De-carbonization of global energy use during the COVID-19 pandemic

Zhu Liu, Biqing Zhu, Philippe Ciais, Steven J. Davis, Chenxi Lu, Haiwang Zhong, Piyu Ke, Yanan Cui, Zhu Deng, Duo Cui, Taochun Sun, Xinyu Dou, Jianguang Tan, Rui Guo, Bo Zheng, Katsumasa Tanaka, Wenli Zhao, Pierre GentinearXiv 2021 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract

The COVID-19 pandemic has disrupted human activities, leading to unprecedented decreases in both global energy demand and GHG emissions. Yet it is little known that there was also a significant low-carbon shift in the global energy system in 2020. Using near-real-time data on energy-related GHG emissions from 30 countries (representing about 70% of global power generation), this study shows that the pandemic caused an unprecedented de-carbonization of the global power system. This was characterized by a dramatic decrease in the carbon intensity of the power sector, which reached a historical low of 414.9 tCO2eq/GWh in 2020. Moreover, the share of energy derived from renewable and low-carbon sources (nuclear, hydro-energy, wind, solar, geothermal, and biomass) exceeded that from coal and oil for the first time in history in May 2020. The decrease in global net energy demand (-1.3% in the first half of 2020 relative to the 2016-2019 average) masks a large down-regulation of fossil-fuel-burning power plants (-6.1%) coincident with a surge of low-carbon sources (+6.2%). Concomitant changes in the diurnal cycle of electricity demand also favored low-carbon generators, including a flattening of the morning ramp and a lower midday peak. However, emission intensities have since rebounded, raising critical questions about maintaining pandemic-level carbon intensities as part of a green recovery.

Introduction: Activity vs. Structural Change

While the plummeting of CO2 emissions during 2020 lockdowns was widely reported, the underlying mechanics of the global power sector remained opaque due to significant time lags in traditional energy data. This research addresses whether the emission drop was solely due to reduced consumption (an "activity" change) or a fundamental shift in the grid's composition (a "structural" change). Understanding this distinction is vital for climate mitigation, revealing how the grid behaves under extreme stress and whether such low carbon intensities can be maintained post-pandemic.

Methodology and Data Integration

The study integrated sub-hourly, hourly, and daily electricity data from 30 countries, covering 70% of global generation. Key sources included the U.S. EIA, Europe's ENTSO-E, and national data from China, India, Brazil, and Japan. The team employed several analytical techniques:

  • LMDI Decomposition: To separate monthly emission changes into "Activity" and "Structure" drivers.
  • Temperature Normalization: Using a Least-Squares Regression Model to filter out weather-induced demand fluctuations.
  • Life-Cycle Assessment (LCA): Applying IPCC life-cycle emission factors to account for the full carbon footprint of energy production.

Key Results: Historical Lows and the May Milestone

The analysis confirms that 2020 saw a record-breaking de-carbonization of the global power system. Global carbon intensity hit a historical low of 414.9 tCO2eq/GWh. A pivotal moment occurred in May 2020, when low-carbon sources reached a 47% share of total production, surpassing coal and oil combined for the first time.

Figure 3: Trends in global carbon intensity and energy mix (1970-2020), showing the sharp decline in 2020.

The overall emission drop was driven by a combination of decreased activity (59%) and improved energy structure (41%). While fossil fuel supply contracted by 6.1%, low-carbon sources surged by 6.2% in the first half of the year, aided by favorable weather for wind and solar.

Analysis of Energy Dynamics: Fossil Fuels as the Marginal Source

The pandemic highlighted that fossil fuels often act as the "marginal" source in the power grid. Due to the near-zero marginal costs of solar and wind, grid operators prioritized these sources, down-regulating coal and gas plants as demand fell. This vulnerability suggests coal may be nearing an economic tipping point.

Figure 6: Monthly electricity production by source in 2020 vs. historical averages, highlighting the down-regulation of fossil fuels.

Furthermore, the shift to remote work flattened the "morning ramp" of electricity demand and delayed the midday peak. This behavioral change aligned human activity more closely with peak solar radiation, creating a unique synergy that further favored renewable generation.

Conclusion and Future Outlook

The "low-carbon shift" observed in 2020 was largely transient, with fossil fuel generation rebounding quickly as lockdowns eased. The core challenge for climate policy is maintaining these lower intensities without economic disruption. The authors emphasize that focused investments in energy storage and renewables during the recovery phase are essential to prevent a return to pre-pandemic emission levels. Future work will require higher-resolution data from developing regions and more granular, country-specific emission factors.

Summary updated

Abstract

The COVID-19 pandemic has disrupted human activities, leading to unprecedented decreases in both global energy demand and GHG emissions. Yet a little known that there is also a low carbon shift of the global energy system in 2020. Here, using the near-real-time data on energy-related GHG emissions from 30 countries (about 70% of global power generation), we show that the pandemic caused an unprecedented de-carbonization of global power system, representing by a dramatic decrease in the carbon intensity of power sector that reached a historical low of 414.9 tCO2eq/GWh in 2020. Moreover, the share of energy derived from renewable and low-carbon sources (nuclear, hydro-energy, wind, solar, geothermal, and biomass) exceeded that from coal and oil for the first time in history in May of 2020. The decrease in global net energy demand (-1.3% in the first half of 2020 relative to the average of the period in 2016-2019) masks a large down-regulation of fossil-fuel-burning power plants supply (-6.1%) coincident with a surge of low-carbon sources (+6.2%). Concomitant changes in the diurnal cycle of electricity demand also favored low-carbon generators, including a flattening of the morning ramp, a lower midday peak, and delays in both the morning and midday load peaks in most countries. However, emission intensities in the power sector have since rebounded in many countries, and a key question for climate mitigation is thus to what extent countries can achieve and maintain lower, pandemic-level carbon intensities of electricity as part of a green recovery.
BibTeX
@misc{liu2021de,
  author = {Zhu Liu and Biqing Zhu and Philippe Ciais and Steven J. Davis and Chenxi Lu and Haiwang Zhong and Piyu Ke and Yanan Cui and Zhu Deng and Duo Cui and Taochun Sun and Xinyu Dou and Jianguang Tan and Rui Guo and Bo Zheng and Katsumasa Tanaka and Wenli Zhao and Pierre Gentine},
  title = {{De-carbonization of global energy use during the COVID-19 pandemic}},
  year = {2021},
  eprint = {2102.03240},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2102.03240},
}

Loading related content...

Figure