DEGRO practical guideline for central nervous system radiation necrosis part 1: classification and a multistep approach for diagnosis

Denise Bernhardt, Laila König, Anca-Ligia Grosu, Benedikt Wiestler, Stefan Rieken, Wolfgang Wick, Jens Gempt, Sandro M. Krieg, Friederike Schmidt‐Graf, Felix Sahm, Bernhard Meyer, Bernd J. Krause, Cordula Petersen, Rainer Fietkau, Michael Thomas, Frank A. Giordano, Andrea Wittig-Sauerwein, Jürgen Debus, Ghazaleh Tabatabai, Peter Hau, Joachim P. Steinbach, Stephanie E. Combs, Expert Panel of the German Society of Radiation Oncology (degro)Strahlentherapie 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This DEGRO (German Society of Radiation Oncology) guideline establishes a standardized framework for diagnosing central nervous system radiation necrosis (RN), a common but complex side effect of modern brain cancer therapy. It proposes a multistep diagnostic approach that integrates clinical history, radiotherapy (RT) dosimetry, advanced MRI, and amino acid PET to distinguish treatment-related changes from actual tumor progression.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

As cancer treatments improve, patients with brain metastases and gliomas are living longer. However, this success comes with a "diagnostic conundrum": the rise of treatment-related changes in the brain, specifically radiation necrosis (RN) and blood–brain barrier disruptions (BBD).

On a standard MRI, both RN and a returning tumor appear as "contrast-enhancing lesions" (CEL). Misidentifying RN as tumor progression can lead to unnecessary, risky surgeries or the discontinuation of effective treatments. Conversely, missing progressive RN can lead to severe, irreversible neurological deficits. Currently, there is a lack of consensus on nomenclature and diagnostic algorithms, making it difficult for clinicians to decide when to "wait and see" versus when to intervene.

Methods

The paper is a clinical practice guideline developed by an expert panel from DEGRO in cooperation with the German Cancer Society. The panel:

  1. Literature Review: Conducted a systematic search of PubMed (2000–2021) focusing on terms like "radiation necrosis," "bevacizumab," and "stereotactic radiosurgery."
  2. Multidisciplinary Consensus: Recruited experts from neurosurgery, neuroradiology, neuropathology, and neuro-oncology to ensure the guideline reflects the entire care chain.
  3. Pathogenesis Mapping: Synthesized current knowledge on the "vicious cycle" of RN, which involves vascular damage, hypoxia-induced VEGF secretion, and subsequent brain edema.
  4. Classification: Developed a standardized nomenclature (Table 1) to categorize lesions based on timing, dose, and imaging characteristics.

Datasets

As a clinical guideline, this paper does not introduce a new experimental dataset. Instead, it synthesizes evidence from:

  • Clinical Trials: Results from contemporary trials (e.g., QUANTEC data for dose-volume relationships).
  • Retrospective Studies: Long-term data on patients treated with stereotactic radiotherapy (SRS) and immunotherapy.
  • Literature Search: References published in English on PubMed between January 1, 2000, and November 1, 2021.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The VEGF Vicious Cycle: The paper highlights that RN isn't just "dead tissue." It’s a dynamic process where radiation damages blood vessels, causing local ischemia. This triggers the release of Vascular Endothelial Growth Factor (VEGF), which creates "leaky" new vessels, leading to more edema and further necrosis. This explains why the drug bevacizumab (an anti-VEGF antibody) is so effective at breaking the cycle.
  • BBD vs. RN: The authors distinguish between BBD (often called "pseudoprogression"), which is typically early (1–6 months), reversible, and mild, and RN, which is often late (6–18+ months), irreversible, and potentially lethal if untreated.
  • The "Swiss Cheese" Pattern: Typical RN on an MRI often displays a "Swiss cheese" or "spreading wavefront" enhancement pattern, which can help differentiate it from the more solid or ring-enhancing appearance of a recurring tumor.
  • The Multistep Approach: Diagnosis shouldn't rely on a single MRI. The panel recommends a hierarchy:
  • Clinical symptoms and timing.
  • Review of the original RT plan (did the lesion appear in a high-dose area?).
  • Advanced MRI (Perfusion/Diffusion).
  • Amino Acid PET: Using tracers like FET or F-DOPA is highlighted as a high-accuracy (80–90%) method to distinguish RN from tumor relapse.

Key Results

  • Standardized Nomenclature: The paper provides a definitive table (Table 1) classifying lesions into BBD, Early RN, Typical RN, and (Ultra-) late RN.
  • Dose Thresholds: It reaffirms that the risk of RN increases significantly when the maximum dose ($D_{max}$) exceeds 60–72 Gy, or when cumulative EQD2 (Equivalent Dose in 2 Gy fractions) exceeds 100 Gy in re-irradiation cases.
  • Diagnostic Tie-Breakers: While biopsy remains the gold standard, the guideline suggests that a combination of perfusion MRI (looking for decreased regional cerebral blood volume) and amino acid PET can provide sufficient diagnostic confidence in most clinical scenarios.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Pathological Ambiguity: The authors acknowledge that even a biopsy can be misleading, as many lesions are "mixed," containing both necrotic tissue and scattered tumor cells.
  • PET Availability: While amino acid PET is highly recommended, the authors note that cost and availability remain barriers in many clinical settings.
  • Computational Future: The paper points toward "Radiomics" and automated tumor segmentation using AI as the next frontier to improve diagnostic speed and accuracy.
  • Part 2: This paper is "Part 1" (classification and diagnosis); a subsequent publication will focus specifically on medical and surgical treatment recommendations.

Summary updated

Abstract

Diagnosis and treatment of RN requires multidisciplinary structures of care and defined processes. Diagnosis has to be made on an interdisciplinary level with the joint knowledge of a neuroradiologist, radiation oncologist, neurosurgeon, neuropathologist, and neuro-oncologist. A multistep approach as an opportunity to review as many characteristics as possible to improve diagnostic confidence is recommended. Additional information about radiotherapy (RT) techniques is crucial for the diagnosis of RN. Misdiagnosis of untreated and progressive RN can lead to severe neurological deficits. In this practice guideline, we propose a detailed nomenclature of treatment-related changes and a multistep approach for their diagnosis.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{bernhardt2022degro,
  author = {Denise Bernhardt and Laila König and Anca-Ligia Grosu and Benedikt Wiestler and Stefan Rieken and Wolfgang Wick and Jens Gempt and Sandro M. Krieg and Friederike Schmidt‐Graf and Felix Sahm and Bernhard Meyer and Bernd J. Krause and Cordula Petersen and Rainer Fietkau and Michael Thomas and Frank A. Giordano and Andrea Wittig-Sauerwein and Jürgen Debus and Ghazaleh Tabatabai and Peter Hau and Joachim P. Steinbach and Stephanie E. Combs and Expert Panel of the German Society of Radiation Oncology (DEGRO)},
  title = {{DEGRO practical guideline for central nervous system radiation necrosis part 1: classification and a multistep approach for diagnosis}},
  booktitle = {Strahlentherapie},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.1007/s00066-022-01994-3},
}
Figure