Decoherence produces coherent states: An explicit proof for harmonic chains

Max Tegmark, Harold S. ShapiroPhysical 1994 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract

In the study of quantum systems, the ubiquity of "coherent states"—Gaussian wave packets that behave remarkably like classical particles—is often observed but rarely proven from first principles. This paper investigates the behavior of infinite systems of coupled harmonic oscillators as time $t \to \infty$. We generalize the Central Limit Theorem (CLT) to demonstrate that reduced Wigner distributions inevitably become Gaussian under general conditions. A sufficient condition for this evolution is an analytic and non-linear spectral function, which physically corresponds to dispersive wave propagation. Because most standard harmonic heat-bath models satisfy these constraints, this work provides a rigorous foundation for the emergence of coherent states in nature, showing that the mathematical structure of Wigner functions is uniquely suited to this generalized CLT.

Introduction

In quantum mechanics, the phenomenon of "decoherence" describes how a system loses its quantum interference properties through interaction with its environment, often modeled as a "heat bath." While it has long been understood that coherent states are the most robust against this process, a formal proof was historically missing: does decoherence actively produce these states from arbitrary initial conditions?

In their 1994 paper, Max Tegmark and Harold S. Shapiro provide a rigorous mathematical foundation for this phenomenon. By treating a quantum environment as an infinite chain of harmonic oscillators, they prove that decoherence does not merely destroy information; it actively "sculpts" the remaining state into a Gaussian form.

The Mathematical Challenge: Wigner Functions and the CLT

The standard tool for explaining why systems tend toward Gaussian distributions (the familiar "bell curve") is the Central Limit Theorem (CLT). However, the standard CLT relies on the assumption that probability densities are non-negative. In quantum mechanics, phase space is often described using the Wigner function $W(q, p)$. Crucially, Wigner functions can take negative values, which traditionally invalidates the application of the CLT.

Tegmark and Shapiro address this by deriving a Generalized Central Limit Theorem applicable to "quasi-probability distributions." They discovered that nature has "arranged things" so that all Wigner functions belong to a special class of "proper" functions. Even when these functions are negative, their Fourier transforms are maximized at the origin—a mathematical property that allows a CLT-like convergence to Gaussianity to hold.

Methodology: The Infinite Harmonic Chain

The authors model the environment as an infinite harmonic chain—a line of oscillators coupled to their neighbors. The evolution of the system is analyzed through two lenses:

  1. Classical Statistical Mechanics: The authors first demonstrate that in a classical chain, the position and momentum of any single oscillator become Gaussian over time as information from the rest of the chain mixes.
  2. Quantum Generalization: Using the Wigner function, they apply their Generalized CLT to show that the quantum state follows a similar trajectory toward Gaussianity.

The "secret sauce" of this proof is the requirement that the system’s spectral function (its dispersion relation) must be analytic and non-linear. Physically, this means waves of different frequencies must travel at different speeds. This dispersion acts as a "mixer," ensuring that localized information spreads out and becomes suppressed, preventing wave packets from traveling indefinitely without changing shape.

Key Insights

Dispersion as a Physical Driver

The requirement for non-linearity is vital. In a linear system (like light in a vacuum), a wave packet would maintain its shape forever. Non-linearity ensures the "mixing" of information necessary for the Central Limit Theorem to take effect. This explains why Gaussianity is the inevitable destination for any system interacting with a dispersive environment.

Information Erasure and Universality

As the system evolves toward $t \to \infty$, the "fine details" of the initial quantum state are effectively erased. The only information that survives the mixing process is the second moments (the covariance matrix), which defines the final Gaussian state. Because almost all standard heat-bath models used in physics (such as the FKM model) are dispersive, this proof explains why Gaussian states are the universal outcome of decoherence in these systems.

Limitations and Scope

While the proof is robust, it relies on specific conditions:

  • Infinite Systems: The proof assumes an infinite number of oscillators. In finite systems, Poincaré recurrence would eventually occur, though the authors note that for macroscopic systems, this timescale exceeds the age of the universe.
  • Initial Correlations: The theorem assumes the initial state lacks "fine-tuned" long-range correlations. An engineered state designed to "un-mix" would resist Gaussianity until those specific correlations were exhausted.

Conclusion

Tegmark and Shapiro’s work suggests that coherent states and their generalizations are not merely convenient analytical tools but are fundamental products of physical law. By showing that Wigner functions are mathematically predisposed to satisfy a generalized CLT, the paper demonstrates that nature is inherently biased toward the production of coherent, Gaussian states through the natural process of dispersive decoherence.

Summary updated

Abstract

We study the behavior of infinite systems of coupled harmonic oscillators as the time t\ensuremath{\rightarrow}\ensuremath{\infty}, and generalize the central limit theorem (CLT) to show that their reduced Wigner distributions become Gaussian under quite general conditions. This shows that generalized coherent states tend to be produced naturally. A sufficient condition for this to happen is shown to be that the spectral function is analytic and nonlinear. For a chain of coupled oscillators, the nonlinearity requirement means that waves must be dispersive, so that localized wave packets become suppressed. Virtually all harmonic heat-bath models in the literature satisfy this constraint, and we have good reason to believe that coherent states and their generalizations are not merely a useful analytical tool, but that nature is indeed full of them. Standard proofs of the CLT rely heavily on the fact that probability densities are non-negative. Although the CLT is generally not applicable if the densities are allowed to take negative values, we show that a CLT does indeed hold for a special class of such functions. We find that, intriguingly, nature has arranged things so that all Wigner functions belong to this class.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{tegmark1994decoherence,
  author = {Max Tegmark and Harold S. Shapiro},
  title = {{Decoherence produces coherent states: An explicit proof for harmonic chains}},
  booktitle = {Physical},
  year = {1994},
  doi = {10.1103/physreve.50.2538},
}
Figure