Degree of Pelvic Rotation in the Coronal Plane on Postoperative Radiographs Obtained after Total Hip Arthroplasty

Kuei-Lin Yeh, Tai‐Yin Wu, Chiou‐Shann Fuh, Chu‐Song Chen, Sheng‐Mou Hou, Chen‐Hao Chiang, Chen‐Kun LiawJournal of Clinical Medicine 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This study quantifies the often-overlooked pelvic rotation in coronal plane radiographs after total hip arthroplasty (THA), revealing a significant average rotation of 2.50°. This finding is crucial because neglecting pelvic rotation can lead to miscalculations in acetabular cup anteversion, impacting the assessment of THA outcomes and potentially leading to incorrect clinical judgments.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Accurate assessment of acetabular cup orientation, specifically anteversion, is vital for evaluating the success of Total Hip Arthroplasty (THA). This involves ensuring proper implant positioning to optimize range of motion, stability, and long-term function, and to detect early signs of complications like loosening or dislocation. While several methods exist for measuring cup anteversion from standard postoperative pelvic radiographs, most of them fail to account for pelvic rotation in the coronal plane. This rotation, which occurs when a patient is not perfectly positioned for the X-ray, can introduce significant errors into anteversion measurements. The paper addresses this gap by quantifying the extent of this potential pelvic rotation and highlighting its importance for accurate clinical assessment.

Methods

The researchers developed a novel method to quantify pelvic rotation using existing postoperative pelvic radiographs. They defined two key measurements: 'h', the horizontal displacement between the sacrococcygeal junction and the upper pole of the pubic symphysis, and 'ssd', the direct distance between these two anatomical landmarks. Pelvic rotation angle (θ) was then calculated using the formula: θ = arcsin(h/ssd) × (180°/π). This calculation was implemented within custom software, building upon their previously developed Elliversion software for cup anteversion measurement. The study also assessed the reliability of their measurements through interobserver and intraobserver analyses.

Datasets

The study utilized a dataset of 388 pelvic radiographs from 77 patients who underwent primary THA at Shin Kong Wu Ho-Su Memorial Hospital between January 2017 and December 2018. Patients with unclear anatomical landmarks (sacrococcygeal junctions, teardrops, or pubic symphysis) were excluded. The dataset comprised 50 women and 27 men, aged 21-91 years.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Pelvic Rotation is a Real and Significant Factor: The study definitively shows that pelvic rotation in the coronal plane is not negligible and averages 2.50° in postoperative THA patients.
  • Impact on Anteversion Measurement: This rotation can lead to substantial errors (up to 10-50% in some cases) in acetabular cup anteversion measurements, particularly for the anterolateral approach.
  • Clinical Implications: Miscalculated anteversion can lead to incorrect clinical judgments, potentially affecting decisions about implant revision or patient activity recommendations.
  • Need for Standardized Assessment: The findings underscore the necessity of considering pelvic rotation in all anteversion measurements to ensure accurate and reliable assessments of THA outcomes.
  • Reliable Measurement Tool: The developed software and methodology demonstrated good interobserver and intraobserver reliability, suggesting its potential for clinical use.

Key Results

The study found a mean pelvic rotation of 2.50° (with a standard deviation of 1.88°), ranging from 0.03° to 11.31°. The mean value of 'h' was -0.22 mm (SD 7.84 mm), and the mean 'ssd' was 158 mm (SD 12 mm). Statistical analysis showed no significant interobserver or intraobserver differences in the measurement of 'h', with p-values of 0.344 and 0.516, respectively.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations:

  • Standing Position Only: The study only analyzed radiographs taken when patients were standing. Postoperative radiographs are initially taken in the supine position, and the effect of patient position on pelvic rotation needs further investigation.
  • Projection Differences: The software and formula were adapted for orthographic projection, while clinical radiographs often use perspective projection. While the authors suggest the difference might be minimal, it warrants further exploration.
  • Software Availability: The custom software used for measurement is not currently available online, though the authors plan to make it accessible.

Future work will focus on investigating the effect of patient position (supine vs. standing) on pelvic rotation and exploring the impact of different projection types.

Summary updated

Abstract

There are many published cup anteversion measurements for postoperative total hip arthroplasty (THA), including Liaw’s, Lewinnek’s, and Murray’s methods. However, most measurements ignore the potential pelvic rotation on radiographs except in Liaw’s method. Without considering pelvic rotation, clinicians can miscalculate cup anteversion. Therefore, we aimed to quantify the mean degree of pelvic rotation. Herein, we collected 388 radiographs of 98 postoperative THA hips of 77 patients and measured pelvic rotation by measuring h, the horizontal displacement of the sacrococcygeal junction associated with the upper pole of the symphysis pubis, and ssd, the distance between the sacrococcygeal junction and pubic symphysis. The angle θ of pelvic rotation was defined as θ = arc sin (h/ssd) × (180°/π). The mean degree of pelvic rotation was then calculated. The standard deviation of h was 7.84 mm, and the mean ssd was 158 mm. The potential pelvic rotation was 2.50°. The p-values from the paired t-test were all >0.05 when interobserver and intraobserver errors were assessed. This is the first study to quantify the potential pelvic rotation in the coronal plane on postoperative plain radiographs. The potential pelvic rotation was too large to be neglected during the measurement of cup anteversion.
BibTeX
@article{yeh2022degree,
  author = {Kuei-Lin Yeh and Tai‐Yin Wu and Chiou‐Shann Fuh and Chu‐Song Chen and Sheng‐Mou Hou and Chen‐Hao Chiang and Chen‐Kun Liaw},
  title = {{Degree of Pelvic Rotation in the Coronal Plane on Postoperative Radiographs Obtained after Total Hip Arthroplasty}},
  journal = {Journal of Clinical Medicine},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.3390/jcm11216353},
}
Figure