Deciphering the alphabet of disorder — Glu and Asp act differently on local but not global properties

Mette Ahrensback Roesgaard, Jeppe E. Lundsgaard, Estella A. Newcombe, Nina L. Jacobsen, Francesco Pesce, Emil E. Tranchant, Søren Lindemose, Andreas Prestel, Rasmus Hartmann‐Petersen, Kresten Lindorff‐Larsen, Birthe B. KragelundbioRxiv 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

Intrinsically disordered proteins (IDPs) are known to be enriched in glutamate over aspartate, but the functional reasons for this bias were unclear. This study uses the yeast protein Dss1 to show that while glutamate and aspartate have similar global effects on IDPs, they differ significantly in their ability to promote local structural features like transient helices, which can impact binding affinities and potentially contribute to functional diversity.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Intrinsically disordered proteins (IDPs) are a class of proteins that lack a stable, well-defined 3D structure, instead existing as dynamic ensembles of conformations. They play crucial roles in various cellular processes, and their malfunction is linked to many diseases. While it's known that IDPs are generally enriched in polar and charged amino acids compared to folded proteins, the specific roles of individual amino acids within IDPs are less understood. Notably, glutamate (Glu) is found to be significantly more enriched in IDPs than its chemically similar counterpart, aspartate (Asp). The authors aim to decipher the functional and structural reasons behind this observed enrichment bias, investigating whether Glu and Asp have distinct roles in shaping the properties and functions of IDPs.

Methods

The researchers employed a multi-pronged approach to investigate the differential effects of Glu and Asp in IDPs:

  • Bioinformatics Analysis: They analyzed the DisProt database of experimentally verified IDPs and compared amino acid frequencies to background datasets of folded proteins to confirm and refine the observed enrichment patterns, specifically looking for biases related to species or protein families.
  • Biochemical and Biophysical Techniques:
    • Yeast Growth Assays: They tested the functional complementation of a Dss1 knockout yeast strain by overexpressing Dss1 variants with different Glu/Asp compositions to assess their in vivo function.
  • NMR Spectroscopy (15N-HSQC): Used to study ubiquitin binding affinity by observing chemical shift perturbations (CSPs) upon addition of ubiquitin to Dss1 variants. This technique also helped assess local structural properties through Secondary Chemical Shift (SCS) analysis.
  • Small-Angle X-ray Scattering (SAXS): Employed to determine the global dimensions (radius of gyration, Rg) of the Dss1 variants.
  • Diffusion-Ordered NMR Spectroscopy (DOSY): Used to determine the hydrodynamic radius (RH) of the Dss1 variants, another measure of global compaction.
  • Molecular Dynamics (MD) Simulations: All-atom MD simulations, enhanced with parallel bias metadynamics, were used to explore the conformational ensembles of the Dss1 variants. This allowed for the calculation of average Rg, analysis of contact maps, and assessment of secondary structure content and helix population.
  • Peptide Studies: Short peptides corresponding to the C-terminal helical region of Dss1 were synthesized and studied using NMR to specifically probe the role of Glu/Asp in stabilizing local helical structures.

Datasets

  • DisProt Database: Used for analyzing the sequence composition of experimentally verified intrinsically disordered proteins.
  • Protein Data Bank (PDB): Used as a background dataset of folded proteins for comparison.
  • UniProt: Used to obtain a non-redundant set of protein sequences for the background dataset.
  • NMR Chemical Shift Databases (e.g., BMRB): Used for accessing chemical shift data.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Local vs. Global Effects: The most striking insight is that while Glu and Asp substitutions in Dss1 have minimal impact on its global dimensions (compaction), they profoundly influence local structural preferences and binding affinities. This suggests that the Glu/Asp bias in IDPs might be driven by subtle, local structural roles rather than broad effects on overall protein shape.
  • Glutamate Favors Transient Helices: Glutamate appears to be more effective than aspartate in promoting and stabilizing transient helical structures, particularly in the C-terminal region of Dss1. This is attributed to its longer side chain, which can form more stable salt bridges and hydrogen bonds, and its position relative to the protein backbone.
  • Aspartate Supports Extended Structures: Conversely, aspartate seems to better support local extended structures, especially when present in consecutive residues.
  • Impact on Binding Affinity: The differential ability to form local structures directly translates to differences in binding affinity. Variants with specific Glu/Asp patterns in the ubiquitin-binding motif (UBS I) showed altered affinities for ubiquitin, with the wild-type (containing a central glutamate) exhibiting the strongest binding.
  • Functional Implications for IDP Evolution: The findings suggest that the preference for glutamate in IDPs might be linked to its ability to pre-form transient helices, which can accelerate ligand binding and contribute to functional diversity. Conversely, aspartate's role in extended structures or calcium binding might explain its less pronounced enrichment.

Key Results

  • Functional Complementation: All tested Dss1 variants (wild-type, All-E, All-D, Swap) were able to rescue the temperature-sensitive growth defect of a dss1 knockout yeast strain, indicating that these substitutions do not abolish essential in vivo function.
  • Ubiquitin Binding Affinity: While all variants bound mono-ubiquitin, they did so with 3.5-7.5 fold weaker affinities compared to the wild-type Dss1. The "Swap" variant showed the lowest affinity.
  • Global Dimensions: Hydrodynamic radius (RH) and radius of gyration (Rg) measurements showed only minor differences between the variants, suggesting that Glu/Asp substitutions do not significantly alter the overall compaction of Dss1.
  • Local Structure: NMR SCS analysis and MD simulations revealed that Glu/Asp variations influence the population and stability of transient helical structures in the C-terminal region of Dss1. Specifically, glutamate was found to stabilize helices, while aspartate favored extended structures.
  • Contact Maps: MD simulations showed that aspartate-containing variants exhibited more frequent interactions between the C-terminal region and the UBS I, potentially influencing the regulation of ubiquitin binding.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Phenotype Complementation Assay Sensitivity: The authors acknowledge that the yeast growth assay might not be sensitive enough to detect subtle functional effects of the Glu/Asp substitutions, as it primarily relates to Dss1's role in the proteasome.
  • MD Simulation Kinetics: The authors note that the kinetics of helix formation/breaking in MD simulations might be perturbed by the bias used for enhanced sampling, and that longer simulations might be needed to fully capture these dynamics.
  • Experimental vs. Simulation Discrepancies: Minor discrepancies were observed between NMR and MD simulations regarding the transient helicity of the UBS I region, which the authors attribute to potential force field inaccuracies.
  • Future Directions: The paper suggests that further investigation into the specific roles of Glu and Asp in other IDP functions, such as transactivation domains and ion binding, is warranted. They also propose exploring the potential for aspartate to minimize binding of divalent cations as another reason for its less pronounced enrichment in IDPs. The authors also highlight the need for better methods to calculate small changes in secondary chemical shifts from simulations for more direct comparison with experimental data.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract Compared to folded proteins, the sequences of intrinsically disordered proteins (IDPs) are enriched in polar and charged amino acids. Glutamate is one of the most enriched amino acids in IDPs, while the chemically similar amino acid aspartate is less enriched. So far, the underlying functional differences of glutamates and aspartates in IDPs remain poorly understood. In this study, we examine the differential effects of aspartate and glutamates in IDPs by comparing the function and conformational ensemble of glutamate and aspartate variants of the disordered protein Dss1, using a range of assays, including interaction studies, nuclear magnetic resonance spectroscopy, small angle X-ray scattering and molecular dynamics simulation. First, we analyze the sequences of the rapidly growing data base of experimentally verified IDPs (DisProt) and show that the glutamate enrichment is not caused by a taxonomy bias in IDPs. From analyses of local and global structural properties as well as cell growth and protein-protein interactions using a model acidic IDP from yeast and three Glu/Asp variants, we find that while Glu/Asp support similar function and global dimensions, the variants differ in their binding affinities and population of local transient structural elements. We speculate that these local structural differences may play roles in functional diversity where glutamates can support increased helicity important for folding and binding, while aspartates support extended structures and form helical caps, as well as playing more relevant roles in e.g., transactivation domains and ion-binding.
BibTeX
@misc{roesgaard2022deciphering,
  author = {Mette Ahrensback Roesgaard and Jeppe E. Lundsgaard and Estella A. Newcombe and Nina L. Jacobsen and Francesco Pesce and Emil E. Tranchant and Søren Lindemose and Andreas Prestel and Rasmus Hartmann‐Petersen and Kresten Lindorff‐Larsen and Birthe B. Kragelund},
  title = {{Deciphering the alphabet of disorder — Glu and Asp act differently on local but not global properties}},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.1101/2022.08.25.505250},
  howpublished = {bioRxiv},
}
Figure