Decentralized, Decomposition-Based Observation Scheduling for a Large-Scale Satellite Constellation

Itai Zilberstein, Ananya Rao, Matthew Salis, Steve ChienICAPS 2024 · OpenReview

TL;DR

This paper tackles the challenge of scheduling observations for massive satellite constellations, which are too complex for traditional centralized or standard decentralized planning methods. They introduce a novel "Geometric Neighborhood Decomposition" (GND) heuristic to break down the problem into manageable sub-problems, enabling a decentralized algorithm called Neighborhood Stochastic Search (NSS) to achieve near-optimal results with significantly reduced communication overhead.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Planning and scheduling observations for large satellite constellations (hundreds or thousands of satellites) is a monumental task. Traditionally, this has been done using centralized systems where a single computer plans every satellite's actions. However, this approach is vulnerable to single points of failure and can become a bottleneck. As satellites gain more autonomy, viewing the constellation as a multi-agent system (MAS) and using decentralized scheduling becomes attractive for robustness. The core challenge is that the sheer scale of these problems (millions of variables) makes existing decentralized planning algorithms, specifically Distributed Constraint Optimization Problems (DCOPs), computationally infeasible and communication-intensive. The authors aim to bridge this gap by developing a decentralized approach that can handle this scale effectively.

Methods

The paper's main contribution is a two-pronged approach:

  1. Geometric Neighborhood Decomposition (GND) Heuristic: This is a novel method for breaking down the global scheduling problem into smaller, more manageable sub-problems. GND operates in three layers:
  2. Global Supply Layer: Estimates the number of satellites capable of observing a target, considering orbital planes and target visibility.
  3. Inter-Neighborhood Delegation Layer: Assigns each request to a specific "neighborhood" (an orbital plane) based on supply and estimated target distance. This effectively partitions the problem.
  4. Intra-Neighborhood Delegation Layer: Further partitions agents within a neighborhood into smaller groups based on "biases" derived from their relative positions and target characteristics. This creates even smaller sub-problems.
  5. Neighborhood Stochastic Search (NSS) Algorithm: This is a decentralized algorithm designed to solve the decomposed sub-problems. NSS builds upon existing DCOP algorithms (like MGM and DSA) but incorporates:
  6. Decomposition: It operates on the sub-problems generated by GND.
  7. Resource Constraints: It handles memory limitations and downlink requirements.
  8. De-scheduling: It allows agents to remove previously scheduled tasks to make room for new, potentially better ones, helping to escape local optima.
  9. Limited Communication: Agents only communicate within their sub-problem, drastically reducing the overall communication burden compared to traditional DCOPs.

Datasets

The paper does not introduce new datasets. Instead, it uses simulated satellite constellations and request campaigns based on real-world scenarios. Specifically, they model a constellation similar to Planet's Earth-observing satellites, with varying orbital planes and satellite numbers. They generate both "small" and "large" problem instances by varying the number of requests and the scheduling horizon.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Decomposition is Key for Scale: The most significant insight is that for extremely large-scale DCOPs, a well-designed decomposition heuristic is crucial to make them tractable for decentralized algorithms.
  • Geometry as a Scheduling Tool: Leveraging the geometric properties of satellite orbits and target locations is an effective way to partition the problem and create meaningful sub-problems.
  • Decentralized Robustness and Efficiency: By moving away from centralized control and enabling agents to solve smaller, localized problems, the system becomes more robust and communication-efficient.
  • NSS Balances Performance and Scalability: The NSS algorithm, empowered by GND, demonstrates that it's possible to achieve high request satisfaction rates comparable to centralized methods, but with significantly better scalability and communication efficiency.

Key Results

  • Small Problem Instances: NSS (both Random and Decomposition initialization) achieved very low "optimal gap" percentages (0.580% and 0.409% respectively), indicating near-optimal solutions. NSS-Decomposition was slightly better than NSS-Random. Both significantly outperformed fully decentralized baselines and were much faster than the centralized SWO algorithm, with orders of magnitude less communication.
  • Large Problem Instances: NSS algorithms were comparable to the centralized SWO approach, achieving only a ~3% satisfaction decrease on average. They significantly outperformed other fully decentralized baselines.
  • Efficiency: NSS algorithms were orders of magnitude faster than the centralized SWO, and the communication cost was drastically reduced due to decomposition.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Heuristic Nature: The GND heuristic is not guaranteed to produce optimal partitions, and the load balancing across sub-problems could be improved.
  • Parameter Tuning: The performance of NSS is sensitive to parameters like p (for intra-neighborhood delegation), which requires tuning.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest exploring more complex variations of COSP, such as those with temporally flexible observations and slewing models. They also plan to investigate methods for improving GND to better balance the workload across sub-problems. The generality of the GND heuristic for other multi-agent coordination problems is also an area for future exploration.

Summary updated

Abstract

Deploying multi-satellite constellations for Earth observation requires coordinating potentially hundreds or thousands of spacecraft. Centralized approaches to observation scheduling rely on a single controller planning the actions of each satellite. With increasing on-board capability for autonomy, we can view the constellation as a multi-agent system (MAS) and employ decentralized scheduling solutions. We formulate the problem as a distributed constraint optimization problem (DCOP) and desire limited inter-agent communication. Due to the scale and structure of the problem, existing DCOP algorithms are inadequate for this application. We develop a scheduling approach that employs a well-coordinated heuristic to decompose the global DCOP into sub-problems as to enable the application of DCOP algorithms. Building on previous work, we present the Neighborhood Stochastic Search (NSS) algorithm, a decentralized algorithm to effectively solve the Earth observing multi-satellite constellation scheduling problem. In this paper, we identify the roadblocks of deploying DCOP solvers to a large-scale, real-world problem, propose a decomposition-based scheduling approach that is effective at tackling large scale DCOPs, empirically evaluate the approach against other baselines to demonstrate the effectiveness, and discuss the generality of the approach.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{zilberstein2024decentralized,
  author = {Itai Zilberstein and Ananya Rao and Matthew Salis and Steve Chien},
  title = {{Decentralized, Decomposition-Based Observation Scheduling for a Large-Scale Satellite Constellation}},
  booktitle = {ICAPS},
  year = {2024},
  url = {https://openreview.net/forum?id=2xNKE2VMeg},
}
Figure