TL;DR
This study reveals a significant degradation of the "Biocoenosis of the Infralittoral Algae" in eastern Sicily, marked by the disappearance of the habitat-forming Cystoseira brachycarpa and a substantial loss of species richness. This ecological shift, observed over two years and compared to historical data, highlights a concerning trend of habitat simplification in the Mediterranean, potentially driven by increased grazing pressure from sea urchins.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
The Mediterranean Sea is facing increasing anthropogenic pressures, leading to concerns about the health and stability of its marine ecosystems. Specifically, the "Biocoenosis of the Infralittoral Algae" (IA), a crucial habitat characterized by the presence of Cystoseira species, is known to be sensitive to environmental changes. These Cystoseira communities are vital for supporting high biodiversity by creating complex three-dimensional structures that provide ecological niches. However, recent reports suggest a widespread decline of these important algal forests across the Mediterranean. This paper addresses the critical question of whether this degradation is occurring in a historically well-preserved area of eastern Sicily, the Ciclopi Islands Marine Protected Area (CIMPA), and aims to quantify the extent of this change by comparing current community structure with historical data and analyzing associated fauna.
Methods
The researchers employed a multiproxy approach to assess the algal community and its associated fauna. They collected scraped samples (40x40 cm) from two stations in the upper infralittoral zone (5m depth) over a two-year period (2015-2016), covering three seasons (late spring, autumn, and winter). This allowed for the identification of algae, as well as associated protists and animal organisms, including foraminifers, serpulids, molluscs, bryozoans, and ostracods.
Key methodological aspects include:
- Sampling: Scuba diving was used for sample collection.
- Algal and Macrofauna Analysis: Samples were scraped for analysis of plants and associated macrofauna.
- Microorganism Analysis: A mobile sorbon was used to collect samples for analyzing slightly attached microorganisms (protists and ostracods).
- Preservation: Samples were preserved in 70% seawater-ethyl alcohol.
- Identification: Standardized laboratory methods were used for species identification, with voucher algal specimens deposited in a herbarium.
- Statistical Analysis: Multivariate statistical analyses, including hierarchical cluster analysis and Non-Metric Multi-Dimensional Scaling (MDS), were performed using PRIMER software to assess community structure and differences between stations and seasons. The Shannon-Weaver diversity index was also calculated.
- Historical Comparison: Present data was compared with historical records from the area, particularly from Pizzuto (1999).
Datasets
The study utilized two primary sources of data:
- Field Samples (2015-2016): Samples collected from two specific stations (Punta Aguzza - CPA, and Santa Maria La Scala - SM) along the eastern coast of Sicily. These samples formed the basis for the current community assessment.
- Historical Data: Previous studies, notably by Pizzuto (1999), provided baseline data on the algal community composition and the presence of Cystoseira brachycarpa in the same area. This historical data was crucial for evaluating changes over time.
No new benchmark datasets were introduced in this paper.
Key Insights and Ideas
- The Disappearance of a Keystone Species: The most striking finding is the complete absence of Cystoseira brachycarpa, a dominant habitat-forming alga that was historically abundant in the area until the late 1990s. This suggests a significant ecological shift.
- Habitat Simplification: The loss of Cystoseira has led to the dominance of morphologically simpler algae like Halopteris scoparia, Padina pavonica, and Dictyota dichotoma. This creates a less complex habitat structure.
- Reduced Biodiversity: The simplification of the algal community has resulted in a considerable loss of species richness across various taxonomic groups, including algae, foraminifers, serpulids, molluscs, bryozoans, and ostracods.
- Spatial Differentiation, Not Seasonal: While the two sampling stations (inside and outside the Marine Protected Area) showed clear differences in community composition, no distinct seasonal trends were observed in the overall community structure.
- Potential Driver: Echinoid Grazing: The observed degradation and habitat homogenization are hypothesized to be linked to an increase in sea urchin populations and their intense grazing activity, a phenomenon noted in other Mediterranean areas.
- Serpulids as Potential Indicators: The study suggests that serpulid diversity might show seasonal patterns, potentially linked to the availability of suitable algal substrata, offering a potential avenue for future monitoring.
Key Results
- Species Richness Decline: The total number of algal species identified decreased from 168 in historical records (Pizzuto, 1999) to 85 in the current study. Specifically, the CPA station (inside the MPA) saw a drop from 148 to 69 species, and the SM station (outside the MPA) from 118 to 61 species.
- Algal Community Shift: The dominant community now consists of Halopteris scoparia, Padina pavonica, Dictyota dichotoma, Ellisolandia elongata, and encrusting coralline algae, replacing the Cystoseira brachycarpa dominated community.
- Foraminifera and Ostracods More Abundant in CPA: These groups showed higher abundance in the Punta Aguzza (CPA) station compared to Santa Maria La Scala (SM).
- Bryozoans and Molluscs More Abundant in SM: Conversely, bryozoans and molluscs were more abundant in the Santa Maria La Scala (SM) station.
- Community Separation: Cluster and MDS analyses clearly separated the CPA and SM stations, with a Bray-Curtis similarity level slightly exceeding 40%.
- Serpulid Seasonal Pattern: Serpulid fauna exhibited a clearer seasonal pattern, with samples showing almost complete seasonal matching at 60-70% BC similarity.
Limitations and Future Work
- Permanent Disappearance? The authors acknowledge that it is not yet possible to definitively state whether the disappearance of Cystoseira brachycarpa is permanent. Further long-term studies are needed to understand the ongoing processes and trends.
- Scantiness of Data: For some taxonomic groups, particularly bryozoans and serpulids associated with algal turfs, available data is very limited, making direct comparisons challenging.
- Monitoring Needs: The study emphasizes the need for continued monitoring of local communities, including associated organisms, over longer time intervals to provide an important snapshot for future comparisons and to understand the long-term ecological trajectory.
- Investigating Drivers: While sea urchin grazing is proposed as a primary driver, further research is needed to confirm this and to investigate other potential contributing factors such as water turbidity and sediment deposition.
- Broader Spatial Scale: While this study provides valuable data for the Ciclopi Islands area, extending similar investigations to other Mediterranean regions would help to assess the broader scale of Cystoseira degradation.
Summary updated