Dear‐PSM: A deep learning‐based peptide search engine enables full database search for proteomics

Qingzu He, Li Xiang, Jinjin Zhong, Gen Yang, Jiahuai Han, Jianwei ShuaiSmart 2024 · DOI

TL;DR

Dear-PSM is a novel peptide search engine that revolutionizes proteomics by enabling full database searches without the restrictive limitations of traditional methods. By combining an inverted index of experimental spectra with deep learning for validation, it achieves a significant speedup and memory reduction, uncovering more peptides and proteins than existing tools.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Proteomics aims to identify and quantify proteins in biological samples, a crucial step for understanding cellular processes and disease. A cornerstone of this field is peptide spectrum matching (PSM), where experimental mass spectrometry data (spectra) are matched to theoretical peptide sequences derived from protein databases. The challenge lies in the sheer scale of this problem: a single spectrum can potentially match thousands of peptides, especially when considering variable modifications (chemical changes to amino acids that occur after protein synthesis, like phosphorylation).

Traditional search engines try to manage this complexity by imposing strict limits on peptide mass errors and the number of allowed variable modifications. While this speeds up the search, it comes at the cost of interpretive capability, potentially missing many true peptide identifications. This is akin to searching for a needle in a haystack by only looking in a small, pre-defined area. The paper addresses the need for a search engine that can perform a comprehensive, full database search without sacrificing speed or memory efficiency, thereby increasing the chances of discovering novel peptides and modifications.

Methods

Dear-PSM introduces several key innovations:

  • Full Database Search Strategy: Unlike traditional methods that restrict mass errors or search specific modification combinations, Dear-PSM removes these limitations. It aims to match every experimental spectrum against all possible peptides in the database, significantly broadening the search scope.
  • Experimental Spectra Inverted Index: Instead of building a massive index of theoretical peptide fragments (which consumes significant memory), Dear-PSM creates an inverted index of the experimental spectra. This index maps fragment ions to the spectra they appear in, drastically reducing memory requirements.
  • Deep Learning for Peptide Validation: After initial matching, Dear-PSM employs deep learning models to validate the PSMs. This includes predicting peptide retention times (which are relatively stable and can improve accuracy) and generating a final "discriminant score" to distinguish true peptides from false positives. This approach is more robust than traditional scoring methods.
  • Expanded Variable Modification Support: Dear-PSM supports up to 20 variable modifications per peptide, allowing for a vastly larger search space of potential peptide forms compared to the conventional 3-20.

Datasets

The study utilized several publicly available datasets for benchmarking and evaluation:

  • PXD028735: A mixed-species dataset from Thermo Orbitrap instruments.
  • PXD001468: A human species dataset.
  • PXD041271: A human phosphorylation modification dataset.

These datasets were chosen to represent diverse instruments, species, and experimental conditions, including complex modification scenarios. The protein sequence databases were obtained from UniProtKB/Swiss-Prot.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The Power of "Looking Everywhere": By removing restrictive mass error tolerances and embracing a full database search, Dear-PSM demonstrates that a more comprehensive search can uncover a significant number of peptides and proteins that are missed by conventional methods. This is particularly important for identifying "dark matter" in proteomics.
  • Memory Efficiency Through Inverted Spectra Index: The clever use of an inverted index for experimental spectra, rather than theoretical ones, is a major breakthrough. This allows for a much larger search space without the prohibitive memory demands that plague other comprehensive search strategies.
  • Deep Learning as a Powerful Validator: The application of deep learning for peptide validation, especially for retention time prediction and discriminant scoring, proves to be highly effective. It allows for more accurate discrimination between true and false positives, even with complex datasets.
  • Unlocking Complex Modifications: The ability to handle up to 20 variable modifications per peptide is crucial for studying post-translational modifications (PTMs) like phosphorylation, which are key to cellular signaling and function.

Key Results

  • Speed and Memory: Dear-PSM is 7 times faster than mainstream search engines on a regular desktop computer and achieves a remarkable 240-fold reduction in memory consumption.
  • Coverage: In full database search mode, Dear-PSM reproduces over 90% of results from mainstream engines like MSFragger and Sage.
  • Discovery: Dear-PSM consistently uncovers a substantial number of new peptides and proteins that are missed by other search engines, particularly in full database search mode. For example, on one dataset, it discovered 20% more peptides than MSFragger and 13% more than Sage.
  • Modification Handling: Dear-PSM can identify peptides with up to 8 variable modifications, whereas MSFragger and Sage are limited to 3, showcasing its superior capability in handling complex modifications.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Computational Resources: While significantly more memory-efficient than some alternatives, full database searches inherently require substantial computational resources. The paper mentions that MSFragger's memory usage can reach hundreds of gigabytes in certain scenarios, and Dear-PSM, while much better, still relies on efficient hardware.
  • Dataset-Specific Training: The deep learning models are trained on each experimental dataset individually to ensure performance consistency. This means that for new datasets, retraining is necessary, which adds a computational step.
  • Future Work: The authors have publicly released Dear-PSM on GitHub, encouraging further development and application. Future work could involve optimizing the deep learning models further, exploring even more complex modification scenarios, or integrating Dear-PSM into broader bioinformatics workflows. The paper also highlights the potential for Dear-PSM to uncover longer peptide sequences, suggesting further exploration in that area.

Summary updated

Abstract

Peptide spectrum matching is the process of linking mass spectrometry data with peptide sequences. An experimental spectrum can match thousands of candidate peptides with variable modifications leading to an exponential increase in candidates. Completing the search within a limited time is a key challenge. Traditional searches expedite the process by restricting peptide mass errors and variable modifications, but this limits interpretive capability. To address this challenge, we propose Dear-PSM, a peptide search engine that supports full database searching. Dear-PSM does not restrict peptide mass errors, matching each spectrum to all peptides in the database and increasing the number of variable modifications per peptide from the conventional 3-20. Leveraging inverted index technology, Dear-PSM creates a high-performance index table of experimental spectra and utilizes deep learning algorithms for peptide validation. Through these techniques, Dear-PSM achieves a speed breakthrough 7 times faster than mainstream search engines on a regular desktop computer, with a remarkable 240-fold reduction in memory consumption. Benchmark test results demonstrate that Dear-PSM, in full database search mode, can reproduce over 90% of the results obtained by mainstream search engines when handling complex mass spectrometry data collected from different species using various instruments. Furthermore, it uncovers a substantial number of new peptides and proteins. Dear-PSM has been publicly released on the GitHub repository https://github.com/jianweishuai/Dear-PSM.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{he2024dearpsm,
  author = {Qingzu He and Li Xiang and Jinjin Zhong and Gen Yang and Jiahuai Han and Jianwei Shuai},
  title = {{Dear‐PSM: A deep learning‐based peptide search engine enables full database search for proteomics}},
  booktitle = {Smart},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.1002/smmd.20240014},
}
Figure