Delayed Diagnosis of a Traumatic Diaphragmatic Injury

Seon-Wook Park, Cheol-Hong Kim, Ji‐Youn Kim, Seung Hwa Lee, Young-Wook Kim, In-Gyu Hyun, Ho-Seung ShinTuberculosis 2009 · DOI

Abstract

Traumatic diaphragmatic rupture is uncommon, but requires a prompt diagnosis and repair. Diaphragmatic injury is most commonly associated with automobile accidents. The diagnosis is difficult and may be delayed because there are no specific symptoms, signs, or radiographic studies that are pathognomic for diaphragmatic injury. The most important factor in the diagnosis is a high suspicion and the use of proper diagnostic studies. We report a case involving the delayed presentation of diaphragmatic rupture in a 54 year old man, requiring surgical repair 12 days following multiple blunt trauma. It should be noted that early recognition for diaphragmatic injury is important in patients with multiple trauma to avoid the potential fatal complications.

Introduction

Traumatic diaphragmatic rupture (TDR) is a rare but life-threatening consequence of blunt force trauma, occurring in roughly 0.8% to 5% of such cases. The primary challenge is that TDR lacks "pathognomonic" signs—specific symptoms or imaging results that point uniquely to the injury. In multi-trauma patients, symptoms like shortness of breath or chest pain are easily attributed to more obvious injuries like rib fractures or hemothorax. If left undiagnosed, the pressure differential between the abdomen and the chest can cause abdominal organs to migrate into the thoracic cavity, leading to organ strangulation and respiratory failure.

Case Presentation

A 54-year-old man was admitted following a high-velocity motor vehicle accident. Initial assessment revealed multiple rib fractures and a suspected hemothorax. He underwent immediate surgery for open leg fractures and received a chest tube for the suspected blood in the chest cavity. Despite these interventions, his respiratory symptoms persisted.

Diagnostic Challenges

Standard chest X-rays only catch TDR in about 17% to 40% of cases. In this patient, the initial radiographs showed increased opacity in the left lower lung, which was initially interpreted as a hemothorax or lung contusion, masking the underlying diaphragmatic tear. This "masking effect" is common in trauma bays where more obvious injuries dominate the clinical picture.

Figure 1: Chest radiographs at admission (A) showing rib fractures and lung opacity, and at 1-year follow-up (B) showing resolution.

Results and Surgical Intervention

The diaphragmatic rupture was finally identified 12 days post-trauma after a follow-up CT scan showed an "interrupted line" of the diaphragm and the spleen herniating into the left hemithorax. Surgeons discovered a significant 10x5 cm defect with the spleen, the fundus of the stomach, and the omentum having migrated into the chest.

Figure 2: CT scans at admission (A) and 12 days later (B), where the arrow indicates the herniated spleen and diaphragmatic defect.

Initial attempts at laparoscopic repair were unsuccessful due to adhesions, necessitating a conversion to thoracotomy. The organs were successfully returned to the abdomen, and the defect was sutured. Despite post-operative complications like pneumonia and empyema, the patient recovered and was discharged on day 52. A one-year follow-up confirmed good health with only minor pleural thickening.

Discussion and Conclusion

This case highlights the progressive nature of TDR, where a small tear can expand over time due to the pressure gradient of breathing. Clinicians must maintain a high index of suspicion in any patient with blunt chest trauma or lower rib fractures. While 3D CT reconstructions and the identification of the "collar sign" (constriction of herniated organs) can aid diagnosis, technology is fallible. Early diagnostic laparoscopy or thoracoscopy may be necessary when clinical suspicion remains high despite inconclusive imaging to prevent fatal complications.

Summary updated

Abstract

Traumatic diaphragmatic rupture is uncommon, but requires a prompt diagnosis and repair. Diaphragmatic injury is most commonly associated with automobile accidents. The diagnosis is difficult and may be delayed because there are no specific symptoms, signs, or radiographic studies that are pathognomic for diaphragmatic injury. The most important factor in the diagnosis is a high suspicion and the use of proper diagnostic studies. We report a case involving the delayed presentation of diaphragmatic rupture in a 54 year old man, requiring surgical repair 12 days following multiple blunt trauma. It should be noted that early recognition for diaphragmatic injury is important in patients with multiple trauma to avoid the potential fatal complications.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{park2009delayed,
  author = {Seon-Wook Park and Cheol-Hong Kim and Ji‐Youn Kim and Seung Hwa Lee and Young-Wook Kim and In-Gyu Hyun and Ho-Seung Shin},
  title = {{Delayed Diagnosis of a Traumatic Diaphragmatic Injury}},
  booktitle = {Tuberculosis},
  year = {2009},
  doi = {10.4046/trd.2009.66.3.241},
}
Figure