Decreased overall neuronal activity in a rodent model of impaired consciousness during absence seizures

Cian McCafferty, Benjamin F. Gruenbaum, Renee Tung, Jing‐Jing Li, Peter Salvino, Peter Vincent, Zachary Kratochvil, Jun Hwan Ryu, Aya Khalaf, Kohl Swift, Rashid Akbari, Wasif Islam, Prince Antwi, Emily A. Johnson, Petr Vitkovskiy, James Sampognaro, Isaac G. Freedman, Adam J. Kundishora, Basavaraju G. Sanganahalli, Péter Hermán, Fahmeed Hyder, Vincenzo Crunelli, Antoine Depaulis, Hal BlumenfeldbioRxiv 2021 · DOI

Abstract

Absence seizures are characterized by brief behavioral impairments and an apparent loss of consciousness. While these events are a hallmark of childhood epilepsy, the underlying neuronal mechanisms have remained elusive, partly due to a long-standing discrepancy between human clinical data and animal models. This study utilizes Genetic Absence Epilepsy Rats from Strasbourg (GAERS) to demonstrate that awake, non-anesthetized rodents recapitulate the decreased neuroimaging signals and loss of consciousness seen in humans. By recording individual neuronal activity, researchers found that while seizures involve rhythmic oscillations, the net result is a significant decrease in overall neuronal firing in the cortex and thalamus, driven primarily by a specific population of neurons that remain suppressed throughout the seizure.

Introduction

Absence seizures present a clinical paradox: while electroencephalogram (EEG) recordings show high-amplitude "spike-wave discharges" (SWD), human functional MRI (fMRI) studies typically show a widespread decrease in brain activity during these events. Historically, rodent models—the primary tool for studying epilepsy—seemed to contradict this, showing increased brain activity. However, most of these animal studies were conducted under anesthesia, which significantly alters brain physiology.

This study addresses two critical questions: First, are rodents a valid model for the human experience of absence seizures when studied in an awake state? Second, what are the specific neuronal dynamics that lead to the characteristic "blank stare" and loss of consciousness?

Methods

To bridge the gap between clinical observation and laboratory modeling, the researchers employed a multi-modal approach designed to capture the brain's activity in its natural, awake state.

Awake Neuroimaging and Behavior

To eliminate the confounding effects of anesthesia, rats were habituated over several weeks to the noise and physical restraint of an MRI environment. This allowed for the measurement of blood flow and oxygenation using fMRI and Laser Doppler flowmetry in awake animals. Simultaneously, the researchers tested consciousness using two behavioral paradigms: an Auditory Response Task, where rats licked for a reward in response to a tone, and a Continuous Motivated Licking task, which measured sustained engagement.

Ensemble Electrophysiology

Using high-density silicon probes, the team recorded the electrical activity of hundreds of individual neurons in the somatosensory cortex and the thalamus. By employing "spike sorting" techniques, they were able to track the firing patterns of 168 cortical neurons and 164 thalamic neurons, categorizing them based on their behavior during seizure events.

Key Insights: The "Quiet" Storm

Resolving the Anesthesia Artifact

The study confirmed that the "increased" activity reported in previous rodent research was likely an artifact of anesthesia. In awake GAERS rats, the brain reacts to absence seizures exactly like the human brain: with a widespread decrease in neuroimaging signals. This validates the GAERS model as a high-fidelity representation of human absence epilepsy.

Net Neuronal Silencing

While seizures are often associated with hyper-excitation, the spike-wave discharges of absence epilepsy actually result in a net reduction of neuronal firing. The "spike" component of the EEG represents a brief burst of activity, but it is followed by a "wave" of prolonged inhibition. In the cortex, overall firing rates dropped from a baseline of 3.7 spikes per second to 2.6 spikes per second during the seizure.

The Four Neuronal "Tribes"

Individual neurons do not respond to seizures uniformly. The researchers identified four distinct functional groups:

  1. Sustained Decrease (SD): The largest group (37% of cortical and 46% of thalamic neurons). these cells go quiet during the seizure and are the primary drivers of the overall brain-wide slowdown.
  2. Onset Peak (OP): These neurons show a brief burst of activity at the very start of a seizure before returning to baseline or decreasing.
  3. Sustained Increase (SI): A small minority of neurons that increase their firing rate throughout the event.
  4. No Change (NC): Neurons that maintain their baseline firing regardless of the seizure.

Behavioral Consequences

The impact of these neuronal shifts on consciousness was profound. In the auditory response task, the rats' success rate plummeted from 88.2% during baseline to a mere 0.4% during seizures. Interestingly, in rare cases where a seizure was "spared" (the rat continued to perform the task), the seizures were significantly shorter and exhibited lower EEG power. This mirrors human clinical cases where patients may maintain some level of function during very mild or brief seizures.

Conclusion and Future Directions

The findings suggest that the loss of consciousness during absence seizures is not caused by a "brain-wide firestorm" of activity, but rather by the widespread silencing of excitatory neurons in the cortex and thalamus. The identification of the "Sustained Decrease" group provides a specific cellular target for future therapies.

While the study clarifies which neurons are slowing down, the exact molecular mechanisms—such as specific ion channel dynamics or synaptic inhibition pathways—remain to be fully elucidated. Future research focusing on the frontal cortex and the potential for optogenetic intervention to "reactivate" these silenced neurons could lead to treatments that prevent the loss of consciousness, even if the electrical seizure itself persists.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract Absence seizures are characterized by a brief behavioural impairment including apparent loss of consciousness. Neuronal mechanisms determining the behavioural impairment of absence seizures remain unknown, and their elucidation might highlight therapeutic options for reducing seizure severity. However, recent studies have questioned the similarity of animal spike-wave-discharges (SWD) to human absence seizures both behaviourally and neuronally. Here, we report that Genetic Absence Epilepsy Rats from Strasbourg recapitulate the decreased neuroimaging signals and loss of consciousness characteristic of human absence seizures. Overall neuronal firing is decreased but rhythmic in the somatosensory cortex and thalamus during these seizures. Interestingly, individual neurons in both regions tend to consistently express one of four distinct patterns of seizure-associated activity. These patterns differ in firing rate dynamics and in rhythmicity during seizure. One group of neurons showed a transient initial peak in firing at SWD onset, accounting for the brief initial increase in overall neuronal firing seen in cortex and thalamus. The largest group of neurons in both cortex and thalamus showed sustained decreases in firing during SWD. Other neurons showed either sustained increases or no change in firing. These findings suggest that certain classes of cortical and thalamic neurons may be particularly responsible for the paroxysmal oscillations and consequent loss of consciousness in absence epilepsy.
BibTeX
@misc{mccafferty2021decreased,
  author = {Cian McCafferty and Benjamin F. Gruenbaum and Renee Tung and Jing‐Jing Li and Peter Salvino and Peter Vincent and Zachary Kratochvil and Jun Hwan Ryu and Aya Khalaf and Kohl Swift and Rashid Akbari and Wasif Islam and Prince Antwi and Emily A. Johnson and Petr Vitkovskiy and James Sampognaro and Isaac G. Freedman and Adam J. Kundishora and Basavaraju G. Sanganahalli and Péter Hermán and Fahmeed Hyder and Vincenzo Crunelli and Antoine Depaulis and Hal Blumenfeld},
  title = {{Decreased overall neuronal activity in a rodent model of impaired consciousness during absence seizures}},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.1101/2021.04.20.440390},
  howpublished = {bioRxiv},
}
Figure