DBD Plasma Combined with Different Foam Metal Electrodes for CO2 Decomposition: Experimental Results and DFT Validations

Ju Li, Xingwu Zhai, Cunhua Ma, Shengjie Zhu, Feng Yu, Bin Dai, Guixian Ge, Dezheng YangNanomaterials 2019 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper explores using dielectric barrier discharge (DBD) plasma combined with foam metal electrodes (Fe, Al, Ti) to efficiently decompose CO2 into valuable CO. The study demonstrates that these foam metal catalysts significantly enhance CO2 conversion and energy efficiency compared to a non-packed reactor, with foam titanium showing the best performance. Density Functional Theory (DFT) calculations further validate these findings by revealing a lower CO2 adsorption energy barrier on titanium surfaces.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The escalating levels of atmospheric carbon dioxide (CO2) are a major driver of global warming, necessitating effective strategies for its utilization and conversion. While direct thermal decomposition of CO2 into carbon monoxide (CO) and oxygen (O2) is possible, it requires extremely high temperatures (over 2000 K), making it an energy-intensive process. Non-thermal plasma (NTP) techniques, particularly dielectric barrier discharge (DBD) plasma, offer a promising alternative for CO2 decomposition at lower temperatures, reducing energy costs. However, optimizing the efficiency and conversion rates of DBD plasma for CO2 splitting remains a challenge. This paper addresses the need for improved catalysts and reactor designs to enhance CO2 decomposition efficiency within DBD plasma systems.

Methods

The researchers developed a coaxial DBD reactor for CO2 splitting. They investigated the effect of packing the discharge gap with different foam metal materials: iron (Fe), aluminum (Al), and titanium (Ti). These foam metals were chosen as potential catalysts. The experimental setup included a plasma generator, the DBD reactor, and a gas chromatograph (GC) for analyzing the gas products. Key parameters like discharge power and gas flow velocity were systematically varied to assess their impact on CO2 conversion and CO yield. Discharge characteristics, such as voltage and current waveforms and Lissajous figures, were monitored to understand how the foam metals influenced the plasma behavior. To complement the experimental findings, Density Functional Theory (DFT) calculations were employed to investigate the CO2 adsorption energies on the surfaces of Ti, Al, and Fe, specifically focusing on their dominant crystallographic planes.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Foam Metals as Catalysts: The introduction of foam metals (Fe, Al, Ti) into the DBD reactor significantly alters the discharge characteristics, transitioning from a purely filamentary discharge to a combination of surface and filamentary discharges. This change in plasma behavior is crucial for enhancing CO2 decomposition.
  • Titanium's Superior Performance: Among the tested foam metals, titanium (Ti) consistently demonstrated the highest CO2 decomposition rate and energy efficiency. This suggests a specific catalytic advantage of titanium in this process.
  • DFT Validation: DFT calculations provided a theoretical basis for the experimental observations. The significantly lower CO2 adsorption energy on the (101) plane of Ti compared to Al and Fe explains why Ti acts as a more effective catalyst, facilitating CO2 dissociation.
  • Synergistic Effect: The combination of DBD plasma and foam metal catalysts creates a synergistic effect, where the plasma generates reactive species, and the catalyst surface promotes their interaction with CO2, leading to enhanced decomposition.
  • Trade-off between Conversion and Efficiency: The study highlights a common trade-off in plasma processes: increasing discharge power generally boosts CO2 conversion but often leads to a decrease in energy efficiency. This necessitates careful optimization of operating parameters.

Key Results

  • Enhanced CO2 Conversion: With foam metal packing, CO2 conversion rates were significantly higher than in the non-packed reactor. The maximum CO2 conversion increased from 21.15% (without packing) to 44.84% (foam Fe), 44.02% (foam Al), and 46.61% (foam Ti).
  • Improved Energy Efficiency: Similarly, energy efficiency saw substantial improvements. It rose from 3.92% (without packing) to 6.86% (foam Fe), 6.19% (foam Al), and 8.85% (foam Ti).
  • Foam Ti Dominance: Foam Ti achieved the highest CO2 decomposition rate (46.61%) and energy efficiency (8.85%) among the tested materials.
  • Discharge Pattern Change: The presence of foam metals shifted the discharge pattern from filamentary to a combination of current filamentary and surface discharge.
  • DFT Adsorption Energies: DFT calculations showed CO2 adsorption energies of -2.49 eV for Ti (101 plane), -0.54 eV for Al (111 plane), and -0.06 eV for Fe (110 plane), indicating Ti's superior ability to adsorb CO2.

Limitations and Future Work

The paper acknowledges that achieving both high CO2 conversion and high energy efficiency simultaneously is challenging. The study focused on specific foam metal types and DBD reactor configurations. Future work could explore:

  • Optimization of Foam Metal Properties: Investigating different pore sizes, surface treatments, or composite foam metals to further enhance catalytic activity.
  • Reactor Design Variations: Exploring other DBD reactor geometries or integration with different plasma sources.
  • Mechanism Elucidation: Deeper investigation into the specific reaction pathways and the role of active species generated in the plasma and on the catalyst surface.
  • Long-term Stability: Assessing the long-term stability and durability of the foam metal catalysts under continuous operation.
  • Scale-up: Evaluating the feasibility of scaling up this technology for industrial applications.

Summary updated

Abstract

In the last few years, due to the large amount of greenhouse gas emissions causing environmental issue like global warming, methods for the full consumption and utilization of greenhouse gases such as carbon dioxide (CO<sub>2</sub>) have attracted great attention. In this study, a packed-bed dielectric barrier discharge (DBD) coaxial reactor has been developed and applied to split CO<sub>2</sub> into industrial fuel carbon monoxide (CO). Different packing materials (foam Fe, Al, and Ti) were placed into the discharge gap of the DBD reactor, and then CO<sub>2</sub> conversion was investigated. The effects of power, flow velocity, and other discharge characteristics of CO<sub>2</sub> conversion were studied to understand the influence of the filling catalysts on CO<sub>2</sub> splitting. Experimental results showed that the filling of foam metals in the reactor caused changes in discharge characteristics and discharge patterns, from the original filamentary discharge to the current filamentary discharge as well as surface discharge. Compared with the maximum CO<sub>2</sub> conversion of 21.15% and energy efficiency of 3.92% in the reaction tube without the foam metal materials, a maximum CO<sub>2</sub> decomposition rate of 44.84%, 44.02%, and 46.61% and energy efficiency of 6.86%, 6.19%, and 8.85% were obtained in the reaction tubes packed with foam Fe, Al, and Ti, respectively. The CO<sub>2</sub> conversion rate for reaction tubes filled with the foam metal materials was clearly enhanced compared to the non-packed tubes. It could be seen that the foam Ti had the best CO<sub>2</sub> decomposition rate among the three foam metals. Furthermore, we used density functional theory to further verify the experimental results. The results indicated that CO<sub>2</sub> adsorption had a lower activation energy barrier on the foam Ti surface. The theoretical calculation was consistent with the experimental results, which better explain the mechanism of CO<sub>2</sub> decomposition.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{li2019dbd,
  author = {Ju Li and Xingwu Zhai and Cunhua Ma and Shengjie Zhu and Feng Yu and Bin Dai and Guixian Ge and Dezheng Yang},
  title = {{DBD Plasma Combined with Different Foam Metal Electrodes for CO2 Decomposition: Experimental Results and DFT Validations}},
  booktitle = {Nanomaterials},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.3390/nano9111595},
}
Figure