Datasets for Studying Generalization from Easy to Hard Examples

Avi Schwarzschild, Eitan Borgnia, Arjun Gupta, Arpit Bansal, Zeyad Emam, Furong Huang, Micah Goldblum, Tom GoldsteinarXiv 2021 · OpenReview

TL;DR

This paper introduces three new datasets—Prefix Sums, Mazes, and Chess Puzzles—designed to help researchers develop AI systems that can generalize from simple training examples to more complex ones. By providing a structured way to test extrapolation capabilities, these datasets aim to drive progress in building more robust and adaptable AI.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Many current AI models excel at tasks similar to their training data but struggle to generalize to slightly harder or out-of-distribution examples. This "brittle" generalization is a significant hurdle for deploying AI in real-world scenarios where conditions are rarely identical to training. The authors highlight the need for AI systems that can truly "learn" and extrapolate, rather than just memorize patterns. They aim to facilitate research into this area by creating accessible benchmarks that specifically test this generalization capability.

Methods

The paper doesn't introduce novel algorithms but focuses on creating structured datasets. The core "method" is the careful design and generation of these datasets to specifically probe generalization.

  • Prefix Sums: This dataset involves binary sequences. Models are trained on shorter sequences and tested on longer ones, requiring them to learn the cumulative sum logic rather than memorizing specific sequences.
  • Mazes: This dataset presents images of mazes with solutions marked. The challenge lies in generalizing pathfinding from smaller mazes to larger ones, or from mazes with certain structures to others.
  • Chess Puzzles: This dataset uses chess board configurations as input and the optimal next move as output. The difficulty is varied, allowing models to be tested on their ability to generalize chess strategy from simpler positions to more complex ones.

Datasets

The paper introduces three new benchmark datasets:

  • Prefix Sums: Consists of binary strings and their cumulative sums modulo two. It offers varying input lengths (from 16 to 512 bits) to create a spectrum of difficulty.
  • Mazes: Contains images of mazes and segmentation maps indicating the shortest path. Datasets are generated for different maze sizes (e.g., 5x5, 9x9, 13x13, 21x21) to test generalization across spatial complexity.
  • Chess Puzzles: Leverages Lichess's open puzzle database. It provides chess board states (encoded as multi-channel images) and the corresponding best next move. Puzzles are categorized by difficulty (Elo rating).

A Python package is also provided to make these datasets easily accessible for training and testing.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The Need for Structured Generalization Benchmarks: The paper argues that current benchmarks often don't sufficiently isolate and test the ability to generalize from easy to hard examples. The proposed datasets aim to fill this gap.
  • Toy Problems for Focused Research: Simple, well-defined problems like Prefix Sums are crucial for understanding fundamental learning mechanisms before tackling more complex, real-world tasks.
  • Bridging Abstract Concepts to Visual Representations: The Mazes and Chess Puzzles datasets demonstrate how abstract problems (pathfinding, game strategy) can be represented visually, making them amenable to deep learning approaches while still posing generalization challenges.
  • Difficulty as a Gradual Scale: By offering variations in input size (Prefix Sums, Mazes) or explicit difficulty ratings (Chess Puzzles), the datasets allow for a nuanced evaluation of how models' generalization capabilities improve with increasing complexity.

Key Results

The paper primarily focuses on introducing and describing the datasets, rather than presenting empirical results from training models on them. The "key results" are the datasets themselves and their design principles. The authors state that the datasets are intended to "motivate and facilitate novel research."

Limitations and Future Work

  • Simplifications in Chess: The paper acknowledges that the Chess Puzzles dataset omits certain game rules like castling rights and en passant for convenience. This simplification means models trained on this dataset might not fully capture the nuances of a complete chess engine.
  • Focus on Specific Generalization: The datasets are designed to test generalization from easy to hard within a specific task domain. They may not cover all forms of generalization (e.g., out-of-domain generalization to entirely new tasks).
  • Future Work: The authors suggest that the provided Python package and code are designed to be easily modifiable, encouraging users to create variations of the standard benchmark problems and explore new research directions. They hope these datasets will spur research into AI systems that exhibit more robust and human-like generalization.

Summary updated

Abstract

We describe new datasets for studying generalization from easy to hard examples.
BibTeX
@misc{schwarzschild2021datasets,
  author = {Avi Schwarzschild and Eitan Borgnia and Arjun Gupta and Arpit Bansal and Zeyad Emam and Furong Huang and Micah Goldblum and Tom Goldstein},
  title = {{Datasets for Studying Generalization from Easy to Hard Examples}},
  year = {2021},
  eprint = {2108.06011},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2108.06011},
}
Figure