Deciphering the importance of culture pH on CD22 CAR T-cells characteristics

Michaela Procházková, Alexandra Dreyzin, Lipei Shao, P Arazo Garcés, Yihua Cai, Rongye Shi, Alejandra Pelayo, Yong Soo Kim, Victoria C. Pham, Sue Ellen Frodigh, Shannon Fenton, Catherine Karangwa, Yan Su, Kathryn R. Martin, Nan Zhang, Steven L. Highfill, Robert Somerville, Nirali N. Shah, David F. Stroncek, Ping JinJournal of Translational Medicine 2024 · DOI

TL;DR

This study reveals that the pH of cell culture media during the manufacturing of CD22 CAR T-cells is a critical, yet often overlooked, factor influencing T-cell expansion, metabolism, and ultimately, clinical response. Maintaining a slightly acidic pH (around 7.2) at the start of manufacturing appears to be associated with more potent CAR T-cells and better patient outcomes, suggesting pH monitoring could become a standard quality control measure.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Chimeric Antigen Receptor (CAR) T-cell therapy has revolutionized the treatment of certain blood cancers, but its widespread adoption hinges on consistently producing high-quality, potent cells. While manufacturing protocols are becoming more standardized, critical environmental parameters like pH and oxygen levels are often not actively monitored during the Good Manufacturing Practice (GMP) process. This lack of attention to seemingly minor details leaves a gap in our understanding of how these factors might impact CAR T-cell quality and efficacy, potentially leading to suboptimal patient outcomes or increased toxicity. The authors aim to decipher the role of culture pH in the manufacturing of CD22 CAR T-cells and its correlation with cell characteristics and clinical response.

Methods

The researchers conducted a retrospective analysis of cell culture supernatants from 20 patients undergoing CD22 CAR T-cell manufacturing. They employed the MetaFLEX bioanalyzer to measure pH, oxygenation, and key metabolites (glucose, lactate, pCO2, pO2) at multiple time points during the 9-day culture process. Bio-Plex assays were used to quantify cytokine and growth factor levels. RNA sequencing (RNA-seq) was performed on the final CAR T-cell products to analyze gene expression profiles and identify pathways associated with different pH conditions. Statistical analysis, including Spearman correlation and t-tests, was used to assess relationships between pH, cell characteristics, and clinical outcomes.

Datasets

The study utilized data from 20 patients diagnosed with recurrent or refractory CD22-expressing B-cell malignancies who were enrolled in a Phase 1/2 clinical trial. The manufacturing process for their CD22 CAR T-cells was analyzed. No new benchmark datasets were introduced; rather, existing patient data was retrospectively analyzed.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • pH as a Predictive Biomarker: The study strongly suggests that pH, particularly early in the manufacturing process (Day 2), can serve as an early indicator of CAR T-cell quality and potential clinical efficacy.
  • The "Sweet Spot" for pH: A slightly acidic pH (around 7.09-7.28) at the beginning of manufacturing appears to be optimal, leading to better T-cell expansion and metabolic activity compared to a higher pH.
  • Metabolic Fingerprint: Lower pH correlates with increased glycolysis (higher lactate, lower glucose) and higher pCO2, indicative of a more metabolically active T-cell population.
  • Cytokine Secretion and pH: Lower pH conditions were associated with increased secretion of cytokines like SCF, M-CSF, LIF, IL-15, IL2Ra, and TNF-β, which are relevant for both CAR T-cell function and potential adverse events like Cytokine Release Syndrome (CRS).
  • Gene Expression Differences: RNA-seq revealed that genes involved in T-cell activation, lymphocyte activation, differentiation, and mediated immunity were downregulated in low pH conditions, suggesting a more "primed" or activated state in higher pH cultures, which paradoxically correlated with poorer clinical outcomes. This highlights a complex interplay between metabolic activity and functional gene expression.
  • Clinical Outcome Correlation: Patients whose CAR T-cells were manufactured in a lower pH environment (Day 2) showed a significantly higher complete response rate (80%) compared to those manufactured in a higher pH environment (33%). This correlation was particularly pronounced in patients with high baseline disease burden or prior HSCT.

Key Results

  • Day 2 pH: A lower Day 2 pH (mean 7.2) was associated with significantly higher total nucleated cell counts, greater fold expansion, higher pCO2, and higher lactate levels compared to a higher Day 2 pH (mean 7.4).
  • Cytokine Levels (Day 2): Six analytes (SCF, M-CSF, LIF, IL-15, IL2Ra, TNF-β) were significantly higher in low pH cultures.
  • Gene Expression: 78 differentially expressed genes were identified between low and high pH groups at harvest, with 63 upregulated in the low pH group. Gene Set Enrichment Analysis (GSEA) indicated that pathways related to T-cell activation were enriched in the high pH group.
  • Clinical Response: 80% of patients receiving CAR T-cells manufactured at a low Day 2 pH achieved a complete response, versus only 33% of patients receiving cells manufactured at a high Day 2 pH.
  • pH Trend and Response: Patients who achieved complete response were more likely to have stable or slightly increased pH during manufacturing, while non-responders often showed a drop in pH.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations:

  • Sample Size: The study included a relatively small sample size (n=20), limiting the generalizability of the findings.
  • Retrospective Design: The study was retrospective, meaning it identified correlations rather than causal relationships.
  • Specific CAR T-cell Type: The findings are specific to CD22 CAR T-cells and may not directly translate to other CAR T-cell therapies.

Future work should focus on:

  • Prospective Studies: Conducting prospective studies to confirm these findings and explore whether actively controlling pH during manufacturing can improve CAR T-cell quality and clinical efficacy.
  • Broader Applicability: Investigating the role of pH in the manufacturing of other CAR T-cell types.
  • Mechanism Elucidation: Further exploring the precise mechanisms by which pH influences T-cell metabolism, gene expression, and function.
  • Causal Relationships: Designing experiments to establish causal links between pH modifications and CAR T-cell characteristics and outcomes.

The study strongly advocates for the integration of pH monitoring into standard CAR T-cell manufacturing protocols, highlighting its potential as an accessible and valuable tool for quality control and outcome prediction.

Summary updated

Abstract

pH has potential to serve as an informative factor in predicting CAR T-cell quality and clinical outcomes. Thus, its active monitoring during manufacturing may ensure a more effective CAR T-cell product.
BibTeX
@article{prochazkova2024deciphering,
  author = {Michaela Procházková and Alexandra Dreyzin and Lipei Shao and P Arazo Garcés and Yihua Cai and Rongye Shi and Alejandra Pelayo and Yong Soo Kim and Victoria C. Pham and Sue Ellen Frodigh and Shannon Fenton and Catherine Karangwa and Yan Su and Kathryn R. Martin and Nan Zhang and Steven L. Highfill and Robert Somerville and Nirali N. Shah and David F. Stroncek and Ping Jin},
  title = {{Deciphering the importance of culture pH on CD22 CAR T-cells characteristics}},
  journal = {Journal of Translational Medicine},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.1186/s12967-024-05197-5},
}
Figure