Debridement, Curettage, and Bone Marrow Stimulation: Proceedings of the International Consensus Meeting on Cartilage Repair of the Ankle

Charles P. Hannon, Steve Bayer, Christopher D. Murawski, Gian Luigi Canata, Thomas O. Clanton, Daniël Haverkamp, Jin Woo Lee, Martin O’Malley, Hua Yinghui, James W. Stone, Jakob Ackermann, Samuel B. Adams, Carol L. Andrews, Chayanin Angthong, Jorge Batista, O Baur, Christoph Becher, Gregory C. Berlet, Lorraine A. T. Boakye, Alexandra J. Brown, Roberto Buda, James Calder, Dominic S. Carreira, Jari Dahmen, Pieter D’Hooghe, Christopher W. DiGiovanni, Malcolm E. Dombrowski, Mark C. Drakos, Richard D. Ferkel, Paulo N. F. Ferrao, Lisa A. Fortier, Mark Glazebrook, Eric Giza, Mohamed Gomaa, Simon Görtz, Amgad M. Haleem, Kamran S. Hamid, László Hangody, Jay Hertel, Beat Hintermann, MaCalus V. Hogan, Kenneth J. Hunt, Eoghan T. Hurley, Jón Karlsson, Stephen R. Kearns, John G. Kennedy, Gino M. M. J. Kerkhoffs, Hak Jun Kim, Siu Wah Kong, Sameh A. Labib, Kaj T. A. Lambers, Keun Bae Lee, Jeffrey S. Ling, Umile Giuseppe Longo, Alberto Marangon, Graham McCollum, Adam Mitchell, Peter N. Mittwede, Stefan Nehrer, Philipp Niemeyer, James A. Nunley, David O. Osei-Hwedieh, Jochen Paul, Christopher J. Pearce, Hélder Pereira, Adam Popchak, Marcelo Pires Prado, Steven M. Raikin, Mikel L. Reilingh, Benjamin B. Rothrauff, Lew C. Schon, Yoshiharu Shimozono, Helene Simpson, Niall A. Smyth, Carolyn M. Sofka, Pietro Spennacchio, Martin Sullivan, Masato Takao, Yasuhito Tanaka, David B. Thordarson, Rocky S. Tuan, Víctor Valderrábano, Christiaan J. A. van Bergen, C. Niek van Dijk, Pim A. D. van Dijk, Francesca Vannini, Tanawat Vaseenon, Markus Walther, Martin Wiewiorski, Xiangyang Xu, Youichi Yasui, Ichiro Yoshimura, Alastair Younger, Zijun ZhangFoot 2018 · DOI

Abstract

This international consensus, derived from leaders in the field, provides clinicians with standardized guidelines for debridement, curettage, and bone marrow stimulation (BMS) as a treatment strategy for osteochondral lesions of the talus (OLT). By synthesizing expert opinion and existing literature, the group established clear thresholds for lesion sizes and surgical techniques to improve clinical outcomes in a field previously dominated by low-quality evidence.

The Problem: Navigating the "Poverty of Evidence"

Osteochondral lesions of the talus (OLT)—essentially "potholes" in the cartilage and underlying bone of the ankle joint—are common but notoriously difficult to treat. While arthroscopic Bone Marrow Stimulation (BMS) is the most frequent surgical intervention, the clinical guidelines supporting it have historically been weak. Most existing studies are categorized as "Level IV" (simple case series) with short follow-up periods.

Clinicians have long struggled with several key questions: How large of a lesion is too large for BMS? How exactly should the bone be prepped? Does adding "biologics" like platelet-rich plasma (PRP) actually help? This paper aims to replace anecdotal "expert preference" with a formal, evidence-graded consensus to standardize care.

Methods: The Delphi Process

The authors employed a Delphi method, a structured communication technique used to reach a reliable consensus among a panel of 75 international experts from 25 countries. The group was divided into 11 specialized working groups that underwent multiple rounds of surveys to refine specific clinical statements.

Every statement was paired with a literature review, and the evidence was graded using a specific hierarchy ranging from A1 (high-quality randomized controlled trials) to E (expert opinion).

Evidence grading scale used to evaluate the strength of consensus statements.

Consensus was defined by the percentage of agreement: 51-74% (Consensus), 75-99% (Strong Consensus), and 100% (Unanimous).

Key Insights and Surgical Standards

The "Ideal" Window for Success

The consensus narrowed the "sweet spot" for BMS. While historical guidelines often used a 15mm diameter cutoff, this group suggests that BMS is most successful for lesions <10mm in diameter, <100mm² in area, and <5mm in depth.

Mechanical Precision

The group reached a strong consensus on technique: the edges of the cartilage defect should be debrided to a stable, vertical (90-degree) rim. This provides better structural integrity for the resulting "clot" that forms the new repair tissue (fibrocartilage).

The Role of Biologics

Interestingly, the only statement to receive 100% unanimous support was that biological augmentation (e.g., PRP, bone marrow aspirate concentrate, or stem cells) may be beneficial. However, the authors admit the current clinical evidence for these is still emerging and sometimes conflicting.

Caution on Repeat Procedures

The experts warned that a repeat BMS procedure often yields inferior results compared to the primary surgery. If the first intervention fails, surgeons should consider more invasive "salvage" procedures like autologous osteochondral transplantation (AOT).

Results and Clinical Impact

The process produced 14 finalized consensus statements:

  • 1 statement reached Unanimous Consensus (100%): Biological augmentation is potentially beneficial.
  • 12 statements reached Strong Consensus (75-99%): This includes the specific size guidelines and technical requirements (using a <2mm awl/drill, spacing holes 3-5mm apart).
  • 1 statement reached Consensus (72%): A previous BMS procedure will negatively affect the outcome of a subsequent BMS.

Quantitatively, the paper highlights that while BMS has an 85% clinical success rate generally, success drops significantly once a lesion exceeds the 15mm diameter mark due to the mechanical inferiority of the fibrocartilage produced.

Limitations and Future Directions

The authors are transparent that consensus is not a substitute for high-quality data. Most statements are still supported by Level IV or V evidence, reflecting the need for more robust research. Future work will focus on long-term randomized controlled trials (RCTs) comparing BMS with and without biological additives to see if the "unanimous" belief in biologics translates to measurable patient improvement.

Summary updated

Abstract

This international consensus derived from leaders in the field will assist clinicians with debridement, curettage and bone marrow stimulation as a treatment strategy for osteochondral lesions of the talus.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{hannon2018debridement,
  author = {Charles P. Hannon and Steve Bayer and Christopher D. Murawski and Gian Luigi Canata and Thomas O. Clanton and Daniël Haverkamp and Jin Woo Lee and Martin O’Malley and Hua Yinghui and James W. Stone and Jakob Ackermann and Samuel B. Adams and Carol L. Andrews and Chayanin Angthong and Jorge Batista and O Baur and Christoph Becher and Gregory C. Berlet and Lorraine A. T. Boakye and Alexandra J. Brown and Roberto Buda and James Calder and Dominic S. Carreira and Jari Dahmen and Pieter D’Hooghe and Christopher W. DiGiovanni and Malcolm E. Dombrowski and Mark C. Drakos and Richard D. Ferkel and Paulo N. F. Ferrao and Lisa A. Fortier and Mark Glazebrook and Eric Giza and Mohamed Gomaa and Simon Görtz and Amgad M. Haleem and Kamran S. Hamid and László Hangody and Jay Hertel and Beat Hintermann and MaCalus V. Hogan and Kenneth J. Hunt and Eoghan T. Hurley and Jón Karlsson and Stephen R. Kearns and John G. Kennedy and Gino M. M. J. Kerkhoffs and Hak Jun Kim and Siu Wah Kong and Sameh A. Labib and Kaj T. A. Lambers and Keun Bae Lee and Jeffrey S. Ling and Umile Giuseppe Longo and Alberto Marangon and Graham McCollum and Adam Mitchell and Peter N. Mittwede and Stefan Nehrer and Philipp Niemeyer and James A. Nunley and David O. Osei-Hwedieh and Jochen Paul and Christopher J. Pearce and Hélder Pereira and Adam Popchak and Marcelo Pires Prado and Steven M. Raikin and Mikel L. Reilingh and Benjamin B. Rothrauff and Lew C. Schon and Yoshiharu Shimozono and Helene Simpson and Niall A. Smyth and Carolyn M. Sofka and Pietro Spennacchio and Martin Sullivan and Masato Takao and Yasuhito Tanaka and David B. Thordarson and Rocky S. Tuan and Víctor Valderrábano and Christiaan J. A. van Bergen and C. Niek van Dijk and Pim A. D. van Dijk and Francesca Vannini and Tanawat Vaseenon and Markus Walther and Martin Wiewiorski and Xiangyang Xu and Youichi Yasui and Ichiro Yoshimura and Alastair Younger and Zijun Zhang},
  title = {{Debridement, Curettage, and Bone Marrow Stimulation: Proceedings of the International Consensus Meeting on Cartilage Repair of the Ankle}},
  booktitle = {Foot},
  year = {2018},
  doi = {10.1177/1071100718779392},
}
Figure