Deep imaging in scattering media with selective plane illumination microscopy

Adithya Pediredla, Shizheng Zhang, Ben Avants, Fan Ye, Shin Nagayama, Ziying Chen, Caleb Kemere, Jacob T. Robinson, Ashok VeeraraghavanJournal of Biomedical Optics 2016 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper demonstrates that Selective Plane Illumination Microscopy (SPIM) can achieve deep imaging in scattering biological tissues, rivaling the performance of more complex and expensive two-photon microscopy (2PM). By optimizing SPIM's light sheet thickness and sensor noise, researchers can significantly extend its imaging depth, making it a more accessible and practical tool for deep tissue imaging.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Optical imaging in biological tissues is severely limited by light scattering. As light penetrates deeper, it scatters off refractive index variations, blurring images and reducing signal intensity. Two-photon microscopy (2PM) has been a go-to solution for deep imaging because it uses near-infrared light and non-linear excitation at the focal plane, minimizing scattering of the excitation beam. However, 2PM systems are expensive, require high-power pulsed lasers, and are not easily miniaturized. This paper addresses the need for a more accessible, cost-effective deep imaging technique by investigating the theoretical and experimental depth limits of Selective Plane Illumination Microscopy (SPIM). SPIM, a single-photon technique, offers advantages like faster acquisition and reduced photobleaching, but its deep imaging capabilities were not well-characterized.

Methods

The researchers employed a combination of theoretical modeling and experimental validation.

  • Monte Carlo Simulations: They developed a Monte Carlo simulation to model photon transport through scattering media. This model accounts for excitation and emission scattering, as well as the signal-to-noise ratio (SNR) of the detected signal. The simulation helps predict the fluorophore intensity decay with depth and identify factors influencing imaging depth.
  • Theoretical Depth Limit Definition: The depth limit was formally defined as the depth at which the signal power equals the total variance from various noise sources (Poisson noise, sensor noise, etc.), or equivalently, where the SNR falls below unity.
  • Experimental Validation: They experimentally tested SPIM, epifluorescence, confocal, and 2PM microscopes on brain phantoms and fixed brain tissue. This allowed for direct comparison of their imaging depths.
  • Parameter Characterization: The study systematically investigated how key parameters like light sheet thickness and sensor noise level affect SPIM's depth limit.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The experiments utilized prepared brain phantoms and fixed brain tissue samples.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • SPIM's Deep Imaging Potential: The most significant insight is that SPIM, when optimized, can achieve imaging depths comparable to 2PM, significantly outperforming other single-photon techniques like confocal and epifluorescence microscopy.
  • The Importance of Light Sheet Thickness and Sensor Noise: The study reveals that the depth limit of SPIM is critically dependent on the light sheet thickness and the sensor's noise level. Thinner light sheets and lower sensor noise directly translate to deeper imaging capabilities.
  • A Unified Framework for Depth Limits: By defining depth limits in terms of Mean Free Paths (MFPs) and using a signal-to-noise ratio (SNR) based criterion, the researchers provide a standardized way to compare different microscopy techniques across various scattering media.
  • SPIM as a Practical Alternative: The findings position SPIM as a highly attractive alternative to 2PM for deep tissue imaging, especially in scenarios where cost, size, and complexity are constraints.

Key Results

  • SPIM Achieves ~10 MFPs: The study demonstrates that an optimized SPIM system can image up to approximately 10 Mean Free Paths (MFPs) deep in scattering media, which is more than twice as deep as confocal microscopy (3-4 MFPs) and comparable to 2PM (15-22 MFPs).
  • Depth Limit Characterization: The researchers provided plots showing how the depth limit scales with light sheet thickness and sensor noise. For instance, decreasing light sheet thickness leads to an increased depth limit.
  • Experimental Verification: Experimental results closely matched the predictions from the Monte Carlo simulations, validating the theoretical framework and the characterization of depth limits.
  • Comparison Across Modalities: In brain phantoms, SPIM achieved a depth limit of ~10.64 MFPs, while confocal microscopy ranged from 3.97 to 4.47 MFPs, and 2PM exceeded 15.51 MFPs. Similar results were observed for fixed brain tissue.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Assumptions: The study assumes a homogeneous distribution of scattering particles and fluorophores and that the light sheet does not have shadows cast by scattering particles. These ideal conditions might not always hold true in complex biological samples.
  • Interference Effects: While polarization was considered, interference effects were not modeled, though they are deemed negligible at the imaging scales of interest.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest future work focusing on designing SPIM systems that produce even thinner light sheets, potentially using adaptive optics or integrated photonics. They also highlight the potential for developing compact, tabletop SPIM techniques for applications like in-vivo brain imaging on freely moving animals. The findings also motivate further exploration of SPIM for high-speed imaging in scattering media.

Summary updated

Abstract

In most biological tissues, light scattering due to small differences in refractive index limits the depth of optical imaging systems. Two-photon microscopy (2PM), which significantly reduces the scattering of the excitation light, has emerged as the most common method to image deep within scattering biological tissue. This technique, however, requires high-power pulsed lasers that are both expensive and difficult to integrate into compact portable systems. Using a combination of theoretical and experimental techniques, we show that if the excitation path length can be minimized, selective plane illumination microscopy (SPIM) can image nearly as deep as 2PM without the need for a high-powered pulsed laser. Compared to other single-photon imaging techniques like epifluorescence and confocal microscopy, SPIM can image more than twice as deep in scattering media ( ? 10 times the mean scattering length). These results suggest that SPIM has the potential to provide deep imaging in scattering media in situations in which 2PM systems would be too large or costly.
BibTeX
@article{pediredla2016deep,
  author = {Adithya Pediredla and Shizheng Zhang and Ben Avants and Fan Ye and Shin Nagayama and Ziying Chen and Caleb Kemere and Jacob T. Robinson and Ashok Veeraraghavan},
  title = {{Deep imaging in scattering media with selective plane illumination microscopy}},
  journal = {Journal of Biomedical Optics},
  year = {2016},
  doi = {10.1117/1.jbo.21.12.126009},
}
Figure