Deficiency of Wdr60 and Wdr34 cause distinct neural tube malformation phenotypes in early embryos

Yan Lu, Hailing Yin, Yiwei Mi, Yu Wu, Yufang ZhengFrontiers in Cell and Developmental Biology 2023 · DOI

This study, published in Frontiers in Cell and Developmental Biology, provides the first characterization of a Wdr60-deficient mouse model and reveals that while WDR60 and WDR34 are partners in the same molecular motor, their roles in embryonic development are surprisingly distinct. The researchers demonstrate that Wdr34 is uniquely critical for neural tube closure via the Planar Cell Polarity (PCP) pathway, whereas both proteins are essential for Sonic Hedgehog (SHH) signaling and proper tissue patterning.

TL;DR

Researchers have developed the first mouse model for Wdr60 deficiency, revealing that it and its partner Wdr34—both parts of the ciliary dynein-2 motor—play overlapping but distinct roles in embryo development. While both are needed for Sonic Hedgehog signaling, only Wdr34 is essential for the Planar Cell Polarity (PCP) pathway required to physically close the neural tube.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Primary cilia are hair-like "antennas" on the surface of cells that act as hubs for essential signaling pathways, most notably Sonic Hedgehog (SHH). To function, these antennas require a transport system: the Intraflagellar Transport (IFT) system. Motor proteins act as the "trains" on these tracks, with dynein-2 handling the "retrograde" trip (from the tip of the cilium back to the base).

The dynein-2 motor relies on a heterodimer of two proteins: WDR60 and WDR34. Mutations in these genes cause severe human birth defects known as ciliopathies, such as Jeune syndrome. While Wdr34 deficiency had been studied in mice, a Wdr60 mouse model was missing from the literature. This paper fills that gap, asking whether these two "partners" in the same motor complex are truly interchangeable or if they have specialized functions during the critical window of neural tube development.

Methods

The authors utilized the piggyBac (PB) transposon system to disrupt the Wdr60 and Wdr34 genes in mice, creating Wdr60<sup>PB/PB</sup> and Wdr34<sup>PB/PB</sup> strains. This method allows for efficient gene disruption by inserting a DNA fragment into the genome.

To analyze the resulting phenotypes, the team employed a multi-omic and biochemical approach:

  • RNA-sequencing (RNAseq) and qRT-PCR: To profile gene expression changes in the head tissues of mutant embryos.
  • Immunofluorescence (IF): To visualize protein localization and tissue patterning (e.g., markers like NKX6.1 and PAX6).
  • Co-Immunoprecipitation (Co-IP) and Mass Spectrometry: To identify which other proteins WDR60 and WDR34 physically interact with, specifically looking at the IFT machinery.

Datasets

The study generated and utilized several key datasets:

  • Transcriptomic Data: RNAseq data from E10.5 mouse head tissues, deposited in the NCBI BioProject database (Accession: PRJNA900366).
  • Proteomic Data: Mass spectrometry data identifying proteins associated with WDR60 (Supplementary Table S1).
  • Reference Genome: Mouse genome data from Ensemble 109.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Partners, Not Clones: Despite being part of the same dynein-2 motor, the loss of these proteins leads to different "times of death." Wdr34 mutants die earlier (E10.5–E11.5) and more severely than Wdr60 mutants (E13.5–E14.5).
  • The PCP Distinction: The most striking finding is that Wdr34 deficiency leads to a high rate of open neural tubes (cranial and caudal), a defect linked to the Planar Cell Polarity (PCP) pathway. Wdr60 mutants, conversely, usually have closed neural tubes but suffer from patterning defects like holoprosencephaly.
  • The IFT140 Connection: The researchers found a biochemical reason for this difference: WDR34 interacts with IFT140, a protein known to regulate the PCP pathway, while WDR60 does not. This suggests WDR34 has a specialized role in transporting or stabilizing PCP components that WDR60 cannot fulfill.
  • SHH is a Shared Requirement: Both mutants showed significant downregulation of SHH signaling targets (Gli1, Ptch1, Ptch2), confirming that the entire dynein-2 motor complex is vital for the "antenna" to receive Hedgehog signals correctly.

Key Results

  • Survival: Wdr60 homozygotes die around E13.5–E14.5; Wdr34 homozygotes die earlier, around E10.5–E11.5.
  • Phenotypes:
    • Wdr60<sup>PB/PB</sup>: 92.6% showed abnormal head development (holoprosencephaly), 33.3% had heart edema, and 25% showed polydactyly (extra digits).
  • Wdr34<sup>PB/PB</sup>: 91.7% showed abnormal head development, but crucially, 66.7% had open caudal neural tubes and 25% had open heads (exencephaly).
  • Molecular Signaling: In Wdr34 mutants, PCP components like Celsr1 and c-Jun were significantly downregulated. In contrast, these were largely unaffected in Wdr60 mutants.
  • Protein Interaction: Co-IP confirmed that while both proteins interact with IFT88 (part of the IFT-B complex), only WDR34 pulls down IFT140 (part of the IFT-A complex).

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge that while they have linked WDR34 to the PCP pathway via IFT140, the exact mechanism of how this interaction facilitates neural tube closure remains to be fully mapped in vivo.

Future research could explore whether these proteins have non-ciliary roles, as some IFT proteins are known to function in the cytoplasm or at the midbody during cell division. Additionally, investigating why Wdr60 deficiency leads to later embryonic lethality compared to Wdr34 could reveal more about the temporal requirements of ciliary transport during organogenesis.

Summary updated

Abstract

Cilia are specialized organelles that extend from plasma membrane, functioning as antennas for signal transduction and are involved in embryonic morphogenesis. Dysfunction of cilia lead to many developmental defects, including neural tube defects (NTDs). Heterodimer <i>WDR60</i>-<i>WDR34</i> (WD repeat domain 60 and 34) are intermediate chains of motor protein dynein-2, which play important roles in ciliary retrograde transport. It has been reported that disruption of <i>Wdr34</i> in mouse model results in NTDs and defects of Sonic Hedgehog (SHH) signaling. However, no <i>Wdr60</i> deficiency mouse model has been reported yet. In this study, piggyBac (PB) transposon is used to interfere <i>Wdr60</i> and <i>Wdr34</i> expression respectively to establish <i>Wdr60</i> <sup><i>PB/PB</i></sup> and <i>Wdr34</i> <sup><i>PB/PB</i></sup> mouse models. We found that the expression of <i>Wdr60</i> or <i>Wdr34</i> is significantly decreased in the homozygote mice. <i>Wdr60</i> homozygote mice die around E13.5 to E14.5, while <i>Wdr34</i> homozygote mice die around E10.5 to E11.5. <i>WDR60</i> is highly expressed in the head region at E10.5 and <i>Wdr60</i> <sup><i>PB/PB</i></sup> embryos have head malformation. RNAseq and qRT-PCR experiments revealed that Sonic Hedgehog signaling is also downregulated in <i>Wdr60</i> <sup><i>PB/PB</i></sup> head tissue, demonstrating that WDR60 is also required for promoting SHH signaling. Further experiments on mouse embryos also revealed that the expression levels of planar cell polarity (PCP) components such as CELSR1 and downstream signal molecule c-Jun were downregulated in <i>WDR34</i> homozygotes compared to wildtype littermates. Coincidently, we observed much higher ratio of open cranial and caudal neural tube in <i>Wdr34</i> <sup><i>PB/PB</i></sup> mice. CO-IP experiment showed that <i>WDR60</i> and <i>WDR34</i> both interact with IFT88, but only <i>WDR34</i> interacts with IFT140. Taken together, <i>WDR60</i> and <i>WDR34</i> play overlapped and distinct functions in modulating neural tube development.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{lu2023deficiency,
  author = {Yan Lu and Hailing Yin and Yiwei Mi and Yu Wu and Yufang Zheng},
  title = {{Deficiency of Wdr60 and Wdr34 cause distinct neural tube malformation phenotypes in early embryos}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Cell and Developmental Biology},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.3389/fcell.2023.1084245},
}
Figure