Defect Analysis of Roll-to-Roll SAIL Manufactured Flexible Display Backplanes

Carl Taussig, Richard Elder, Warren B. Jackson, Albert Jeans, Mehrban Jam, E.r. Holland, Hao Luo, John G. Maltabes, Craig Perlov, Steven Trovinger2011 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper details the challenges and solutions for defect analysis in the world's first roll-to-roll (R2R) manufactured flexible display backplanes, specifically the Self-Aligned Imprint Lithography (SAIL) process. The authors present their developed tools and processes for identifying and mitigating defects, crucial for scaling up production for applications like wrist-worn displays for the U.S. Army.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The fabrication of flexible displays using roll-to-roll (R2R) manufacturing offers a path to lower costs and new form factors, but scaling up from research to pre-production presents significant challenges, particularly in defect analysis and mitigation. Traditional methods for analyzing defects in rigid display manufacturing are not directly applicable to flexible substrates that are not bonded to a carrier. This paper addresses the need for robust defect detection and elimination strategies specifically for the R2R SAIL process, which is used to create active matrix displays on flexible polyimide films. The primary focus is on identifying and understanding defects that arise during the SAIL process, which is critical for achieving the necessary yields for commercialization, such as for a wrist-worn solar-powered display for the U.S. Army.

Methods

The paper focuses on the Self-Aligned Imprint Lithography (SAIL) process, a novel R2R technique for fabricating flexible display backplanes. The core of the SAIL process involves a single imprint step using a 3D molded mask to define multiple patterns through alternating etching of the mask and the thin film stack. This approach ensures perfect alignment regardless of substrate distortion, a key advantage for R2R manufacturing.

To address defect analysis, the authors developed:

  • An electrical tester: This tester uses flexible circuit contacts to connect to the backplane pads, enabling rapid testing (under 10 seconds per data/gate line) for opens or shorts. It utilizes alignment pins for accurate positioning and a pressure ring for consistent contact.
  • A R2R optical inspection tool: This system allows for in-line inspection of the web at intermediate processing stages without cutting samples. It employs a microscope mounted on a precision roller that can scan in the cross-web direction, enabling the study of defect evolution throughout the manufacturing process.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • SAIL's unique alignment advantage: The SAIL process's inherent alignment mechanism, where patterns are transferred through alternating etching of the mask and thin film stack, is crucial for maintaining registration on flexible substrates that can distort during R2R processing.
  • The dual nature of defects: Defects in the SAIL process fall into two main categories: electrical defects within the thin films of the Thin Film Transistor (TFT) and defects related to the imprint lithography process itself.
  • The importance of in-line inspection: The development of a R2R optical inspection tool is vital because cutting samples from the flexible web can disrupt further processing and prevent the study of defect evolution.
  • "Tenting defects" as a major imprint challenge: A significant class of defects, termed "tenting defects," arise when particles or surface irregularities cause the imprint stamp to locally deflect, leading to an excess of photopolymer and potential shorts in the device layers.
  • Shunts are a critical electrical defect: Shunts, low-resistance paths between top and bottom metal layers in the TFT stack, are a major concern as they can lead to pixel, row, or column loss.

Key Results

  • The paper demonstrates the successful fabrication of active matrix displays using the R2R SAIL process.
  • Transfer curves for 180°C amorphous silicon TFTs produced with the R2R SAIL process are presented, showing scaling behavior for channel lengths down to 1µm.
  • The developed electrical tester can measure data and gate lines for opens or shorts in less than 10 seconds.
  • The R2R optical inspection tool allows for real-time monitoring of defect evolution throughout the manufacturing process.
  • Two primary defect types are identified: shunts (electrical) and surface particles/tenting defects (imprint-related).

Limitations and Future Work

  • Limitations: The paper focuses on defect analysis and mitigation for the SAIL process. While it mentions the development of tools, it doesn't provide extensive quantitative data on the reduction of defect rates achieved through these tools. The "tent-pole" defect discussion highlights the potential for masking subsequent etch processes or adhesion to the web, indicating areas where further process control is needed.
  • Future Work: The paper implies that continued refinement of the SAIL process, defect analysis tools, and mitigation strategies will be necessary to achieve the high yields required for mass production of flexible displays. The development of materials that can maintain fidelity for thousands of impressions at high throughputs is also mentioned as an ongoing effort.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@misc{taussig2011defect,
  author = {Carl Taussig and Richard Elder and Warren B. Jackson and Albert Jeans and Mehrban Jam and E.R. Holland and Hao Luo and John G. Maltabes and Craig Perlov and Steven Trovinger},
  title = {{Defect Analysis of Roll-to-Roll SAIL Manufactured Flexible Display Backplanes}},
  year = {2011},
  doi = {10.21236/ada549450},
}
Figure