarXiv 2021 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract: We find that, in the 21st century, democracy has persistent negative impacts on growth in GDP and night-time light intensity. This finding emerges from five different instrumental variable strategies that account for potential invalidity in some of the instruments. Our analysis also suggests a key mechanism: In this century, many electoral democracies shift toward populism and protectionism. These political changes weaken trade and investment, collectively dampening economic growth. Democracies also experienced lower growth in subjective life satisfaction among citizens. However, democracy causes slower growth in CO2 emissions and energy use, suggesting a trade-off between economic growth and socio-environmental performance.

Introduction

For decades, the prevailing consensus in political economy—championed by scholars like Daron Acemoglu—was that democratic institutions are the primary engines of long-term economic prosperity. By protecting property rights and encouraging investment, democracy was seen as a prerequisite for growth. However, the first two decades of the 21st century have challenged this narrative. The meteoric rise of autocratic China, alongside democratic backsliding and the surge of populism in the West, suggests a fundamental shift in the relationship between political systems and economic performance.

In a recent study, Yusuke Narita (Yale University) investigates whether the "democracy dividend" of the 20th century has vanished. His findings suggest a provocative reversal: in the modern era, democracy may actually act as a "tax" on economic growth.

Methodology: Isolating the Causal Effect

A central challenge in this field is the problem of reverse causality: does democracy cause growth, or do wealthy countries simply find it easier to democratize? To address this, Narita employs a rigorous Instrumental Variable (IV) strategy using Two-Stage Least Squares (2SLS) and Generalized Method of Moments (GMM).

He utilizes five distinct sets of historical and geographic "shocks" to predict modern democracy levels, ensuring the results are not the product of a single flawed model:

  1. Settler Mortality: Historical death rates of colonial settlers.
  2. Population Density in 1500: High density often led to extractive colonial regimes.
  3. Legal Origin: British Common Law vs. Civil Law traditions.
  4. Language: The prevalence of English or Western European languages.
  5. Geographic Endowments: Historical availability of specific crops and minerals.

To ensure data integrity, especially in countries where official GDP figures might be manipulated, the study uses night-time light intensity captured via satellite as a proxy for economic activity. Furthermore, the analysis applies modern econometric techniques to account for the potential invalidity of historical instruments in a 21st-century context.

The Great Reversal: Empirical Findings

The study’s results indicate a significant departure from 20th-century trends. Between 2001 and 2022, democracy became a statistically significant drag on growth.

  • GDP Impact: A one standard deviation increase in a country’s democracy level (using the V-Dem Electoral Democracy Index) causes a 2.2 percentage point decrease in annual GDP growth.
  • Night-time Lights: This finding is corroborated by satellite data, which shows a 2.3 percentage point decrease in the growth of light intensity.
  • Pandemic Performance: The "democracy tax" extended to crisis management. During the COVID-19 pandemic, a 1 s.d. increase in democracy was associated with 22.4 more excess deaths per 100,000 people and deeper economic recessions, likely due to narrower and less decisive initial containment policies.

The Mechanism: Populism and Protectionism

Why has democracy’s impact on growth flipped? Narita identifies a specific political channel: the rise of short-termism, protectionism, and polarization.

Modern democracies appear increasingly prone to populist shifts that prioritize immediate consumption or protectionist trade policies over long-term stability. The data shows that democracy causes a 0.4 s.d. increase in protectionism and a 0.6 s.d. increase in populism. These factors lead to stagnation in "future-oriented" investments, such as R&D, education, and physical capital formation, which are essential for sustained growth.

The Socio-Environmental Trade-off

Despite the negative economic findings, the study highlights a critical trade-off. While democracies grow more slowly, they perform significantly better on environmental and social metrics. Democracy causes a 2.7 percentage point reduction in the growth of CO2 emissions and a 2.5 percentage point reduction in energy use growth. This suggests that democratic institutions may be better suited for managing the "negative externalities" of industrialization, prioritizing sustainability over raw output.

Conclusion and Limitations

Narita’s research suggests that the 21st century presents a new set of challenges for democratic governance. While democracy remains a powerful tool for environmental protection and equality, its current form appears to struggle with the economic demands of the modern era, largely due to the rise of populist and protectionist tendencies.

However, the author notes several caveats. The study focuses on countries that were already democratic at the baseline, and it remains unclear if the process of democratization yields the same immediate slowdown. Furthermore, the 21st century is still in its early stages; it is possible that the stability and human capital fostered by democracy will yield superior economic results in the very long run (50+ years). For now, the data suggests that the relationship between freedom and growth is more complex—and more fraught—than previously believed.

Summary updated

Abstract

We find that, in the 21st century, democracy has persistent negative impacts on growth in GDP and night-time light intensity. This finding emerges from five different instrumental variable strategies that account for potential invalidity in some of the instruments. Our analysis also suggests a key mechanism: In this century, many electoral democracies shift toward populism and protectionism. These political changes weaken trade and investment, collectively dampening economic growth. Democracies also experienced lower growth in subjective life satisfaction among citizens. However, democracy causes slower growth in CO2 emissions and energy use, suggesting a trade-off between economic growth and socio-environmental performance.
BibTeX
@misc{narita2021democracy,
  author = {Yusuke Narita},
  title = {{Democracy and Growth in the 21st Century}},
  year = {2021},
  eprint = {2104.07617},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2104.07617},
}
Figure