This retrospective study compares two cutting-edge minimally invasive endoscopic techniques for treating lumbar disc herniation: Delta large-channel endoscopic discectomy (DLED) and Unilateral biportal endoscopic discectomy (UBED). While both procedures achieve excellent clinical outcomes in pain reduction and functional recovery, DLED demonstrated superior surgical efficiency, characterized by shorter operation times, significantly lower blood loss, and reduced soft tissue trauma.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
Lumbar disc herniation (LDH) is a leading cause of lower back pain and sciatica. While many patients recover with conservative treatment, those with severe nerve compression often require surgery. The surgical trend has shifted from "open" procedures to minimally invasive endoscopic techniques, which aim to decompress the nerve while preserving spinal stability and muscle integrity.
Two popular approaches have emerged:
- DLED: A single-port system using a larger-than-average (10mm) endoscope.
- UBED: A dual-port system (one for the camera, one for tools) that mimics traditional arthroscopic surgery.
Until now, there has been a lack of comparative data regarding which of these two specific approaches is more efficient or "gentler" on the patient’s physiology. The authors sought to fill this gap by comparing perioperative safety and clinical efficacy.
Methods
The researchers conducted a retrospective analysis of 74 patients treated at Nanjing Jinling Hospital between January 2023 and January 2024. The cohort was split into two groups: 39 patients underwent DLED and 35 underwent UBED.
- DLED Approach: Utilized a single-port "iLESSYS Delta" system. This involves a stepwise expansion tube that splits muscle fibers rather than dissecting them, providing a direct, high-efficiency channel to the herniation.
- UBED Approach: Utilized a dual-portal design. This requires creating a larger working space between the two ports to allow for tool maneuverability, often involving more extensive soft tissue separation.
The team measured "hard" surgical metrics (time, blood loss, fluoroscopy) and physiological markers of trauma, specifically Creatine Kinase (CK) levels, which serve as a proxy for muscle damage. Clinical success was measured via the Visual Analog Scale (VAS) for pain and the Oswestry Disability Index (ODI).
Datasets
The study utilized a primary clinical dataset of 74 patients with single-level disc herniation (at L4/L5 or L5/S1).
- Inclusion Criteria: Single-level herniation, failure of 3+ months of conservative treatment, and confirmation via MRI/CT.
- Exclusion Criteria: Multi-level herniation, spinal stenosis, or previous spinal surgeries.
No external benchmarks or public datasets were used, as this was an original clinical observation study.
Key Insights and Ideas
- Muscle-Splitting vs. Space-Creating: The most significant finding was the difference in Creatine Kinase (CK) levels. DLED patients had significantly lower post-operative CK levels than UBED patients. This suggests that the single-port "muscle-splitting" expansion used in DLED is less traumatic to the paravertebral muscles than the "space-creating" requirements of the dual-port UBED system.
- The "Hidden" Cost of UBED: UBED was associated with higher Hidden Blood Loss (HBL). The authors attribute this to the larger operating space and the potential for cancellous bone bleeding during the laminectomy phase of the dual-port procedure.
- Clinical Parity: Interestingly, despite the physiological differences (blood loss and muscle trauma), the subjective outcomes (pain and disability scores) were nearly identical between the two groups. This suggests that while DLED is "cleaner" and faster, both techniques are equally effective at achieving the primary goal: nerve decompression.
Key Results
- Surgical Efficiency: DLED was significantly faster, averaging 83.97 minutes compared to 94.29 minutes for UBED ($P = 0.006$).
- Blood Loss: Total blood loss was substantially lower in the DLED group (236.70 ml) versus the UBED group (356.32 ml) ($P = 0.002$).
- Physiological Trauma: Post-operative CK levels (indicating muscle damage) were 102.33 U/L for DLED and 120.54 U/L for UBED ($P < 0.001$).
- Clinical Success: Both groups saw VAS scores for back pain drop from ~6.6 pre-op to ~0.4 at six months. The "Excellent/Good" satisfaction rate (modified MacNab criteria) was 89.74% for DLED and 88.57% for UBED, showing no statistical difference in patient satisfaction.
Limitations and Future Work
The authors acknowledge several limitations:
- Retrospective Nature: The study was not a randomized controlled trial (RCT), which introduces potential selection bias.
- Sample Size: A cohort of 74 patients is relatively small for definitive clinical guidelines.
- Follow-up Duration: The 6-month follow-up is sufficient for short-term recovery but does not account for long-term recurrence rates or adjacent segment disease.
Future Work: The researchers suggest that larger-scale, multi-center randomized trials with long-term follow-up (2+ years) are necessary to fully validate the long-term safety and superiority of the DLED approach.
Summary updated