Decision Support System for Strengthening Medium and Short Span Concrete Bridges

Yiqiang Xiang, Chaochao He, Xing Cheng, Yuan Yuan2016 · DOI

Abstract

According to the requirement analysis and current main diseases of medium and short span bridges, a decision-making system—ranging from the preliminary design of reinforcement schemes to hierarchy analysis and comprehensive evaluation—has been developed. Built on the Windows platform using object-oriented programming, the system features a robust man-machine interface. It provides an objective assessment of project alternatives for strengthening and reconstructing medium-to-short span reinforced concrete bridges, offering significant practical utility for infrastructure management.

1. Introduction

As global infrastructure ages, the maintenance and reinforcement of medium and short-span concrete bridges have become critical engineering challenges. Deteriorating structures require timely intervention to ensure public safety and economic continuity. However, selecting the optimal reinforcement strategy is rarely straightforward. Engineers must navigate a complex landscape of technical feasibility, long-term reliability, economic constraints, and construction timelines.

Traditionally, these decisions have relied heavily on subjective professional judgment or single-variable priorities, such as minimizing immediate capital expenditure. This approach often overlooks the multi-objective nature of bridge maintenance. To address this, there is a pressing need for a systematic, objective framework that can translate qualitative engineering expertise into quantitative decision-making. This paper details the development of a Decision Support System (DSS) designed to optimize reinforcement strategies for aging concrete bridges.

2. Methodology and System Architecture

The developed DSS is a stand-alone software package designed for the Windows environment. The system architecture utilizes Visual Basic 6.0 for the graphical user interface (GUI) and Microsoft Access for the backend database management. Complex mathematical operations, particularly those involving fuzzy logic calculations, are integrated via Matlab.

The system is structured into eight functional modules, including Information Input, Disease Analysis, Scheme Generation, and the Display of the Best Scheme. The core logic of the DSS rests on two primary components:

2.1 Reinforcing Countermeasures Tree

The system utilizes a logical database that maps specific structural "diseases" (e.g., superstructure degradation, coping cracks, or reinforcement corrosion) to established engineering solutions. This ensures that the generated alternatives are grounded in proven civil engineering practices and regional codes.

2.2 Fuzzy Analytical Hierarchy Process (FAHP)

To handle the inherent ambiguity in engineering judgment, the system employs the Fuzzy Analytical Hierarchy Process. FAHP allows the DSS to:

  • Decompose the Problem: Break down the decision into a hierarchical structure of goals, criteria, and alternatives.
  • Weight Assignment: Use a judgment matrix to determine the relative importance of various evaluation factors (e.g., cost, construction difficulty, and durability).
  • Consistency Verification: Calculate eigenvectors and maximum characteristic roots to ensure the logical consistency of the user's input.

3. Decision-Making Process

The DSS operates by guiding the user through a structured evaluation workflow. After the engineer inputs specific bridge parameters—such as span, category, and observed defects—the system queries its database to suggest potential reinforcement schemes.

Unlike traditional models, this system requires policymakers to score indices on a scale of 1 to 10. These scores populate fuzzy matrices, which the system then processes to rank the alternatives. By applying the maximum membership degree principle, the software identifies the most suitable scheme based on the weighted priorities of the project. A key feature of the interface is the use of tab controls, which retain calculated variables throughout the session, allowing for a seamless transition between analysis phases.

4. Results and Discussion

The prototype successfully demonstrates an objective assessment pipeline. For instance, when presented with a specific structural issue like a "coping crack," the system can automatically generate five alternative schemes and narrow them down to the most viable candidates for detailed fuzzy evaluation.

A significant advantage of this system is its built-in consistency check. If the expert's scoring in the judgment matrix is logically inconsistent, the software prompts a revision. This ensures that the final recommendation is mathematically sound and not merely a reflection of biased or erratic input. The FAHP-based model provides a more comprehensive basis for bridge reconstruction than traditional single-objective methods by balancing multiple competing factors.

5. Limitations and Future Directions

While the framework is robust, several areas for improvement remain. The current tech stack (Visual Basic 6.0 and Microsoft Access) is dated; migrating to a cloud-based or web-integrated platform would enhance accessibility and data sharing. Furthermore, the system's reliance on manual expert scoring introduces potential human bias. Future iterations could integrate Structural Health Monitoring (SHM) sensor data to automate the initial assessment phase. Finally, while the development of the system is complete, extensive long-term field validation is required to compare the system's recommendations against the actual performance of reinforced bridges over several decades.

6. Conclusion

The developed Decision Support System represents a significant step toward the scientific management of bridge infrastructure. By integrating fuzzy logic with a comprehensive disease-countermeasure database, the system provides engineers with a powerful tool to move beyond subjective decision-making, ensuring that reinforcement strategies are both effective and optimized for the specific needs of medium and short-span concrete bridges.

Summary updated

Abstract

According to the requirement analysis and current main diseases of medium and short span bridges, the decision-making system from preliminary design of reinforcement scheme, hierarchy analysis to comprehensive evaluation and optimization decision models for strengthening medium and short span bridges are studied and developed on the platform of Windows using object-oriented programming method.It has a good man-machine dialogue interface.It can conveniently and objectively assess the project alternatives of strengthening and reconstructing medium-short span reinforced concrete bridges.It has a significant meaning in reality.
BibTeX
@misc{xiang2016decision,
  author = {Yiqiang Xiang and Chaochao He and Xing Cheng and Yuan Yuan},
  title = {{Decision Support System for Strengthening Medium and Short Span Concrete Bridges}},
  year = {2016},
  doi = {10.2991/ifmeita-16.2016.22},
}
Figure