DEMATEL and ISM analysis of factors influencing coal spontaneous combustion in longwall gobs

Liming Zhou, Jiangfeng Wang, Guozhong Dai, Min Tang, Jing QiuJournal of the Southern African Institute of Mining and Metallurgy 2024 · DOI

Abstract

Coal spontaneous combustion in longwall gobs is a major concern in coal mines. In comparison to other hazards, this phenomenon is difficult to detect. Fifteen factors influencing coal spontaneous combustion in longwall gobs were identified from the literature. The logical relationships between these factors were evaluated and quantified by decision-making trial and evaluation laboratory (DEMATEL) and interpretive structural modelling (ISM) methods. A four-level hierarchical structure model was established. The research shows that combining DEMATEL and ISM can reveal the key factors that influence coal spontaneous combustion in longwall gobs and establish the interactions and relationships among these factors. The results can provide the basis for preventing and controlling coal spontaneous combustion in longwall gobs.

Introduction: The Challenge of Spontaneous Combustion

In coal mining, the "gob" refers to the abandoned, hollowed-out area left behind as a longwall working face advances. These areas often contain residual coal and are highly susceptible to spontaneous combustion—a "silent killer" that is notoriously difficult to detect until it reaches a critical stage. While factors such as oxygen supply, coal type, and ventilation are known contributors, they do not act in isolation. Instead, they form a complex, non-linear network of influences. This study addresses the "complexity gap" by quantifying the logical and hierarchical relationships between 15 key influencing factors to determine the primary drivers of fire risk.

Methodology: A Hybrid Analytical Framework

To transition from qualitative expert insights to a quantitative structural model, the researchers employed a two-pronged mathematical approach:

  1. DEMATEL (Decision-Making Trial and Evaluation Laboratory): This method calculates the "influence" and "dependence" of each factor, categorizing them into a Cause Group (drivers of change) and an Effect Group (results of other factors).
  2. ISM (Interpretive Structural Modelling): This technique organizes the logical relationships identified by DEMATEL into a visible, multi-level hierarchy.
The hybrid DEMATEL-ISM methodology flowchart used to analyze the complex relationships between fire-inducing factors.

The process began with a literature synthesis to identify 15 critical factors, followed by consultations with industry experts to rank the intensity of their relationships on a scale of 0 to 4.

Identifying Influencing Factors

The study distilled 15 factors from existing mining safety research, ranging from physical coal properties to management practices. These factors are categorized into four primary domains: spontaneous combustion tendency, air leakage, heat storage/dissipation conditions, and safety management.

Hierarchical categorization of the 15 factors influencing spontaneous coal combustion in longwall gobs.

Key Insights and Results

The analysis successfully mapped these factors into a four-level hierarchical structure, distinguishing between immediate triggers and fundamental root causes.

  • Root vs. Symptom: The "top" level (Level 1) contains direct triggers such as surrounding rock temperature, propulsion speed ratio, and the critical temperature of the coal. These are the immediate precursors to a fire event. Conversely, the "bottom" level (Level 4) contains fundamental causes like ventilation mode, dip angle, roof lithology, and management level.
  • The Centrality of Management: Factor $x_{15}$ (Management level) emerged with the highest "centrality" score in the DEMATEL analysis. This indicates that while geological factors are largely fixed, management quality is the most critical lever for influencing the entire safety system.
  • Geology as a Primary Driver: Factors such as Roof lithology ($x_8$) and Dip angle of coal seam ($x_7$) were identified as strong "cause" factors. These fundamental drivers dictate the patterns of air leakage into the gob, which subsequently fuels combustion.
  • Quantified Influence: The DEMATEL analysis provided specific Causality ($N_i$) scores. Factors with $N_i > 0$ (e.g., $x_8$ Roof lithology) are net influencers, while those with $N_i < 0$ (e.g., $x_{10}$ Propulsion speed ratio) are net recipients of influence.

Conclusion and Future Directions

By integrating DEMATEL and ISM, this research provides a roadmap for more effective mine safety interventions. While the model is currently based on expert rankings and provides a static structural "snapshot," it establishes a foundation for future dynamic safety evaluation systems. The authors suggest that this hierarchical model can serve as the basis for developing automated monitoring protocols and real-time safety assessments in longwall mining operations.

Summary updated

Abstract

Coal spontaneous combustion in longwall gobs is a major concern in coal mines. In comparison to other hazards, this phenomenon is difficult to detect. Fifteen factors influencing coal spontaneous combustion in longwall gobs were identified from the literature. The logical relationships between these factors were evaluated and quantified by decision-making trial and evaluation laboratory (DEMATEL) and interpretive structural modelling (ISM) methods. A four-level hierarchical structure model was established. The research shows that combining DEMATEL and ISM can reveal the key factors that influence coal spontaneous combustion in longwall gobs and establish the interactions and relationships among these factors. The results can provide the basis for preventing and controlling coal spontaneous combustion in longwall gobs.
BibTeX
@article{zhou2024dematel,
  author = {Liming Zhou and Jiangfeng Wang and Guozhong Dai and Min Tang and Jing Qiu},
  title = {{DEMATEL and ISM analysis of factors influencing coal spontaneous combustion in longwall gobs}},
  journal = {Journal of the Southern African Institute of Mining and Metallurgy},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.17159/2411-9717/856/2024},
}
Figure