Decoding Spontaneous Informal Spaces in Old Residential Communities: A Drone and Space Syntax Perspective

Ran Zhang, Lei Cao, Yiqing Liu, Ru Guo, Junjie Luo, Ping ShuISPRS Int. J. Geo Inf 2023 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel approach combining drone imagery and space syntax to analyze spontaneous informal spaces (SIS) in aging urban communities. The study reveals how architectural layout and road networks significantly influence the type and distribution of these spaces, offering valuable insights for urban planning and the well-being of elderly residents.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Old residential communities, often rich in historical context, are vital parts of urban fabric and significantly impact residents' quality of life and psychological well-being. As global populations age, understanding and optimizing these environments for the elderly becomes paramount. A common phenomenon in these communities is the emergence of "spontaneous informal spaces" (SIS) – small, often self-created areas using discarded materials, serving as leisure corners or activity domains for the elderly. While these spaces meet specific needs, their informality can clash with formal urban planning, leading to their removal, only for them to re-emerge. Existing research on SIS often relies on qualitative methods or macro-level analyses of informal settlements, lacking a quantitative approach to understand the specific factors influencing SIS emergence, their types, and their determinants within formal aged communities. This gap hinders effective urban renewal strategies that truly cater to the elderly.

Methods

The study employs a multi-faceted approach:

  • Drone Oblique Photography: A DJI Mini 3 PRO drone was used to capture high-resolution aerial imagery and video. This allowed for the precise identification and documentation of SIS features, including location, area, structure, and type, as well as the observation of resident activity patterns (gender, age, activity type).
  • Questionnaire Survey: A detailed questionnaire was administered to elderly residents to gather information on their age, usage frequency of SIS, residential building number, main activities, and feelings about the environment. This provided insights into user characteristics and service radius.
  • Space Syntax Analysis: The Depthmap software was utilized to construct topological models of the residential environment. Key space syntax parameters were extracted:
  • Visual Clustering Coefficient (VCC): Measures visual obstruction.
  • Visual Integration (VI): Gauges how well a space is connected to the entire system (centrality).
  • Normalized Angular Integration (NAIN): Measures integration of a space/path with others, considering angle changes.
  • Normalized Angular Choice (NACH): Quantifies a space/path's selectivity and flow.
  • Data Analysis:
    • Clustering Algorithms: Used to categorize SIS based on their spatial syntax parameters and identify typical types.
  • Multivariate Correlation Analysis: Examined the relationships between SIS structural features (area, service radius) and user characteristics (age, number, frequency) with the space syntax parameters.
  • Generalized Linear Models: Developed to model the relationship between environmental parameters and the number of SIS users and their service radius.

This integrated methodology aims to provide a scientific and quantitative approach to understanding SIS, moving beyond qualitative observations.

Datasets

  • Drone Imagery: Collected from five representative old residential communities in Tianjin City, China, during September 2022.
  • Questionnaire Data: 188 valid questionnaires were collected from elderly residents within these communities.
  • SIS Data: 72 spontaneous informal spaces (SIS) were identified and analyzed across the selected communities.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • SIS as a Reflection of Elderly Needs: The study strongly suggests that SIS are not mere random occurrences but rather a direct manifestation of the elderly's fundamental needs for greenery, social interaction, and basic living functionalities.
  • Architecture and Road Layout as Key Determinants: The research highlights that the physical structure of communities, specifically architectural layout and road network configurations, plays a decisive role in shaping where and what kind of SIS emerge.
  • Accessibility Dictates Social vs. Private SIS: Highly accessible areas with good visibility and connectivity tend to foster "social-type" SIS (e.g., public seating, communication spaces), while more secluded or less trafficked zones are more likely to host "private-type" SIS (e.g., personal gardening, drying clothes).
  • "Air-Drying Clothes" Dominates: The most common type of SIS identified was "air-drying clothes," underscoring the urgent and widespread need for basic living space in these communities.
  • Hidden Cluttered Spaces as Negative Indicators: SIS characterized by high visual obstruction and low accessibility (hidden cluttered spaces) are linked to negative behaviors like indiscriminate trash piling, suggesting these areas are overlooked and can become problematic.
  • Scalability of the Methodology: The combined drone and space syntax approach is noted for its remarkable scalability, making it suitable for larger-scale urban analyses.

Key Results

  • SIS Types and Their Spatial Signatures: Five main types of SIS were identified, each with distinct space syntax parameter profiles:
  • Gardening and Planting: High VI, moderate VCC.
  • Daily Living (in front of buildings): High VCC, moderate VI.
  • Leisure and Communication (between buildings): Moderate VI, NAIN, NACH.
  • Intersection Entertainment and Leisure: High VI, NAIN, NACH.
  • Hidden Cluttered Space: High VCC, low NACH.
  • Correlation Findings:
    • SIS structural features (area, service radius) and user characteristics (age, frequency) did not show a significant correlation with VI and VCC.
  • However, a significant relationship was found between the number of users and the service radius with space syntax parameters.
  • Specifically, NACH and NAIN were found to be the most critical factors influencing the number of users in an SIS.
  • VI and NAIN primarily influenced the service radius of SIS.
  • Quantitative Impact: Regression models indicated that NACH and NAIN significantly influence the number of users, with NAIN and VI influencing the service radius. For example, a model for the number of users showed a significant influence from NACH (p < 0.01) and NAIN (p < 0.001).

Limitations and Future Work

  • Limited Scope of Study Area: The study focused on five specific communities in Tianjin. While representative, this sample might not capture the full diversity of urban dynamics across different cities or newer developments.
  • Broader Urban Planning Framework: The analysis was concentrated on SIS within neighborhoods and did not encompass a broader analysis of the overall urban planning framework or the influence of expansive public spaces.
  • Future Work:
    • Expand the research scope to larger urban areas and diverse cultural terrains.
  • Investigate how extensive public spaces within residential communities influence SIS incidence.
  • Explore whether the presence of structured green amenities reduces the inclination for spontaneous planting.
  • Further research into the relationship between public spaces and community dynamics.
  • The authors suggest that future research should broaden its scope and explore the application of technology in urban planning to foster sustainable urban development and a harmonious coexistence between humans and their surroundings.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@article{zhang2023decoding,
  author = {Ran Zhang and Lei Cao and Yiqing Liu and Ru Guo and Junjie Luo and Ping Shu},
  title = {{Decoding Spontaneous Informal Spaces in Old Residential Communities: A Drone and Space Syntax Perspective}},
  journal = {ISPRS Int. J. Geo Inf.},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.3390/ijgi12110452},
}
Figure