Deficient Adipogenesis of Scleroderma Patient and Healthy African American Monocytes

Rebecca Lee, Charles Reese, Gustavo Carmen-Lopez, Beth Perry, Michael Bonner, Marina Zemskova, Carole L. Wilson, Kristi L. Helke, Richard M. Silver, Stanley Hoffman, Elena TourkinaFrontiers in Pharmacology 2017 · DOI

TL;DR

This study reveals that monocytes from scleroderma (SSc) patients and healthy African Americans (AA) have a reduced ability to differentiate into fat cells (adipocytes), unlike monocytes from healthy Caucasians (C). This deficiency is linked to lower levels of the proteins caveolin-1 and PPARγ, which are crucial for maintaining a balance between fibrotic and adipogenic differentiation, and this imbalance contributes to the characteristic skin fibrosis and fat loss seen in SSc.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Scleroderma (SSc) is an autoimmune disease characterized by excessive fibrosis (scarring) in the skin and internal organs. While skin fibrosis is well-known, a less recognized feature of SSc is the loss of subcutaneous adipose tissue. Furthermore, African Americans (AA) have a higher risk of developing SSc and often experience more severe disease. This paper investigates the underlying cellular mechanisms that might explain these observations, specifically focusing on how monocytes, a type of immune cell, differentiate into either fibrotic cells or fat cells. The researchers aim to understand why SSc patients and healthy AA individuals might have an altered balance in this differentiation process, leading to fibrosis and fat loss.

Methods

The study employed a multi-pronged approach using both in vitro and in vivo models:

  • Monocyte Isolation and Differentiation: Peripheral blood mononuclear cells (PBMCs) were isolated from healthy Caucasian (C), healthy African American (AA), and SSc patients. These PBMCs were then cultured and induced to differentiate into adipocyte-like cells (ALCs) using a specific medium (Adipocyte Induction Medium - AIM). To distinguish ALCs from macrophages, which can also accumulate lipids, researchers used flow cytometry and immunocytochemistry with specific markers.
  • Protein Analysis: Western blotting and immunocytochemistry were used to assess the levels of key proteins, namely caveolin-1 and peroxisome proliferator-activated receptor gamma (PPARγ), in differentiated cells and tissue samples.
  • Pharmacological Intervention: The caveolin-1 scaffolding domain peptide (CSD), a surrogate for caveolin-1, and a PPARγ agonist (TRO) were used to investigate their effects on monocyte differentiation and protein expression.
  • Animal Models: A mouse model was used where skin fibrosis and adipose tissue loss were induced by bleomycin treatment. This model was used to study the in vivo roles of caveolin-1 and PPARγ in fibrosis and adipogenesis.
  • Cell Tracing: EGFP-labeled monocytes were injected into mice to track their contribution to the adipose tissue layer, particularly after bleomycin-induced injury.
  • Histological Analysis: Tissue sections from both human patients and mice were stained to visualize cellular structures, protein localization, and fibrosis (Masson's Trichrome staining).

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study primarily uses primary human blood samples and established mouse models.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Monocyte Differentiation Imbalance: The core idea is that monocytes have a dual potential: to become fibrotic cells or adipocytes. In SSc and healthy AA individuals, this balance is skewed towards fibrosis, at the expense of adipogenesis.
  • Caveolin-1 and PPARγ as Key Regulators: The study strongly implicates caveolin-1 and PPARγ as critical regulators of this balance. Low levels of these proteins in SSc and AA monocytes lead to impaired adipogenesis and enhanced fibrogenesis.
  • CSD as a Therapeutic Lever: The CSD peptide, by mimicking caveolin-1's function, can reverse the impaired adipogenesis and potentially influence the fibrotic process, suggesting a therapeutic avenue.
  • Monocytes as Adipocyte Precursors: The in vivo experiments provide compelling evidence that monocytes can directly differentiate into adipocytes, contributing to the maintenance and repair of adipose tissue. This challenges previous assumptions about the origin of adipocytes in certain contexts.
  • Shared Deficiencies: The study highlights that the molecular deficiencies (low caveolin-1 and PPARγ) observed in monocytes are mirrored in the subcutaneous adipose tissue of SSc patients and in the bleomycin-induced mouse model, suggesting a systemic issue.

Key Results

  • Reduced Adipogenesis in vitro: Monocytes from healthy AA and SSc patients showed significantly less differentiation into adipocyte-like cells (ALCs) compared to healthy Caucasian monocytes, as evidenced by Oil Red O staining and FABP4 expression.
  • Caveolin-1 and PPARγ Deficiency: Both caveolin-1 and PPARγ protein levels were found to be significantly lower in monocytes from healthy AA and SSc patients compared to healthy C individuals. This deficiency was also observed in the subcutaneous adipose tissue of SSc patients.
  • CSD Reverses Impaired Adipogenesis: Treatment with CSD restored the adipogenic potential of AA and SSc monocytes in vitro and promoted adipogenesis in mice treated with bleomycin.
  • Bleomycin Induces Fibrosis and Adipose Loss in Mice: Mice treated with bleomycin exhibited increased dermal thickness (fibrosis) and a significant reduction in subcutaneous adipose tissue, mirroring features of SSc. Adipocytes in these mice showed decreased caveolin-1 and PPARγ.
  • Monocytes Contribute to Adipose Tissue Repair: In mice treated with bleomycin, injected EGFP+ monocytes were found to incorporate into the adipose layer and express FABP4, indicating their differentiation into adipocytes and contribution to tissue repair.

Limitations and Future Work

  • TGFβ's Complex Role: While TGFβ is known to influence fibrosis, its effect on PPARγ levels in monocytes was found to be complex and not consistently inhibitory, suggesting further investigation is needed.
  • Mechanisms of Caveolin-1/PPARγ Regulation: The paper suggests that caveolin-1 and PPARγ can regulate each other's expression and activation. However, the precise molecular mechanisms underlying this interplay require further elucidation.
  • Therapeutic Translation: While CSD shows promise, its translation into clinical therapies for SSc would require extensive further research, including efficacy and safety studies.
  • Discrepancies with Previous Studies: The authors acknowledge potential discrepancies with previous findings regarding the origin of adipocytes from bone marrow-derived cells, attributing them to differences in experimental models and methodologies. Further studies are needed to fully reconcile these findings.
  • Role of Other Cell Types: While the focus is on monocytes, the complex interplay of various cell types in fibrotic diseases warrants further investigation.

Summary updated

Abstract

Monocytes from systemic sclerosis (SSc, scleroderma) patients and healthy African Americans (AA) are deficient in the regulatory protein caveolin-1 leading to enhanced migration toward chemokines and fibrogenic differentiation. While dermal fibrosis is the hallmark of SSc, loss of subcutaneous adipose tissue is a lesser-known feature. To better understand the etiology of SSc and the predisposition of AA to SSc, we studied the adipogenic potential of SSc and healthy AA monocytes. The ability of SSc and healthy AA monocytes to differentiate into adipocyte-like cells (ALC) is inhibited compared to healthy Caucasian (C) monocytes. We validated that monocyte-derived ALCs are distinct from macrophages by flow cytometry and immunocytochemistry. Like their enhanced fibrogenic differentiation, their inhibited adipogenic differentiation is reversed by the caveolin-1 scaffolding domain peptide (CSD, a surrogate for caveolin-1). The altered differentiation of SSc and healthy AA monocytes is additionally regulated by peroxisome proliferator-activated receptor γ (PPARγ) which is also present at reduced levels in these cells. <i>In vivo</i> studies further support the importance of caveolin-1 and PPARγ in fibrogenesis and adipogenesis. In SSc patients, healthy AA, and mice treated systemically with bleomycin, adipocytes lose caveolin-1 and PPARγ and the subcutaneous adipose layer is diminished. CSD treatment of these mice leads to a reappearance of the caveolin-1+/PPARγ+/FABP4+ subcutaneous adipose layer. Moreover, many of these adipocytes are CD45+, suggesting they are monocyte derived. Tracing experiments with injected EGFP+ monocytes confirm that monocytes contribute to the repair of the adipose layer when it is damaged by bleomycin treatment. Our observations strongly suggest that caveolin-1 and PPARγ work together to maintain a balance between the fibrogenic and adipogenic differentiation of monocytes, that this balance is altered in SSc and in healthy AA, and that monocytes make a major contribution to the repair of the adipose layer.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{lee2017deficient,
  author = {Rebecca Lee and Charles Reese and Gustavo Carmen-Lopez and Beth Perry and Michael Bonner and Marina Zemskova and Carole L. Wilson and Kristi L. Helke and Richard M. Silver and Stanley Hoffman and Elena Tourkina},
  title = {{Deficient Adipogenesis of Scleroderma Patient and Healthy African American Monocytes}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Pharmacology},
  year = {2017},
  doi = {10.3389/fphar.2017.00174},
}
Figure