Abstract
A numerical solution of a model for the hydraulic recoil brake in the artillery weapon is presented. A program solution and an algorithm for the identification of dynamic recoil brake parameters and the recoil process simulation have been worked out in the procedure of numerical modeling. The analysis of the influence of hydraulic brake input parameters on the level of estimated parameters has been performed as well as the optimization of estimated parameters to according to defined limitations.
Introduction
When a heavy artillery piece fires, the backward momentum generated by the projectile and propellant gases—the recoil—is immense. To prevent the weapon from damaging its carriage (the lafet) or becoming unstable, engineers utilize hydraulic recoil brakes. The design of these systems involves a complex trade-off between minimizing recoil distance for compact design, reducing peak forces to protect structural integrity, and maintaining internal fluid pressure within safe limits.
Traditionally, finding the optimal balance required expensive and time-consuming trial-and-error firing tests. This research proposes a high-fidelity numerical model to predict performance and optimize parameters before physical testing, significantly streamlining the design process.
Methodology and Simulation
The researchers developed a mathematical model based on non-linear differential equations of motion for the recoiling parts. This system, grounded in Newton’s second law, accounts for the impulse of propellant gases, hydraulic resistance, spring/pneumatic returner forces, and friction.
The model was implemented in MATLAB using Simulink, employing a 5th-order Runge-Kutta method to solve the non-linear equations. This digital environment allows for the virtual testing of various internal components, such as control rings or counter-recoil valves, to immediately observe their impact on weapon stability.
To validate the model, experimental data from reference weapons—the PT 100, TON 100, and TH 152—were used to establish baseline performance metrics. The H-122 mm howitzer served as the primary test case for the optimization routine, comparing simulated pressure-time and velocity-time curves against real-world firing data.
Sensitivity Analysis and Optimization
A critical stage of the research involved identifying the "vital few" parameters among 33 potential variables categorized into construction, internal ballistics, and hydraulics. Through a screening process, the researchers determined which parameters most significantly influenced performance.
The analysis revealed that the flow area of the orifices ($a(x)$), the pressure of propellant gases ($p(t)$), and specific hydraulic resistance coefficients dominate the system's behavior. Because braking force depends on the square of the velocity and changing valve geometry, achieving "ideal" constant-force braking is practically impossible, necessitating this nuanced numerical approach.
Key Results
The optimization of the H-122 mm howitzer yielded significant improvements:
- Recoil Reduction: The simulation successfully reduced the recoil distance from a nominal 910 mm to 762 mm, representing a ~20% improvement in compactness.
- Safety and Accuracy: This was achieved while maintaining a maximum internal pressure limit of 15 MPa. The simulated curves for pressure and velocity showed high correlation with experimental firing data, particularly during the critical initial and middle phases of recoil.
Conclusion
While the model proved highly effective, limitations remain. Computational constraints prevented a full factorial experiment, requiring a more targeted sensitivity analysis. Additionally, the linearization of mechanical and hydraulic friction into a constant force and slight discrepancies at the end-of-stroke suggest areas for future refinement. Nevertheless, this framework provides a robust tool for the virtual design and optimization of artillery recoil systems.
Summary updated