Deliberation Scheduling for Time-Critical Sequential Decision Making

Thomas L. Dean, Leslie Pack Kaelbling, Jak Kirman, Ann E. NicholsonUAI 1993 · OpenReview

TL;DR

This paper tackles the challenge of making optimal decisions in time-critical scenarios where actions must be taken quickly. The authors propose a novel "deliberation scheduling" approach that intelligently allocates computational resources to refine decision-making policies, balancing the need for speed with the desire for accuracy. This method allows agents to adapt and improve their decision-making strategies on the fly, even in complex, stochastic environments.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

In many real-world applications, such as robotics or autonomous systems, agents need to make sequential decisions under strict time constraints. These decisions are often based on models of the environment, which are typically stochastic (meaning outcomes are uncertain). The ideal approach would be to compute a perfect, optimal policy for every possible situation. However, for complex environments with many states and actions, this is computationally infeasible. The core problem is how to make the best possible decision within a limited time budget, especially when the agent can choose to spend time refining its decision-making strategy (deliberation) or act immediately. This paper focuses on the meta-level problem of scheduling this deliberation process.

Methods

The paper introduces a framework for "deliberation scheduling" that involves iteratively refining a decision-making policy. The core idea is to work with a "restricted automaton," which is a simplified model of the environment. The agent then computes a policy for this restricted automaton. This process is iterative and involves two main components:

  • Envelope Alteration (EA): This process expands or contracts the set of states considered in the restricted automaton. It can involve finding new paths to goals, adding likely states, or pruning unlikely states.
  • Policy Generation (PG): This is where the actual policy is computed for the current restricted automaton. The paper mentions using standard iterative algorithms like value iteration or policy iteration, which can be interrupted to yield a policy at any point.

The key innovation is the "deliberation scheduling" itself, which decides how to allocate time between EA and PG. The authors explore different models:

  • Precursor-deliberation models: The agent has one opportunity to deliberate before acting. This can be with a fixed deadline or a linear cost of delay.
  • Recurrent-deliberation models: The agent periodically replans, either when it "falls out" of its current policy's scope or at fixed intervals. This is crucial for dynamic environments.

The paper proposes using statistical models and empirical data to learn performance profiles that predict the expected improvement in decision quality for a given amount of deliberation time. This allows for greedy or myopic scheduling strategies.

Datasets

The experiments were conducted using a simulated mobile-robot path-planning domain. The environment consisted of 166 locations on a grid, leading to 664 states when considering robot orientation. The robot had five actions. This domain was chosen because it's easy to understand the generated policies and allows for comparison with exact optimal policy computation for smaller versions of the problem. No specific named datasets were used; rather, a simulated environment was created for evaluation.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The value of "anytime" algorithms: The paper emphasizes that in time-critical situations, it's often better to have a good-enough policy quickly than to wait for a perfect one. Deliberation scheduling enables this by allowing policies to be interrupted and used.
  • Intelligent resource allocation: The core insight is that simply spending more time deliberating doesn't always lead to proportional improvements. The paper proposes learning how to allocate time effectively by understanding the trade-offs between policy refinement and execution speed.
  • Restricted automata as a tractable approximation: Working with simplified models (restricted automata) is a practical way to handle large, complex environments. The iterative refinement of these automata and their policies is key.
  • Empirical learning of performance profiles: Instead of relying solely on theoretical models, the authors advocate for gathering statistics on how deliberation time affects policy improvement. This allows for data-driven scheduling decisions.
  • Recurrent deliberation for dynamic environments: The ability to replan periodically is essential for agents operating in environments that change or where new information becomes available over time.

Key Results

The paper presents empirical results from experiments on the mobile-robot domain. While specific quantitative improvements are not the sole focus, the results demonstrate:

  • Improved performance over time: The deliberation scheduling algorithm shows policies whose values increase over time as more deliberation is performed.
  • Comparison with baseline methods: In the mobile-robot domain, the proposed "LOOKUP" (recurrent-deliberation with strategies chosen using statistical estimates of EIV) algorithm achieved comparable or better results than standard policy iteration (ITER) and a full optimal policy computation (WHOLE) in terms of the number of steps taken to reach the goal. For example, LOOKUP took an average of 71 steps, while ITER took 87 and WHOLE took 246.
  • Statistical significance: The improvement obtained using the recurrent-deliberation algorithm was found to be statistically significant, even with preliminary results and potential bugs in the implementation.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Pessimistic strategies: The authors note that the strategies used in their experiments were found to be pessimistic, suggesting that further performance improvements are possible.
  • Computational complexity: Computing optimal deliberation schedules can be computationally complex, leading the authors to explore greedy and myopic strategies.
  • Uncertainty in observation: The current models assume the agent correctly identifies its state. The paper mentions extending this to handle uncertainty in observation as future work.
  • Larger domains: The experiments were conducted on domains small enough to compute optimal policies for comparison. Extending to larger, more realistic domains where exact solutions are infeasible is a key future direction.
  • More sophisticated scheduling: While greedy strategies were explored, developing more advanced deliberation scheduling algorithms remains an area for future research.

Summary updated

Abstract

We describe a method for time-critical decision making involving sequential tasks and stochastic processes. The method employs several iterative refinement routines for solving different aspects of the decision making problem. This paper concentrates on the meta-level control problem of deliberation scheduling, allocating computational resources to these routines. We provide different models corresponding to optimization problems that capture the different circumstances and computational strategies for decision making under time constraints. We consider precursor models in which all decision making is performed prior to execution and recurrent models in which decision making is performed in parallel with execution, accounting for the states observed during execution and anticipating future states. We describe algorithms for precursor and recurrent models and provide the results of our empirical investigations to date.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{dean1993deliberation,
  author = {Thomas L. Dean and Leslie Pack Kaelbling and Jak Kirman and Ann E. Nicholson},
  title = {{Deliberation Scheduling for Time-Critical Sequential Decision Making}},
  booktitle = {Conference on Uncertainty in Artificial Intelligence},
  year = {1993},
  url = {https://openreview.net/forum?id=Pv4qiFzV3U},
}
Figure