Delayless Block Individual-Weighting-Factors Sign Subband Adaptive Filters With an Improved Band-Dependent Variable Step-Size

Jung-Hee Kim, Jeong-Hwan Choi, Sang Won Nam, Joon-Hyuk ChangIEEE Access 2020 · DOI

Abstract

This paper presents a novel delayless block individual-weighting-factors sign subband adaptive filter (DB-IWF-SSAF) designed for robust active noise control (ANC) in environments plagued by impulsive noise. By combining a block-processing architecture with an improved band-dependent variable step-size (I-BDVSS) algorithm, the proposed method achieves superior noise reduction and faster convergence with significantly lower computational overhead than traditional delayless subband filters.

Introduction

Active Noise Control (ANC) is a critical technology for real-time audio applications, such as noise-canceling headphones. However, traditional ANC algorithms, like the filtered-x least mean square (FxLMS), are optimized for Gaussian noise and often fail when encountering impulsive noise—sudden, sharp acoustic spikes (e.g., machinery clanks or gunshots). These spikes violate the $l_2$-norm assumptions of standard filters.

To address this, researchers utilize Sign Subband Adaptive Filters (SSAF), which employ the more robust $l_1$-norm. While effective, standard SSAFs introduce signal path delays that are unacceptable for real-time use. Previous "delayless" versions solved the latency issue but remained computationally expensive. This paper proposes a hybrid approach that optimizes both efficiency and robustness.

Proposed Methodology

The authors introduce two major innovations to the SSAF framework:

  1. Block Implementation with Overlap-Save: Instead of updating filters on a sample-by-sample basis, the proposed DB-IWF-SSAF uses block processing. As illustrated in Figure 1, the filtered-x signal is generated in the frequency domain using Fast Fourier Transforms (FFTs) and the overlap-save technique. This allows for high-speed signal generation while keeping the weight updates in the time domain, where sign-based logic remains computationally trivial.
The proposed delayless block SSAF architecture, featuring frequency-domain filtering via FFT/IFFT for enhanced computational efficiency.
  1. Improved Band-Dependent Variable Step-Size (I-BDVSS): Subband filtering splits the signal into various frequency ranges. The proposed I-BDVSS exploits "auxiliary past gradients" that are naturally generated during block processing. By averaging these gradients, the algorithm dynamically adjusts the step-size for each band, leading to smoother and more rapid convergence without adding significant mathematical complexity.

Experimental Setup

The algorithm was tested using simulations modeled on the Symmetric Alpha Stable ($S\alpha S$) distribution to represent varying levels of impulsive noise. The characteristic exponent ($\alpha$) was varied from 1.0 (less impulsive) to 0.4 (highly impulsive). The primary and secondary acoustic paths were modeled using high-order Finite Impulse Response (FIR) filters to simulate realistic acoustic environments.

A representative acoustic impulse response used to model the system paths in the simulation studies.

Key Results and Discussion

  • Computational Efficiency: For a filter with $M=1024$ taps, the proposed block method reduced the multiplications required for filtered-x signal generation from 1024 down to approximately 104—a nearly 10x improvement in efficiency.
  • Enhanced Noise Reduction: In highly impulsive environments ($\alpha = 0.6$), the proposed I-BDVSS achieved an Averaged Noise Reduction (ANR) of ~22 dB, compared to the ~17 dB achieved by the original BDVSS algorithm.
  • Robust Stability: While conventional algorithms often become unstable or fail to converge under extreme impulsivity ($\alpha = 0.4$), the DB-IWF-SSAF remained stable and effective, proving its suitability for harsh real-world noise environments.

Conclusion

The DB-IWF-SSAF offers a powerful balance of robustness and efficiency for real-time ANC. By leveraging frequency-domain block processing and an intelligent variable step-size, it overcomes the limitations of previous delayless subband filters. Future research will focus on formal theoretical convergence analysis and hardware implementation for industrial and consumer audio devices.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@article{kim2020delayless,
  author = {Jung-Hee Kim and Jeong-Hwan Choi and Sang Won Nam and Joon-Hyuk Chang},
  title = {{Delayless Block Individual-Weighting-Factors Sign Subband Adaptive Filters With an Improved Band-Dependent Variable Step-Size}},
  journal = {IEEE Access},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.1109/access.2020.3029269},
}
Figure