Decreased but diverse activity of cortical and thalamic neurons in consciousness-impairing rodent absence seizures

Cian McCafferty, Benjamin F. Gruenbaum, Renee Tung, Jing-Jing Li, Xinyuan Zheng, Peter Salvino, Peter Vincent, Zachary Kratochvil, Jun Hwan Ryu, Aya Khalaf, Kohl Swift, Rashid Akbari, Wasif Islam, Prince Antwi, Emily A. Johnson, Petr Vitkovskiy, James Sampognaro, Isaac G. Freedman, Adam Kundishora, Antoine Depaulis, François David, Vincenzo Crunelli, Basavaraju G. Sanganahalli, Peter Herman, Fahmeed Hyder, Hal BlumenfeldNature Communications 2023 · OpenReview

Abstract

Absence seizures are characterized by brief lapses in consciousness and behavioral arrest. While often colloquially described as "electrical storms," the underlying neuronal mechanisms have remained poorly understood due to discrepancies between human fMRI data and anesthetized animal models. This study utilizes an awake rodent model (GAERS) to demonstrate that absence seizures actually involve an overall decrease in neuronal firing in the cortex and thalamus. By combining fMRI, behavioral testing, and high-density electrophysiology, researchers identified four distinct neuronal firing patterns and discovered that significant brain state changes precede seizure onset by up to 60 seconds. These findings bridge the gap between human clinical data and animal models, offering new insights into the mechanisms of impaired consciousness.

Introduction

Absence seizures present a clinical paradox: while EEG recordings show high-amplitude spike-wave discharges (SWDs), human fMRI studies typically reveal a decrease in cortical blood-oxygen-level-dependent (BOLD) signals. Previous animal models often failed to replicate this decrease, likely due to the confounding effects of anesthesia which can artificially boost neuronal excitability. This study aimed to resolve this discrepancy by investigating neuronal activity in awake, restraint-habituated rats to uncover how individual neurons behave during these lapses in consciousness.

Methods

The researchers employed Genetic Absence Epilepsy Rats from Strasbourg (GAERS), a well-validated model for absence epilepsy. Crucially, all experiments were conducted on awake animals. The study integrated a multi-modal approach:

  • Simultaneous EEG-fMRI: Mapping whole-brain hemodynamics during spontaneous seizures.
  • Behavioral Testing: Utilizing conditioned auditory response and sustained motivated licking tasks to quantify the depth of unresponsiveness.
  • High-Density Electrophysiology: Using multi-contact silicon probes to record single-unit activity in the somatosensory cortex and ventrobasal thalamus.

Key Results

Model Validation and Hemodynamics

The awake GAERS model successfully replicated the human fMRI pattern of absence seizures. During spontaneous SWDs, the cortex exhibited significant BOLD signal decreases (cool colors), while the thalamus showed increases (warm colors). This confirms the model's validity for studying human-like absence epilepsy and suggests that the "quieting" of the cortex is a fundamental feature of the seizure state.

BOLD fMRI signals showing cortical decreases (cool colors) and thalamic increases (warm colors) during seizures.

Behavioral Arrest and the 60-Second Warning

Seizures were associated with a profound loss of responsiveness; auditory response rates plummeted from 88.2% to 0.4%. In the licking task, lick rates dropped precipitously at seizure onset. Interestingly, a linear decline in licking behavior and shifts in EEG frequency power were observed starting 40–60 seconds before the first EEG evidence of a seizure, suggesting a prolonged pre-ictal transition state rather than an instantaneous event.

Behavioral and EEG data showing the dramatic drop in licking behavior (e, f) and increased EEG power (g, h) during seizures.

Neuronal Firing Patterns

Electrophysiological recordings revealed that despite the rhythmic "spikes" in the EEG, the overall firing rate of neurons in both the cortex and thalamus decreased. This is primarily driven by a "trough deficit"—a significant reduction in firing during the "wave" portion of the SWD cycle. The researchers identified four functional groups of neurons:

  1. Sustained Decrease (SD): The largest group (~40-50%), driving the overall drop in activity.
  2. Sustained Increase (SI): A small subset that actually fires more.
  3. Onset Peak (OP): Neurons that surge briefly at the very start of a seizure.
  4. No Change (NC): Neurons whose average firing rate remains stable.

Discussion and Conclusion

The discovery of diverse neuronal responses explains how a net decrease in activity can coexist with rhythmic synchronization. The "thalamic paradox"—increased BOLD signal despite decreased firing—may reflect the high metabolic cost of massive inhibitory synaptic inputs.

This study redefines absence seizures not as simple hyperactivity, but as a complex reorganization of neuronal firing characterized by an overall decrease in activity and increased rhythmicity. Furthermore, the 60-second pre-ictal window identifies a critical period for potential therapeutic interventions that could stop a seizure before consciousness is impaired.

Summary updated

Abstract

Absence seizures are brief episodes of impaired consciousness, behavioral arrest, and unresponsiveness, with yet-unknown neuronal mechanisms. Here we report that an awake female rat model recapitulates the behavioral, electroencephalographic, and cortical functional magnetic resonance imaging characteristics of human absence seizures. Neuronally, seizures feature overall decreased but rhythmic firing of neurons in cortex and thalamus. Individual cortical and thalamic neurons express one of four distinct patterns of seizure-associated activity, one of which causes a transient initial peak in overall firing at seizure onset, and another which drives sustained decreases in overall firing. 40–60 s before seizure onset there begins a decline in low frequency electroencephalographic activity, neuronal firing, and behavior, but an increase in higher frequency electroencephalography and rhythmicity of neuronal firing. Our findings demonstrate that prolonged brain state changes precede consciousness-impairing seizures, and that during seizures distinct functional groups of cortical and thalamic neurons produce an overall transient firing increase followed by a sustained firing decrease, and increased rhythmicity. Absence seizures impair consciousness by an unknown neuronal mechanism. Here, the authors find that a rat absence seizure model’s behavior and hemodynamics recapitulate previously reported characteristics of human absence seizures, and uncover four distinct patterns of neuronal activity in cortex and thalamus during consciousness-impairing seizures.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{mccafferty2023decreased,
  author = {Cian McCafferty and Benjamin F. Gruenbaum and Renee Tung and Jing-Jing Li and Xinyuan Zheng and Peter Salvino and Peter Vincent and Zachary Kratochvil and Jun Hwan Ryu and Aya Khalaf and Kohl Swift and Rashid Akbari and Wasif Islam and Prince Antwi and Emily A. Johnson and Petr Vitkovskiy and James Sampognaro and Isaac G. Freedman and Adam Kundishora and Antoine Depaulis and François David and Vincenzo Crunelli and Basavaraju G. Sanganahalli and Peter Herman and Fahmeed Hyder and Hal Blumenfeld},
  title = {{Decreased but diverse activity of cortical and thalamic neurons in consciousness-impairing rodent absence seizures}},
  booktitle = {Nature Communications},
  year = {2023},
  url = {https://openreview.net/forum?id=SynjPVSoJ6},
}
Figure