Degradation of Coastlines under the Pressure of Urbanization and Tourism: Evidence on the Change of Land Systems from Europe, Asia and Africa

Alexandru-Ionuţ Petrişor, Walid Hamma, Huu Duy Nguyen, Giovanni Randazzo, Anselme Muzirafuti, Mari-Isabella Stan, Van Truong Tran, Roxana Aştefănoaiei, Quang‐Thanh Bui, Dragoş-Florian Vintilă, Quang Hải Trương, Cristina Lixăndroiu, Diana-Doina Ţenea, Igor Sîrodoev, Ioan IanoşLand 2020 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigates the impact of urbanization and tourism on coastal areas across Romania, Algeria, and Vietnam, revealing a global trend of increasing pressure on these vital ecosystems. The research highlights that "derogatory planning" and profit-driven exemptions from regulations are key drivers of degradation, underscoring the urgent need for integrated, sustainable land-use policies and international cooperation.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Coastal areas are incredibly valuable, providing essential ecosystem services and driving socio-economic development. However, they are increasingly facing immense pressure from human activities, particularly land-use change, urban sprawl, and tourism. This escalating pressure threatens the sustainability of these landscapes, necessitating in-depth analysis to develop effective management tools and policies. The paper addresses the critical gap in understanding the complex interplay between anthropogenic pressures (urbanization, tourism), socioeconomic factors, political influences, and the resulting degradation of coastal land systems on a global scale. It seeks to move beyond isolated case studies to identify common mechanisms and differences across diverse geographical and cultural contexts.

Methods

The study employed an "ecological approach," analyzing administrative units rather than individual organisms, to understand the broader system dynamics. The core methodology involved:

  • Geospatial Analysis: Producing maps of land-use/land-cover (LCLU) changes over time.
  • Indicator Computation: Calculating and analyzing various indicators related to urbanization, population density, and tourism.
  • Data Synergism: Correlating geospatial data (from satellite imagery and GIS) with socio-economic data (from statistical yearbooks, census data, and official reports).
  • Comparative Analysis: Examining three distinct case studies (Romania, Algeria, Vietnam) to identify both common drivers and context-specific variations.

Specific techniques included supervised classification of satellite imagery (Landsat, Sentinel, SPOT), CORINE land cover data analysis, and the use of statistical software (ArcGIS, Microsoft Excel) to compute correlation coefficients (Bravais-Pearson) and analyze transitional dynamics.

Datasets

The study utilized a combination of publicly available and officially sourced datasets:

  • Satellite Imagery: Landsat, Sentinel, and SPOT imagery were used for LCLU classification and change detection, with varying resolutions (e.g., 30m, 10m).
  • CORINE Land Cover (CLC) Data: Freely available datasets from the European Environment Agency and Copernicus Land Monitoring Service were used for the Romanian case study, covering periods from 1990 to 2018.
  • National Statistical Data: Official statistical yearbooks, population censuses, and data from national responsible agencies were used for Algeria and Vietnam, providing information on population, urbanization, tourism, and economic indicators.
  • GIS Data: Administrative boundaries and other relevant geospatial data were utilized.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • "Derogatory Planning" as a Universal Driver: A key finding across all three case studies is the significant role of "derogatory planning" – the practice of granting exceptions or bypassing regulations for profit – in driving coastal degradation. This highlights a systemic issue where short-term economic gains override long-term sustainability.
  • Socioeconomic and Political Nexus: The study emphasizes that land-use changes are not solely driven by environmental factors but are deeply intertwined with socioeconomic aspirations and political decisions, often leading to conflicts between national policies and local interests.
  • Tourism as a Double-Edged Sword: While tourism is a significant economic driver, its rapid and often unplanned development can lead to substantial environmental degradation, including habitat loss and increased infrastructure pressure.
  • Urban Sprawl's Persistent Threat: Regardless of the continent, urban sprawl remains a primary force reshaping coastal landscapes, often consuming natural areas and agricultural land.
  • Data Availability as a Major Hurdle: The study encountered significant limitations due to the uneven availability and quality of data, particularly in Algeria and Romania, underscoring the need for better data management and accessibility for effective coastal management.

Key Results

  • Increased Anthropogenic Pressure: The study confirmed a global increase in urbanization and tourism pressure on coastal areas across the three continents.
  • Romania: Urbanization was identified as a major transitional dynamic, strongly correlated with population and density. While tourism also played a role, building permits for residential units significantly outnumbered those for tourism, suggesting urban development was a stronger driver.
  • Vietnam: Urbanization and tourism were identified as key drivers of coastal change, with rapid economic development and population growth leading to significant land-use transformations. The study noted a disconnect between policies aimed at economic growth and those addressing environmental protection.
  • Algeria: Urbanization and agricultural development were the primary causes of land-use change, leading to significant deforestation. The study highlighted the impact of demographic explosion and rural exodus on coastal areas.
  • Correlation Findings: In Romania, a significant correlation was found between urbanization rate and building permits issued, and a marginally significant correlation with existing tourism capacity.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Methodological Heterogeneity: The authors acknowledge that applying the exact same methodology across all three case studies was not possible due to data availability and national contexts. This heterogeneity, however, also allowed for a broader exploration of mechanisms.
  • Data Availability and Quality: Significant limitations were encountered due to the availability and quality of data, especially in Algeria and Romania. The study stresses the need for more accessible and trustworthy data from official sources.
  • Resolution Differences: While efforts were made to harmonize data, differences in satellite image resolutions could have introduced some level of uncertainty.
  • Future Research Directions:
    • Long-Term Diachronic Analysis: Conducting deeper analyses over longer time scales to understand historical trends.
  • Focus on Erosion and Accretion: Investigating the direct relationship between urbanization and coastal erosion/accretion.
  • Forest and Agricultural Area Dynamics: Expanding the analysis to include changes in forest and agricultural areas as potential precursors to urbanization.
  • Integrated Coastal Zone Management: Developing and implementing integrated, participatory governance models that consider the complex interactions between land and sea.
  • Evolutionary Governance Theory: Further validating and applying this theory to coastal management, emphasizing co-evolution and adaptive policies.
  • International Cooperation: Establishing networks for managers and researchers to share best practices and develop coordinated land-use planning and protection strategies.
  • Climate Change Resilience: Incorporating climate change adaptation and resilience into planning strategies.

Summary updated

Abstract

The importance of studying coastal areas is justified by their resources, ecosystem services, and key role played in socio-economic development. Coastal landscapes are subject to increasing demands and pressures, requiring in-depth analyses for finding appropriate tools or policies for a sustainable landscape management. The present study addresses this issue globally, based on case studies from three continents: Romania (Europe), Algeria (Africa), and Vietnam (Asia), focusing on the anthropogenic pressure resulting from land use/land cover change or urban sprawl, taking into account the role of socioeconomic and political factors. The methodology consisted of producing maps and computing and analyzing indicators, correlating geospatial and socio-economic data in a synergistic manner to explore the changes of landscapes, and identify the specific driving forces. The findings show that the pressure of urbanization and tourism on coastal areas increased, while the drivers and impacts vary. Urbanization is due to derogatory planning in Romania and Algeria, and different national and local goals in Vietnam. The two drivers determine local exemptions from the national regulations, made for profit. In addition to the need for developing and enforcing policies for stopping the degradation and restoring the ecosystems, the findings underline the importance of international cooperation in policy development.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{petrisor2020degradation,
  author = {Alexandru-Ionuţ Petrişor and Walid Hamma and Huu Duy Nguyen and Giovanni Randazzo and Anselme Muzirafuti and Mari-Isabella Stan and Van Truong Tran and Roxana Aştefănoaiei and Quang‐Thanh Bui and Dragoş-Florian Vintilă and Quang Hải Trương and Cristina Lixăndroiu and Diana-Doina Ţenea and Igor Sîrodoev and Ioan Ianoş},
  title = {{Degradation of Coastlines under the Pressure of Urbanization and Tourism: Evidence on the Change of Land Systems from Europe, Asia and Africa}},
  booktitle = {Land},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.3390/land9080275},
}
Figure