Deep learning of MRI contrast enhancement for mapping cerebral blood volume from single-modal non-contrast scans of aging and Alzheimer's disease brains

Chen Liu, Nanyan Zhu, Haoran Sun, Junhao Zhang, Xinyang Feng, Sabrina Gjerswold-Selleck, Dipika Sikka, Xuemin Zhu, Xueqing Liu, Tal Nuriel, Hongjian Wei, Cheng–Chia Wu, J. Thomas Vaughan, Andrew F. Laine, Frank A. Provenzano, Scott A. Small, Jia GuoFrontiers in Aging Neuroscience 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces "DeepContrast," a deep learning model that can generate contrast-enhancement information, typically requiring gadolinium contrast agents in MRI, from standard, non-contrast T1-weighted MRI scans. This breakthrough allows for the mapping of cerebral blood volume (CBV) with high resolution, enabling the study of brain function in aging and Alzheimer's disease without the need for invasive contrast agents.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Traditional MRI techniques often rely on gadolinium-based contrast agents (GBCAs) to visualize brain structures and map metabolic activity, such as cerebral blood volume (CBV). However, GBCAs have raised safety concerns due to potential gadolinium retention in the body and can be invasive, requiring intravenous administration. Furthermore, non-contrast MRI scans are far more common and readily available in large public datasets like ADNI. The challenge, therefore, is to obtain valuable functional information, like CBV maps, from these widely available non-contrast scans, thereby avoiding the risks and limitations associated with GBCAs.

Methods

The core of this work is the development of "DeepContrast," a deep learning model based on a residual attention U-Net (RAU-Net) architecture. This model is trained to learn the complex, non-linear relationship between standard, non-contrast MRI scans (T1-weighted for humans, T2-weighted for mice) and the corresponding contrast-enhanced scans that reveal CBV.

The training process involved:

  • Cross-species transfer learning: The model was first trained and optimized on mouse brain data, then adapted for human brain data. This approach leverages the inherent similarities in MRI physics and allows for robust initial training.
  • Quantitative ground truth: The model was trained using meticulously acquired, quantitative CBV maps derived from contrast-enhanced MRI scans. Crucially, these maps were generated with a focus on preserving scaling, minimizing inter-subject variability.
  • RAU-Net architecture: This architecture combines the feature extraction capabilities of U-Net with residual blocks for deeper network training and attention gates to focus on relevant image regions, enhancing performance.
  • Voxel-based and ROI-based analyses: The generated synthesized CBV maps were then used in standard neuroimaging analysis pipelines (SPM12, FreeSurfer) to identify functional abnormalities in aging and Alzheimer's disease.

Datasets

  • Healthy Mouse Dataset: A custom dataset of T2-weighted MRI scans from 49 healthy adult C57BL/6 mice, acquired before and after GBCA injection.
  • Healthy Human Dataset: A large dataset of T1-weighted MRI scans from 598 healthy participants (16-94 years old) at Columbia University, acquired before and after GBCA injection. This dataset was used for training and validation of the human model.
  • Human Aging Dataset: A subset of 177 cognitively normal participants (20-72 years old) from the healthy human dataset, used for studying age-related changes.
  • Alzheimer's Disease Neuroimaging Initiative (ADNI) Dataset: Publicly available T1-weighted MRI scans from ADNI were used for studying Alzheimer's disease. This included:
  • A pilot study dataset of 50 cognitively normal (CN) and 50 Alzheimer's disease (AD) participants.
  • A larger utility study dataset of 1,290 CN and 1,290 AD participants (total 2,580).

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Bridging the gap: The most significant insight is that deep learning can effectively learn to infer contrast-enhancement information (and thus CBV) from standard, non-contrast MRI scans. This bypasses the need for invasive contrast agents.
  • Safety and accessibility: By enabling CBV mapping from non-contrast scans, DeepContrast offers a safer and more accessible alternative for studying brain function, particularly for large-scale studies and retrospective analyses of existing datasets.
  • Cross-species validation: The successful transfer of the model from mice to humans demonstrates the robustness of the approach and the underlying principles of MRI physics.
  • Sub-millimeter granularity: The synthesized CBV maps achieve sub-millimeter resolution, providing detailed insights into brain activity.
  • Clinical potential: The framework's ability to be applied retrospectively to existing datasets like ADNI opens up vast possibilities for re-analyzing past research and improving diagnostic capabilities.

Key Results

  • High Similarity: DeepContrast-predicted CBV maps showed high similarity to ground truth GBCA-uptake maps in both mice and humans, as quantified by PSNR, Pearson correlation, Spearman correlation, and SSIM. For example, in healthy humans, the Pearson correlation coefficient was 0.822 ± 0.002.
  • Test-Retest Reliability: DeepContrast-predicted maps exhibited higher test-retest reliability than experimentally acquired GBCA-uptake maps, indicating greater stability.
  • Aging Studies:
    • In aging brains, DeepContrast identified age-related decline in CBV primarily in the dentate gyrus, consistent with prior research.
  • Analysis across the entire cortex showed synthesized CBV maps reflected similar age-related changes as ground truth CBV, with a high concordance (AUC = 0.91).
  • Alzheimer's Disease Studies:
    • In AD brains, DeepContrast localized decline to the transentorhinal cortex, aligning with known AD pathology.
  • For AD classification, models using synthesized CBV alone or in combination with T1W scans significantly outperformed models using only T1W scans. The best model achieved an AUC of 0.942.
  • Class Activation Maps: These maps revealed that the model identified physiologically relevant brain regions (e.g., temporal lobe for structural information, parietal/occipital for functional changes in AD) when making predictions.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Structural Lesion Detection: The current framework is optimized for functional lesions. Detecting structural brain lesions (e.g., tumors, infections) still relies on GBCAs, and future work could extend DeepContrast to these applications.
  • Data Heterogeneity: The study primarily used data from a single site with consistent protocols. Future research should explore the model's performance with more heterogeneous datasets from various cohorts, sites, and scanners.
  • Limited Data: Deep learning models typically require large datasets. While data augmentation can help, future work could focus on enhancing sample size and variance.
  • Transfer Learning: The current CNN model was trained from scratch. Applying transfer learning from pre-trained models could further improve performance.
  • Multi-task Learning: Exploring multi-task learning (e.g., combining CBV synthesis with image reconstruction or segmentation) could lead to more generalized and robust models.
  • Clinical Translation: While promising, the work is presented as a pioneer proof-of-concept. Further validation and refinement are needed for widespread clinical adoption.

Summary updated

Abstract

While MRI contrast agents such as those based on Gadolinium are needed for high-resolution mapping of brain metabolism, these contrast agents require intravenous administration, and there are rising concerns over their safety and invasiveness. Furthermore, non-contrast MRI scans are more commonly performed than those with contrast agents and are readily available for analysis in public databases such as the Alzheimer's Disease Neuroimaging Initiative (ADNI). In this article, we hypothesize that a deep learning model, trained using quantitative steady-state contrast-enhanced structural MRI datasets, in mice and humans, can generate contrast-equivalent information from a single non-contrast MRI scan. The model was first trained, optimized, and validated in mice, and was then transferred and adapted to humans. We observe that the model can substitute for Gadolinium-based contrast agents in approximating cerebral blood volume, a quantitative representation of brain activity, at sub-millimeter granularity. Furthermore, we validate the use of our deep-learned prediction maps to identify functional abnormalities in the aging brain using locally obtained MRI scans, and in the brain of patients with Alzheimer's disease using publicly available MRI scans from ADNI. Since it is derived from a commonly-acquired MRI protocol, this framework has the potential for broad clinical utility and can also be applied retrospectively to research scans across a host of neurological/functional diseases.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{liu2022deep,
  author = {Chen Liu and Nanyan Zhu and Haoran Sun and Junhao Zhang and Xinyang Feng and Sabrina Gjerswold-Selleck and Dipika Sikka and Xuemin Zhu and Xueqing Liu and Tal Nuriel and Hongjian Wei and Cheng–Chia Wu and J. Thomas Vaughan and Andrew F. Laine and Frank A. Provenzano and Scott A. Small and Jia Guo},
  title = {{Deep learning of MRI contrast enhancement for mapping cerebral blood volume from single-modal non-contrast scans of aging and Alzheimer's disease brains}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Aging Neuroscience},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.3389/fnagi.2022.923673},
}
Figure