Decoherence of a two-qubit system away from perfect symmetry

M. J. Storcz, Frank Hellmann, Calin Hrelescu, Frank K. WilhelmPhysical 2005 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract

The decoherence of an asymmetric two-qubit system that is coupled via a variable interaction term to a common bath or two individual baths of harmonic oscillators is examined. The dissipative dynamics are evaluated using the Bloch-Redfield formalism. It is shown that the behavior of the decoherence effects is affected mostly by the symmetries between the qubit operator that is coupled to the environment and the temperature, whereas the differences between the two bath configurations are very small. Moreover, it is elaborated that small imperfections of the qubit parameters do not necessarily lead to a drastic enhancement of the decoherence rates.

Introduction

In the development of functional quantum computers, decoherence—the loss of quantum information due to environmental interaction—remains a critical obstacle. Theoretical models often simplify this by assuming perfectly identical qubits. However, experimental reality involves asymmetric qubits and complex environmental couplings. This study investigates how these real-world imperfections, specifically parameter spread and bath configurations, impact the performance of two-qubit gates like CNOT and CPHASE.

Methodology

The researchers utilized the Bloch-Redfield formalism to model the open quantum system's dynamics under weak coupling to a thermal bath of harmonic oscillators. The study focused on:

  • Gate Operations: Analyzing the CPHASE gate and the full CNOT sequence.
  • Coupling Symmetry: Introducing a mixing angle $\theta$ to represent noise ranging from longitudinal ($\sigma_z$) to transverse ($\sigma_x$).
  • Bath Models: Comparing a single shared bath versus two independent baths.
  • Quality Metrics: Evaluating Fidelity (F), Purity (P), and Entanglement Capability (C).

Impact of Coupling Symmetry and Bath Configuration

A key finding is that the symmetry of the noise coupling is far more significant than the specific bath configuration. At low temperatures, $\sigma_z$-type noise is naturally suppressed for the CPHASE gate because the noise operator commutes with the gate operation.

Gate quality factors (1-P, 1-Q, 1-F, |-0.5-C|) as a function of the coupling angle $\theta$ at low temperature. CNOT (circles) and CPHASE (squares) show distinct sensitivities to the noise angle.

Interestingly, the difference between coupling to one common bath versus two separate baths is minimal. For the CNOT gate, a shared bath can even offer a slight performance advantage in certain regimes, challenging the intuition that more noise sources are always worse.

Robustness to Qubit Asymmetry

One of the most encouraging results for quantum engineers is the system's tolerance for parameter spread. While perfect symmetry is ideal, small experimental deviations in qubit energies (parameter $G$) do not lead to a "decoherence catastrophe."

Decoherence rates normalized by $\alpha \nu_s$ as a function of qubit asymmetry $G$. The relaxation rate $\Gamma_R$ (top curve) remains remarkably stable across a wide range of asymmetry.

As shown in the figure above, the relaxation rate ($\Gamma_R$) is notably flat even as the qubits become significantly non-identical. This suggests that current manufacturing tolerances for superconducting qubits may be sufficient for high-fidelity operations.

Conclusion

The study concludes that the nature of noise coupling (symmetry) and the operating temperature are the primary determinants of gate success. The relative indifference to bath configuration and the robustness against small qubit asymmetries provide a positive outlook for scaling up superconducting quantum processors. Future research will need to address strong coupling regimes and non-Ohmic noise sources like $1/f$ noise.

Summary updated

Abstract

The decoherence of an asymmetric two-qubit system that is coupled via a variable interaction term to a common bath or two individual baths of harmonic oscillators is examined. The dissipative dynamics are evaluated using the Bloch-Redfield formalism. It is shown that the behavior of the decoherence effects is affected mostly by the symmetries between the qubit operator that is coupled to the environment and the temperature, whereas the differences between the two bath configurations are very small. Moreover, it is elaborated that small imperfections of the qubit parameters do not necessarily lead to a drastic enhancement of the decoherence rates.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{storcz2005decoherence,
  author = {M. J. Storcz and Frank Hellmann and Calin Hrelescu and Frank K. Wilhelm},
  title = {{Decoherence of a two-qubit system away from perfect symmetry}},
  booktitle = {Physical},
  year = {2005},
  doi = {10.1103/physreva.72.052314},
}
Figure