Decoding stress patterns of the 2023 Turkey-Syria earthquake doublet

Jianquan Chen, Luca Dal Zilio, Hang Zhang, Guangliang Yang, Yaolin Shi, Chang LiuResearch Square 2023 · DOI

This research paper, recently published as a preprint on Research Square, provides a deep dive into the geophysics behind one of the most catastrophic seismic events of the 21st century: the February 2023 earthquake doublet in Turkey and Syria.

TL;DR

By modeling two centuries of seismic history, researchers discovered that the first Mw 7.8 earthquake was actually delayed by 52 years due to "stress shadows" from past events, while the subsequent Mw 7.6 quake was accelerated and ultimately triggered by a cascading chain reaction. The study identifies the Elazig-Bingol seismic gap as a high-risk zone that has now accumulated over 500 years' worth of tectonic stress.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Seismologists often struggle to explain why certain faults rupture when they do, especially in "doublet" events where two massive earthquakes occur in quick succession. The 2023 Turkey-Syria sequence involved a Mw 7.8 and a Mw 7.6 earthquake occurring within nine hours on different, though connected, fault systems (the East Anatolian Fault and the Cardak Fault).

The authors sought to understand the "stress clock" of these faults. Did historical earthquakes push these faults toward failure, or did they provide a temporary reprieve? Furthermore, how did the individual sub-events (smaller rupture stages within the main shocks) interact to sustain or terminate the overall disaster?

Methods

The team employed Coulomb Failure Stress ($\Delta$CFS) modeling to calculate how stress was transferred across the region.

  • Viscoelastic Modeling: Unlike simple elastic models, the authors used a layered lithospheric model (via the PSGRN/PSCMP code) that accounts for "viscoelastic relaxation"—the way the Earth's mantle slowly flows and redistributes stress over decades following an earthquake.
  • Stress Calculation: They calculated stress changes at a depth of 10 km (near the hypocenters) using a friction coefficient of 0.4.
  • Tectonic Loading: They compared earthquake-induced stress changes against the background "interseismic loading rate" (the steady buildup of stress from tectonic plate movement), estimated at 3 kPa per year for this region.

Datasets

The study integrated several critical data sources:

  • Historical Catalogue: A curated list of 21 major earthquakes ($M \ge 6.1$) occurring between 1822 and 2023.
  • Slip Models: Kinematic fault slip models for the 2023 events derived from Global Navigation Satellite System (GNSS) and seismic data (referencing USGS and Barbot et al., 2023).
  • Lithospheric Parameters: Crustal and mantle viscosity values derived from previous seismic imaging studies of the Anatolian Plate.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The "Stress Shadow" Delay: Counter-intuitively, historical earthquakes between 1822 and 2022 actually reduced stress at the 2023 Mw 7.8 hypocenter. This "stress shadow" effectively acted as a brake, delaying the earthquake by approximately 52 years.
  • The 2020 Elazig "Brake": The 2020 Mw 6.7 Elazig earthquake created a significant stress shadow at the northeastern end of the 2023 rupture zone. The authors suggest this shadow is likely what stopped the Mw 7.8 rupture from propagating further northeast.
  • The Loaded Gun: While the first quake was delayed, the second (Mw 7.6) was being pushed forward. Historical events brought the Cardak Fault 26 years closer to failure. When the Mw 7.8 quake hit, it added a massive stress load, advancing the Mw 7.6 "clock" by another 75 years and triggering it almost instantly.
  • Sub-event Cascades: The paper breaks down the main shocks into six cascading sub-events (S1–S6). It shows a "chain reaction" where the failure of one segment (like the splay fault S1) provided the necessary kick to trigger the main strand of the East Anatolian Fault (S2).

Key Results

  • Mw 7.8 Initiation: Experienced a stress decrease of -154 kPa from historical events, equivalent to a 52-year delay.
  • Mw 7.6 Triggering: The Mw 7.8 event increased stress on the Cardak Fault by up to 252 kPa, effectively triggering the second main shock.
  • The Elazig-Bingol Gap: This segment of the East Anatolian Fault is now under extreme duress. It has accumulated a $\Delta$CFS of 1547 kPa—equivalent to 516 years of tectonic loading—without a major rupture.
  • Dead Sea Fault (DSF): The northern section of the DSF also saw a stress increment of ~312 kPa, marking it as a zone of "heightened seismic hazard."

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several hurdles:

  • Historical Uncertainty: Parameters for earthquakes from the 1800s (epicenter, exact slip) are not well-constrained, which may impact the precision of long-term stress values.
  • Static vs. Dynamic Stress: This study focuses on static stress transfer (permanent shifts in the crust). It does not model dynamic stress (the passing of seismic waves), which also plays a major role in triggering subsequent ruptures during the seconds and minutes of an event.
  • Future Monitoring: The paper concludes with an urgent call for increased seismic monitoring in the Elazig-Bingol gap and the northern Dead Sea Fault, as these areas are now "primed" for future large events.

Summary updated

Abstract

<title>Abstract</title> Earthquake interaction across multiple time scales can reveal complex stress evolution and rupture patterns. Here, we investigate the stress change's role in the 2023 Mw 7.8 and 7.6 earthquake doublet along the Eastern Anatolian Fault (EAF), using simulations of 21 historical earthquakes (M ≥ 6.1) from 1822 to 2023. Focusing on six cascading sub-events during the 2023 Kahramanmaraş Earthquake Sequence, we reveal how one sub-event's stress alteration can impact the emergence and rupture dynamics of subsequent sub-events. Our analysis unveils that the 2023 Mw 7.8 earthquake was deferred by 52 years due to stress shadow effects from historical events, while the 2023 Mw 7.6 earthquake was accelerated by 26 years as a result of stress increases from historical events and ultimately triggered by the 2023 Mw 7.8 earthquake. This study underscores the importance of grasping earthquake preparation, rupture initiation, and propagation in the context of intricate fault systems worldwide. Based on these results, we draw attention to heightened seismic hazards in the Elazig-Bingol seismic gap of the EAF and the northern section of the Dead Sea Fault, necessitating increased monitoring and preparedness efforts.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{chen2023decoding,
  author = {Jianquan Chen and Luca Dal Zilio and Hang Zhang and Guangliang Yang and Yaolin Shi and Chang Liu},
  title = {{Decoding stress patterns of the 2023 Turkey-Syria earthquake doublet}},
  booktitle = {Research Square},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.21203/rs.3.rs-2922091/v1},
}
Figure