Dear reviewers: Responses to common reviewer critiques about infant neuroimaging studies

Marta Korom, M. Catalina Camacho, Courtney A. Filippi, Roxane Licandro, Lucille A. Moore, Alexander J. Dufford, Lilla Zöllei, Alice M. Graham, Marisa N. Spann, Brittany Howell, Sarah Shultz, Dustin ScheinostDevelopmental 2021 · DOI

TL;DR

Infant neuroimaging is a rapidly evolving field with unique challenges compared to adult neuroimaging. This paper addresses common critiques from ethics boards, grant reviewers, and manuscript reviewers by providing a comprehensive Q&A resource for researchers and reviewers, aiming to foster transparency and establish best practices.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The field of infant neuroimaging, while yielding groundbreaking insights into early brain development, lacks the standardized protocols and established best practices common in adult neuroimaging. This immaturity leads to frequent critiques from ethics boards, grant reviewers, and manuscript reviewers regarding safety, study design, data acquisition, and analysis. These critiques, while important for rigor, can sometimes stifle progress if not understood within the context of the field's inherent challenges. This paper aims to bridge this gap by providing clear, evidence-based responses to these common critiques, fostering a more productive dialogue and guiding the field toward greater standardization.

Methods

This paper is not a traditional research study with novel methods or datasets. Instead, it functions as a comprehensive review and expert consensus document. The authors, members of the Fetal, Infant, and Toddler Neuroimaging Group (FIT'NG), address 20 common questions categorized by when they arise in the research lifecycle: ethics board reviews (infant safety), grant reviews (study planning and data acquisition), and manuscript reviews (data processing and interpretation). For each question, they provide detailed answers drawing from existing literature, highlighting best practices, acknowledging limitations, and offering practical advice. Key citations are provided in a table for further reference.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Infant neuroimaging is inherently more complex: Unlike adult studies, infant research must contend with unique challenges like participant safety, comfort, motion, and the rapid pace of brain development, necessitating specialized approaches.
  • Safety is paramount and multifaceted: Beyond basic MRI safety, infant studies require meticulous attention to hearing protection, temperature regulation, and secure positioning to ensure participant well-being.
  • Standardization is a work in progress: The field is actively developing and refining methodologies for data acquisition (e.g., specific MRI sequences, hardware considerations), processing (e.g., adapting adult pipelines, developing infant-specific tools), and analysis.
  • Reviewer critiques are valuable but require context: Understanding the rationale behind common critiques, such as sample size or hardware choices, is crucial for both researchers and reviewers to navigate the field's limitations and potential.
  • Open science is key to maturation: Sharing data and code, and developing community-driven standards, are essential for accelerating progress and building robust, reproducible infant neuroimaging research.

Key Results

The paper doesn't present quantitative results in the traditional sense. Instead, its "results" are the detailed answers and recommendations provided for each of the 20 questions. These include:

  • Safety Protocols: Detailed descriptions of monitoring procedures (physiological, visual, auditory), hearing protection strategies (earplugs, earmuffs, acoustic hoods), SAR limit considerations, temperature management, and methods for preventing infants from rolling off the table.
  • Study Design & Acquisition: Guidance on hardware choices (adult vs. infant-specific coils), harmonizing data across scanners, selecting appropriate anatomical sequences (T1 vs. T2), justifying small sample sizes, and the potential of infant neuroimaging to predict later behavior.
  • Data Processing & Interpretation: Discussions on the impact of sleep on functional data, the comparability of neuronal-hemodynamic coupling to adults, methods for measuring myelination, why adult processing standards often need adaptation for infants, and the importance of open science practices.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations:

  • Focus on healthy, at-term infants: The advice is primarily tailored to this population, and special considerations for higher-risk groups (e.g., infants exposed to substances in-utero) are not discussed.
  • Geographic scope: The guidance reflects experiences primarily from US and European institutions, and ethical/legal requirements may differ in other regions.
  • Depth of technical detail: While providing broad guidance, the paper doesn't delve into the fine-tuning of specific MRI sequences, as this requires specialized expertise.
  • Rapidly evolving field: Infant neuroimaging is constantly advancing, meaning standards and best practices will continue to evolve.

Future work suggested by the paper includes:

  • Continued development of field-wide standards for data collection, processing, and analysis.
  • Further research into neurovascular coupling in infants and tailored HRF estimation methods.
  • More work to characterize the prevalence and clinical significance of incidental findings at different infant ages.
  • Increased adoption of open science practices to foster transparency and collaboration.

Summary updated

Abstract

The field of adult neuroimaging relies on well-established principles in research design, imaging sequences, processing pipelines, as well as safety and data collection protocols. The field of infant magnetic resonance imaging, by comparison, is a young field with tremendous scientific potential but continuously evolving standards. The present article aims to initiate a constructive dialog between researchers who grapple with the challenges and inherent limitations of a nascent field and reviewers who evaluate their work. We address 20 questions that researchers commonly receive from research ethics boards, grant, and manuscript reviewers related to infant neuroimaging data collection, safety protocols, study planning, imaging sequences, decisions related to software and hardware, and data processing and sharing, while acknowledging both the accomplishments of the field and areas of much needed future advancements. This article reflects the cumulative knowledge of experts in the FIT'NG community and can act as a resource for both researchers and reviewers alike seeking a deeper understanding of the standards and tradeoffs involved in infant neuroimaging.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{korom2021dear,
  author = {Marta Korom and M. Catalina Camacho and Courtney A. Filippi and Roxane Licandro and Lucille A. Moore and Alexander J. Dufford and Lilla Zöllei and Alice M. Graham and Marisa N. Spann and Brittany Howell and Sarah Shultz and Dustin Scheinost},
  title = {{Dear reviewers: Responses to common reviewer critiques about infant neuroimaging studies}},
  booktitle = {Developmental},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.1016/j.dcn.2021.101055},
}
Figure