Decarbonising the iron and steel sector for a 2 °C target using inherent waste streams

Yongqi Sun, Sicong Tian, Philippe Ciais, Zhenzhong Zeng, Jing Meng, Zuotai ZhangNature Communications 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper proposes a novel approach to decarbonize the iron and steel industry by leveraging waste streams (blast furnace slag and steel slag) for energy recovery and material reuse. This strategy can generate significant revenue, which can then be reinvested into carbon capture and storage (CCS), potentially achieving the 2°C climate target without external funding.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The iron and steel industry is a major contributor to global CO2 emissions, accounting for approximately 8% of the total. Meeting ambitious climate targets, such as limiting global warming to 2°C, requires substantial reductions in emissions from this sector. However, the industry faces challenges due to growing global steel demand and the limited availability of cost-effective low-carbon steelmaking technologies. Current emission reduction pathways often rely on expensive technologies like CCS, which may not be economically viable without significant external investment. This paper addresses the gap by exploring how inherent waste streams within the industry can be utilized to create a financially self-sustaining decarbonization pathway.

Methods

The study employs a multi-faceted approach:

  • Pathway Development: Nine distinct pathways were constructed based on the properties of blast furnace slag (BFS) and steel slag (SS), considering different treatment strategies (e.g., glassy vs. crystalline states, dry granulation vs. water quenching). These pathways were evaluated for their CO2 emission reduction potential against the 2°C target requirements.
  • Techno-Economic Analysis: For the most promising pathways (Pathways 5 and 6), five technological schemes were developed and analyzed. These schemes involve strategies for recovering energy from hot slag and utilizing its material components. The analysis includes cost-benefit assessments, considering investment, operation, and revenue generation from product sales and avoided emissions.
  • Sensitivity Analysis: The study performs sensitivity analyses to understand how variations in key parameters (e.g., slag price, discharge temperature, input material ratios, CO2 price) affect the economic viability and emission reduction potential of the proposed schemes.
  • Integration with CCS: The research models the integration of the revenue generated from waste stream utilization with the implementation of carbon capture and storage (CCS) technologies, assessing the combined impact on achieving the 2°C target.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study relies on existing data for global steel production, waste stream properties, and energy/material balances.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Waste Streams as a Financial Engine: The most striking insight is that waste streams from iron and steel production are not just environmental burdens but can be a significant source of revenue. This revenue stream is crucial for making decarbonization economically feasible.
  • Self-Funded CCS: By reinvesting the profits from waste stream utilization into CCS, the industry can achieve deep decarbonization without needing external capital. This shifts the paradigm from costly mitigation to a circular economy approach.
  • Glassy BFS is Key: The study highlights that obtaining blast furnace slag in a glassy state is critical for maximizing its value, particularly for its use as a cement feedstock. This emphasizes the importance of efficient cooling and granulation techniques.
  • Synergistic Benefits: The proposed pathways offer dual benefits: energy recovery (reducing reliance on fossil fuels) and material recycling (reducing the need for virgin materials, especially in cement production, which also has a significant carbon footprint).

Key Results

  • Significant CO2 Reduction: Pathway 6, which involves energy recovery and resource recycling of glassy BFS and crystalline SS, can achieve a CO2 emission reduction of 28.5 ± 5.7% by 2050 relative to the 2°C target requirements.
  • Substantial Revenue Generation: The technological schemes applied to these high-potential pathways are projected to generate global revenues of US$35 ± 16 billion in 2035** and **US$40 ± 18 billion in 2050.
  • Accelerated Decarbonization with CCS: When the generated revenue is reinvested into CCS, the equivalent CO2 emission reduction to meet the 2°C sectoral target requirements can be achieved before 2050 (e.g., by 2042 for Pathway 6 + CCS).
  • Economic Sensitivity: The net revenue is most sensitive to the slag price, underscoring the importance of maximizing the value of these waste materials.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Technological Readiness: Some of the proposed gasification methods have a low Technology Readiness Level (TRL), indicating that further development and scaling are needed.
  • Policy and Regulatory Frameworks: The study assumes strong decarbonization policies and a supportive regulatory environment. The actual implementation may depend on these factors.
  • Uncertainties in Demand and Technology: The projections are based on estimated steel demand and technological advancements, which inherently carry uncertainties.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest further research into optimizing gasification agents and conditions, exploring other applications for slag components, and investigating the integration of these pathways with other low-carbon steelmaking technologies like hydrogen-based metallurgy. They also emphasize the need for policy support to facilitate the adoption of these innovative solutions.

Summary updated

Abstract

The decarbonisation of the iron and steel industry, contributing approximately 8% of current global anthropogenic CO<sub>2</sub> emissions, is challenged by the persistently growing global steel demand and limitations of techno-economically feasible options for low-carbon steelmaking. Here we explore the inherent potential of recovering energy and re-using materials from waste streams, high-temperature slag, and re-investing the revenues for carbon capture and storage. In a pathway based on energy recovery and resource recycling of glassy blast furnace slag and crystalline steel slag, we show that a reduction of 28.5 ± 5.7% CO<sub>2</sub> emissions to the sectoral 2 °C target requirements in the iron and steel industry could be realized in 2050 under strong decarbonization policy consistent with low warming targets. The technological schemes applied to engineer this high-potential pathway could generate a revenue of US$35 ± 16 and US$40 ± 18 billion globally in 2035 and 2050, respectively. If this revenue is used for carbon capture and storage implementation, equivalent CO<sub>2</sub> emission to the 2 °C sectoral target requirements is expected to be reduced before 2050, without any external investments.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{sun2022decarbonising,
  author = {Yongqi Sun and Sicong Tian and Philippe Ciais and Zhenzhong Zeng and Jing Meng and Zuotai Zhang},
  title = {{Decarbonising the iron and steel sector for a 2 °C target using inherent waste streams}},
  booktitle = {Nature Communications},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.1038/s41467-021-27770-y},
}
Figure