Deep Synoptic Array Science: A Massive Elliptical Host Among Two Galaxy-cluster Fast Radio Bursts

Kritti Sharma, Jean J. Somalwar, Casey Law, Vikram Ravi, Morgan Catha, Ge Chen, Liam Connor, Jakob T. Faber, Gregg Hallinan, Charlie Harnach, Greg Hellbourg, Rick Hobbs, David O. Hodge, Mark Hodges, James W. Lamb, Paul G. Rasmussen, Myles B. Sherman, Jun Shi, Dana Simard, Reynier Squillace, S. Weinreb, D. P. Woody, Nitika Yadlapalli, The Deep Synoptic Array teamThe Astrophysical Journal 2023

TL;DR

This paper reports the discovery of two Fast Radio Bursts (FRBs) localized within massive galaxy clusters, one in a typical star-forming galaxy and the other in a rare, quiescent elliptical galaxy. This finding expands the known diversity of FRB host environments and provides crucial evidence for multiple progenitor channels, including those involving older stellar populations.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Fast Radio Bursts (FRBs) are enigmatic, powerful radio transients whose origins remain largely unknown. Understanding the environments where FRBs occur is key to unraveling their progenitor mechanisms. Previous studies have primarily identified FRB hosts as star-forming galaxies, suggesting a link to young, energetic phenomena like magnetars. However, the possibility of FRBs originating from older stellar populations or through different evolutionary pathways has been less explored due to a lack of observational evidence. This paper addresses this gap by searching for FRBs in galaxy clusters, environments that contain both young and old stellar populations, and by characterizing the host galaxies of any detected FRBs.

Methods

The researchers utilized the Deep Synoptic Array (DSA-110) for the initial detection of FRBs. Following detection, they employed optical follow-up observations, including imaging with PanSTARRS1 and spectroscopy with Keck-I/LRIS, to precisely localize the FRBs and characterize their host galaxies. A key analytical technique was the use of the Prospector software for spectral energy distribution (SED) fitting. This method allowed for the simultaneous modeling of photometric and spectroscopic data to derive crucial galaxy properties such as stellar mass, star formation rate (SFR), dust attenuation, and star formation history. They also developed a framework for analyzing the delay-time distribution of FRB progenitors, which relates the time of an FRB event to the star formation history of its host galaxy.

Datasets

  • Deep Synoptic Array (DSA-110): Used for the initial detection of the two FRBs.
  • PanSTARRS1 (PS1): Used for i-band imaging of the host galaxies.
  • Keck-I/LRIS: Used for optical spectroscopy of the host galaxies.
  • DESI Legacy Surveys: Provided g, r, and z band imaging data.
  • 2MASS and ALLWISE surveys: Used for photometric analysis.
  • GALEX-SDSS-WISE Legacy Catalog (GSWLC): Used for background galaxy population comparison.
  • PRIMUS dataset: Used for background galaxy population comparison at higher redshifts.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • FRBs in Galaxy Clusters: The detection of FRBs within massive galaxy clusters is a significant step, as these environments offer a diverse range of stellar populations.
  • Quiescent Elliptical Host: The discovery of FRB 20220509G in a quiescent, early-type elliptical galaxy is particularly groundbreaking. This challenges the prevailing notion that FRBs are exclusively linked to active star formation.
  • Multiple Progenitor Channels: The existence of FRBs in both star-forming and quiescent galaxies strongly supports the hypothesis that FRBs have multiple formation channels. This implies that some FRB progenitors must have longer lifetimes and can form from older stellar populations.
  • Wide Delay-Time Distribution: The varied star formation histories of the two host galaxies suggest a broad delay-time distribution for FRB progenitors, meaning FRBs can originate from stars of various ages.
  • Constraining FRB Evolution: The methods developed in this paper for analyzing host galaxy properties and delay-time distributions are crucial for future studies aimed at understanding the evolutionary histories of FRB sources.

Key Results

  • FRB 20220914A: Localized to a star-forming, late-type galaxy in the Abell 2310 galaxy cluster at a redshift of $z=0.1139$. This galaxy exhibits multiple starbursts within the last ~3.5 Gyr.
  • FRB 20220509G: Localized to a quiescent, early-type galaxy in the Abell 2311 galaxy cluster at a redshift of $z=0.0894$. This is identified as the first quiescent, early-type galaxy host for an FRB.
  • Stellar Properties:
    • FRB 20220914A host: Stellar mass $\log M_* = 9.99 \pm 0.09 M_\odot$, SFR $= 1.45 \pm 0.61 M_\odot/\text{yr}$.
  • FRB 20220509G host: Stellar mass $\log M_* = 11.13 \pm 0.02 M_\odot$, SFR $= 0.08 \pm 0.09 M_\odot/\text{yr}$.
  • Delay-Time Distribution Parameters: The study provides kernel density estimates for the delay-time distribution parameters ($\alpha$, $t_{\text{min}}$, $t_{\text{max}}$), though the small sample size limits definitive conclusions.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge that the small sample size of two FRBs makes it difficult to draw strong statistical conclusions about the delay-time distribution parameters. They emphasize that future studies with larger FRB host samples are needed to better constrain these parameters and shed light on the evolutionary histories of FRB sources and their rate evolution with redshift. Additionally, they note that while their analysis framework is robust, potential systematic uncertainties can arise from differences in SED-modeling approaches and the use of various SFR indicators across different studies when comparing with other FRB host populations. Future work will involve a more detailed analysis with a larger FRB sample to address these issues.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract The stellar population environments that are associated with fast radio burst (FRB) sources provide important insights for developing their progenitor theories. We expand the diversity of known FRB host environments by reporting two FRBs in massive galaxy clusters that were discovered by the Deep Synoptic Array (DSA-110) during its commissioning observations. FRB 20220914A has been localized to a star-forming, late-type galaxy at a redshift of 0.1139 with multiple starbursts at lookback times less than ∼3.5 Gyr in the A2310 galaxy cluster. Although the host galaxy of FRB 20220914A is similar to typical FRB hosts, the FRB 20220509G host stands out as a quiescent, early-type galaxy at a redshift of 0.0894 in the A2311 galaxy cluster. The discovery of FRBs in both late- and early-type galaxies adds to the body of evidence that the FRB sources have multiple formation channels. Therefore, even though FRB hosts are typically star-forming, there must exist formation channels that are consistent with old stellar population in galaxies. The varied star formation histories of the two FRB hosts that we report here indicate a wide delay-time distribution of FRB progenitors. Future work in constraining the FRB delay-time distribution, using the methods that we develop herein, will prove crucial in determining the evolutionary histories of FRB sources.
BibTeX
@article{sharma2023deep,
  author = {Kritti Sharma and Jean J. Somalwar and Casey Law and Vikram Ravi and Morgan Catha and Ge Chen and Liam Connor and Jakob T. Faber and Gregg Hallinan and Charlie Harnach and Greg Hellbourg and Rick Hobbs and David O. Hodge and Mark Hodges and James W. Lamb and Paul G. Rasmussen and Myles B. Sherman and Jun Shi and Dana Simard and Reynier Squillace and S. Weinreb and D. P. Woody and Nitika Yadlapalli and The Deep Synoptic Array team},
  title = {{Deep Synoptic Array Science: A Massive Elliptical Host Among Two Galaxy-cluster Fast Radio Bursts}},
  journal = {The Astrophysical Journal},
  year = {2023},
}
Figure