Deciphering and predicting CD4+ T cell immunodominance of influenza virus hemagglutinin

Antonino Cassotta, Philipp Paparoditis, Roger Geiger, Ramgopal R. Mettu, Samuel J. Landry, Alessia Donati, Marco Benevento, Mathilde Foglierini, David Lewis, Antonio Lanzavecchia, Federica SallustoThe Journal of Experimental Medicine 2020 · DOI

TL;DR

This study reveals that while naive CD4+ T cells recognize a wide range of influenza hemagglutinin (HA) peptides, memory T cells become highly focused on a few immunodominant regions. This immunodominance is primarily dictated by how the HA protein is processed and presented by antigen-presenting cells, rather than just peptide-MHC binding affinity.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

CD4+ T cells are crucial for adaptive immunity, but understanding what makes certain parts of a complex protein antigen (like influenza HA) stand out as "immunodominant" has been a challenge. Immunodominance refers to the phenomenon where only a small subset of potential T cell epitopes within an antigen elicits a strong response, while others are ignored or weakly recognized. This paper aims to unravel the mechanisms behind this selection process, specifically for the influenza H1 hemagglutinin (H1-HA), to understand how the immune system prioritizes certain viral fragments for T cell recognition.

Methods

The researchers employed a multi-pronged approach:

  • Ex vivo T cell stimulation and cloning: They isolated different types of memory CD4+ T cells (central, effector, and follicular helper) from vaccinated individuals and stimulated them with H1-HA. Proliferating cells were cloned to identify specific peptide targets.
  • T cell library screening: They created libraries of naive and memory CD4+ T cells and screened them against a comprehensive set of overlapping H1-HA peptides to map their reactivity.
  • TCR sequencing: They sequenced the T cell receptors (TCRs) of identified clones to understand the diversity of the T cell response.
  • Mass Spectrometry (MS)-based immunopeptidomics: They analyzed the actual peptides naturally presented on MHC class II molecules by antigen-presenting cells (APCs) after exposure to H1-HA.
  • In silico prediction: They used algorithms to predict MHC-II binding affinity and, importantly, developed a new approach based on structural accessibility and protease cleavage likelihood (Antigen Processing Likelihood - APL) to predict how easily peptides could be liberated from the HA protein.

Datasets

The study utilized blood samples from multiple healthy donors vaccinated with influenza vaccines. The primary "dataset" in this context is the repertoire of T cell responses and the naturally processed peptides identified from these donors. No new benchmark datasets were introduced, but the study provides a detailed characterization of the H1-HA T cell epitope landscape.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Naive vs. Memory T cells: A striking difference was observed: naive T cells have a broad recognition profile, responding to many peptides across the entire H1-HA sequence, including "cryptic" ones (those not typically processed or presented). Memory T cells, however, become highly focused on a few specific immunodominant regions.
  • Antigen Processing is Key: The study strongly suggests that the process of breaking down the HA protein into peptides by APCs is a major determinant of immunodominance. It's not just about which peptides can bind to MHC-II, but which ones are actually generated and presented in sufficient quantities.
  • Structural Accessibility Matters: The researchers developed and validated an "Antigen Processing Likelihood" (APL) score, which predicts how easily a peptide can be released from the protein based on its structural context and susceptibility to protease cleavage. This, combined with MHC-II binding prediction, significantly improved the ability to predict immunodominant epitopes.
  • Antibodies Can Modulate Presentation: Experiments with B cells expressing antibodies against different parts of HA (head vs. stem) showed that antibody binding could alter which peptides were presented on MHC-II, potentially influencing T cell responses.

Key Results

  • In a vaccinated donor, memory CD4+ T cells were predominantly directed against just two overlapping peptides within the H1-HA401-430 region.
  • Naive T cells from the same donors showed a much broader reactivity, recognizing peptides across the entire H1-HA sequence.
  • MS-based immunopeptidomics confirmed that the immunodominant regions targeted by memory T cells were indeed those most abundantly presented on MHC-II molecules by APCs.
  • A combined predictive model incorporating both MHC-II binding affinity and Antigen Processing Likelihood (APL) significantly outperformed models based on either factor alone in predicting immunodominant epitopes.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Individual Variation: While the study analyzed multiple donors with diverse HLA types, the specific immunodominant regions identified varied between individuals, highlighting the importance of HLA background.
  • In vitro vs. In vivo: The study relies on ex vivo analysis and in vitro stimulation. Further validation in live systems would be beneficial.
  • Mechanisms of Antibody Modulation: The precise mechanisms by which antibodies modulate HA processing by B cells remain to be fully elucidated.
  • Broader Antigen Application: The developed predictive model for immunodominance could be tested and refined on other complex protein antigens beyond influenza HA. The authors suggest that understanding antigen processing and structural accessibility is crucial for developing more accurate predictive algorithms for T cell immunogenicity of protein antigens.

Summary updated

Abstract

The importance of CD4+ T helper (Th) cells is well appreciated in view of their essential role in the elicitation of antibody and cytotoxic T cell responses. However, the mechanisms that determine the selection of immunodominant epitopes within complex protein antigens remain elusive. Here, we used ex vivo stimulation of memory T cells and screening of naive and memory T cell libraries, combined with T cell cloning and TCR sequencing, to dissect the human naive and memory CD4+ T cell repertoire against the influenza pandemic H1 hemagglutinin (H1-HA). We found that naive CD4+ T cells have a broad repertoire, being able to recognize naturally processed as well as cryptic peptides spanning the whole H1-HA sequence. In contrast, memory Th cells were primarily directed against just a few immunodominant peptides that were readily detected by mass spectrometry-based MHC-II peptidomics and predicted by structural accessibility analysis. Collectively, these findings reveal the presence of a broad repertoire of naive T cells specific for cryptic H1-HA peptides and demonstrate that antigen processing represents a major constraint determining immunodominance.
BibTeX
@article{cassotta2020deciphering,
  author = {Antonino Cassotta and Philipp Paparoditis and Roger Geiger and Ramgopal R. Mettu and Samuel J. Landry and Alessia Donati and Marco Benevento and Mathilde Foglierini and David Lewis and Antonio Lanzavecchia and Federica Sallusto},
  title = {{Deciphering and predicting CD4+ T cell immunodominance of influenza virus hemagglutinin}},
  journal = {The Journal of Experimental Medicine},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.1084/jem.20200206},
}
Figure