Dealing with All-stage Missing Modality: Towards A Universal Model with Robust Reconstruction and Personalization

Yunpeng Zhao, Cheng Chen, Qing You Pang, Quanzheng Li, Carol Tang, Beng-Ti Ang, Yueming JinarXiv 2024 · DOI · OpenReview

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel "all-stage" approach to multimodal learning that tackles missing data during both training and inference, a significant limitation of prior work. Their method uses a multimodal masked autoencoder for robust modality reconstruction and a CLIP-driven hyper-network for personalized model adaptation, achieving state-of-the-art results on brain tumor segmentation.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Multimodal learning, which combines information from different data sources (like various MRI scans), is crucial for accurate medical diagnosis and treatment. However, in real-world scenarios, it's common for one or more modalities to be missing, either during training or inference. Existing methods often assume complete data for training and only handle missing modalities during inference. This reliance on complete training data limits their ability to leverage the vast amounts of incomplete data available, hindering performance. The core challenge is to build a universal model that can effectively learn from and predict with incomplete data at all stages of the machine learning pipeline, regardless of the missing modality combinations or their ratios.

Methods

The proposed solution, termed "all-stage missing modality," is built upon three key innovations:

  1. Multimodal Masked Autoencoder (MAE) with Distribution Approximation: To address the information loss from missing modalities, the authors employ a MAE. This model is trained to reconstruct both missing modalities and masked patches within the available modalities. The novelty lies in a "distribution approximation mechanism" that allows the MAE to effectively learn from both complete and incomplete training data by implicitly guiding the reconstruction process towards more informative, tumor-centric representations.
  2. Data-Model Co-distillation: To leverage the reconstructed modalities and mitigate potential noise from synthesized data, a co-distillation scheme is introduced. This involves a learnable "modality recovering module" (initialized by the MAE) that synthesizes missing modalities. A frozen "teacher model" uses these synthesized full modalities, while a "student segmentation model" learns from modality-dropped inputs. This process effectively transfers knowledge from the synthesized complete data to the student model.
  3. CLIP-Driven Hyper-network for Model Personalization: To handle the heterogeneity introduced by different missing modality combinations, a CLIP-driven hyper-network is proposed. This network takes textual prompts describing the available modalities (generated using CLIP) and visual features to personalize a subset of the segmentation model's parameters. This allows the model to adapt its predictions to specific missing modality scenarios during both training and inference.

Datasets

The proposed method was evaluated on two widely-used brain tumor segmentation benchmarks:

  • BraTS2018
  • BraTS2020

These datasets contain multimodal MRI scans (FLAIR, T1, T1c, T2) and corresponding ground truth segmentation labels for different tumor regions (whole tumor, tumor core, enhancing tumor). The authors followed standard data splits for training, validation, and testing.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • "All-stage" is Crucial: The paper strongly emphasizes that addressing missing modalities only during inference is insufficient. Effectively utilizing incomplete data during training is key to achieving robust performance.
  • Auxiliary Supervision for Reconstruction: The distribution approximation in the MAE acts as a form of auxiliary supervision, guiding the reconstruction process to focus on relevant tumor information even when ground truth is unavailable for some modalities.
  • Hyper-network for Personalization: The heterogeneity of missing modalities creates distinct data distributions. A hyper-network, informed by CLIP's understanding of modalities, provides a flexible way to adapt the model to these variations without needing separate models for each scenario.
  • CLIP's Semantic Understanding: Using CLIP for modality prompts is more effective than simple binary codes because CLIP can capture semantic relationships between different MRI modalities, leading to better personalization.

Key Results

The proposed "all-stage" model consistently outperformed state-of-the-art methods across various missing modality settings and ratios on both BraTS2018 and BraTS2020 datasets.

  • Superior Performance: The method achieved superior performance compared to RFNet, M³AE, and Meta-learning across different full modality (FM) ratios (1%, 10%, 50%, 100%).
  • Robustness to Low FM Ratios: Even with only 1% full modality data during training, the proposed model achieved comparable or superior results to other methods trained with 100% full modality data.
  • Ablation Studies:
    • The distribution approximation in the MAE improved performance by 1.43%.
  • Adding the CLIP-driven hyper-network further boosted performance by 2.31%.
  • Data-model co-distillation contributed an additional 2.49% advantage.
  • The CLIP-driven hyper-network with binary modality codes showed a 0.38% improvement, while using CLIP text embeddings increased the average DSC by 0.5%.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Computational Cost: While not explicitly stated as a limitation, the complexity of the proposed framework (MAE pre-training, co-distillation, hyper-network) likely implies a higher computational cost compared to simpler methods.
  • Generalizability to Other Modalities/Tasks: The paper focuses on brain tumor segmentation. Future work could explore the applicability of this "all-stage" approach to other medical imaging tasks or different types of modalities.
  • Hyper-parameter Tuning: The effectiveness of the distribution approximation factor ($\lambda$) and the weights for data refining ($\alpha$) and knowledge distillation ($\beta$) might require careful tuning for different datasets or tasks.
  • Further Exploration of Hyper-network: While CLIP-driven hyper-networks show promise, further research could investigate alternative or more advanced methods for generating personalized parameters.

Summary updated

Abstract

Addressing missing modalities presents a critical challenge in multimodal learning. Current approaches focus on developing models that can handle modality-incomplete inputs during inference, assuming that the full set of modalities are available for all the data during training. This reliance on full-modality data for training limits the use of abundant modality-incomplete samples that are often encountered in practical settings. In this paper, we propose a robust universal model with modality reconstruction and model personalization, which can effectively tackle the missing modality at both training and testing stages. Our method leverages a multimodal masked autoencoder to reconstruct the missing modality and masked patches simultaneously, incorporating an innovative distribution approximation mechanism to fully utilize both modality-complete and modality-incomplete data. The reconstructed modalities then contributes to our designed data-model co-distillation scheme to guide the model learning in the presence of missing modalities. Moreover, we propose a CLIP-driven hyper-network to personalize partial model parameters, enabling the model to adapt to each distinct missing modality scenario. Our method has been extensively validated on two brain tumor segmentation benchmarks. Experimental results demonstrate the promising performance of our method, which consistently exceeds previous state-of-the-art approaches under the all-stage missing modality settings with different missing ratios. Code will be available.
BibTeX
@misc{zhao2024dealing,
  author = {Yunpeng Zhao and Cheng Chen and Qing You Pang and Quanzheng Li and Carol Tang and Beng-Ti Ang and Yueming Jin},
  title = {{Dealing with All-stage Missing Modality: Towards A Universal Model with Robust Reconstruction and Personalization}},
  year = {2024},
  eprint = {2406.01987},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2406.01987},
}
Figure