Data reduction for weighted and outlier-resistant clustering

Dan Feldman, Leonard J. SchulmanSODA 2012 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel algorithmic framework for data reduction, specifically for weighted and outlier-resistant clustering problems. The core contribution is the efficient construction of "core-sets" – smaller, representative datasets that allow for approximate solutions to complex optimization problems, significantly improving computational efficiency. This work bridges a gap in existing literature by providing a unified approach for a variety of robust statistical estimation and clustering tasks.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Statistical data often contains outliers, which can severely distort the results of standard estimation and clustering algorithms. While robust statistical methods exist to mitigate outlier effects, algorithmic results for clustering with outliers have been limited. Specifically, problems like "k-median with outliers" and weighted clustering variants pose significant computational challenges. The core issue is efficiently finding approximate solutions to these problems, which often involves dealing with a large number of data points and complex loss functions. The paper addresses the need for efficient "data reduction" techniques, where a large dataset is compressed into a smaller "core-set" that preserves the essential information for optimization.

Methods

The paper's central technical contribution is a randomized algorithm for constructing core-sets for a broad class of "tractable" optimization problems. A problem is considered tractable if its associated loss function satisfies certain monotonicity and log-log Lipschitz conditions, and if a weak triangle inequality holds. The authors leverage a recursive approach, "Recursive-Robust-Median," which iteratively identifies and removes "dense" clusters from the data. This process, combined with insights from Vapnik-Chervonenkis (VC) dimension theory, allows them to bound the sensitivity of data points and construct core-sets with provably small sizes. The core-set construction algorithm is designed to be efficient, with a runtime that depends polynomially on the desired approximation error ($\epsilon$) and logarithmically on the number of data points ($n$), and crucially, only polynomially on the number of clusters ($k$).

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The paper focuses on theoretical algorithmic results and does not present experimental evaluations on specific datasets.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Unified Framework for Robustness: The paper provides a single algorithmic framework that can handle a variety of outlier-resistant statistical estimators (like Huber and Tukey loss functions) and clustering problems, unifying previously disparate algorithmic challenges.
  • Core-sets for Weighted Problems: A significant breakthrough is the ability to construct core-sets for weighted clustering problems. This was a known open problem, and its solution is crucial for many applications.
  • Efficiency Through Data Reduction: The core idea of data reduction via core-sets is powerful. By compressing data, complex optimization algorithms can be run on much smaller inputs, leading to significant speedups.
  • Tractability as a Key Property: Defining "tractability" for loss functions provides a clear criterion for when their core-set construction techniques can be applied, offering a principled way to extend their results.
  • Recursive Clustering for Sensitivity Bounding: The recursive removal of dense clusters is an elegant way to bound the sensitivity of points, which is key to the core-set construction.

Key Results

  • Core-set Size: The paper shows that for a broad class of problems, core-sets of size $O(\frac{k^2 \log^2 n}{\epsilon^2} (\Delta \log^2 n))$ can be constructed, where $\Delta$ is related to the VC dimension of the problem. For many common scenarios, this size is near-optimal.
  • Runtime Efficiency: The core-set construction algorithm runs in near-linear time in the number of data points ($n$), with polynomial dependence on $k$ and logarithmic dependence on $n$. This is a significant improvement over previous methods that might have had exponential dependence on $k$.
  • Application to Specific Problems: As a corollary, the paper achieves improved data reduction for problems like k-median with penalties, weighted k-median, k-line median, and robust M-estimators (Huber, Tukey).
  • Optimal Results (in 1D): For the one-dimensional case, the core-set sizes achieved are shown to be optimal up to logarithmic factors.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Randomized Algorithm: The primary algorithm presented is randomized. While the paper mentions derandomization techniques, the core algorithm relies on random sampling.
  • Polynomial Dependence on k: While the dependence on $k$ is polynomial, for very large $k$, the core-set size and construction time can still become substantial.
  • VC Dimension Dependence: The size of the core-set depends on the VC dimension ($\Delta$) of the problem. For problems with very high VC dimensions, the core-set might still be large.
  • Future Work: The paper suggests exploring applications to other robust statistical estimators and clustering variants. Further investigation into deterministic core-set construction and improving the dependence on $k$ are also natural directions. The authors also highlight that their results are optimal in one dimension and pose the question of whether similar optimality can be achieved in higher dimensions.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{feldman2012data,
  author = {Dan Feldman and Leonard J. Schulman},
  title = {{Data reduction for weighted and outlier-resistant clustering}},
  booktitle = {SODA},
  year = {2012},
  doi = {10.1137/1.9781611973099.106},
}
Figure