Abstract
Applying security as a lifecycle practice is becoming increasingly important to combat targeted attacks in safety-critical systems. Among others there are two significant challenges in this area: (1) the need for models that can characterize a realistic system in the absence of an implementation and (2) an automated way to associate attack vector information; that is, historical data, to such system models. We propose the cybersecurity body of knowledge (CYBOK), which takes in sufficiently characteristic models of systems and acts as a search engine for potential attack vectors. CYBOK is fundamentally an algorithmic approach to vulnerability exploration, which is a significant extension to the body of knowledge it builds upon. By using CYBOK, security analysts and system designers can work together to assess the overall security posture of systems early in their lifecycle, during major design decisions and before final product designs. Consequently, assisting in applying security earlier and throughout the systems lifecycle.
The "Congruence Gap" in System Design
In Cyber-Physical Systems (CPS) like autonomous vehicles or smart grids, security is frequently treated as a post-hoc patch rather than a foundational design requirement. Research indicates that approximately 70% of security flaws originate during the design phase. Addressing these flaws early is hindered by a "congruence gap":
- Abstraction Mismatch: Design models (e.g., SysML) are high-level and abstract, whereas vulnerability databases (e.g., CVE) are highly specific to particular software/hardware versions.
- Manual Bottlenecks: Mapping these abstract designs to concrete threats currently requires intensive manual labor by security experts.
The CYBOK Methodology
The proposed Cybersecurity Body of Knowledge (CYBOK) framework automates this mapping, acting as a "search engine" for vulnerabilities during the design phase.
The process follows three primary stages:
- Graph-Based Modeling: The system is represented as a graph (Σ) where nodes are assets (sensors, processors) and edges represent data flows or dependencies.
- Keyword Augmentation: Designers add "extra design information"—keywords describing the intended hardware, OS, and protocols (e.g., "ARM Cortex", "ZigBee").
- Algorithmic Analysis: CYBOK employs NLP-based algorithms to match keywords against vulnerability databases, identifies entry points, and calculates potential lateral movement paths via exploit chains.
Data-Driven Vulnerability Mapping
CYBOK bridges the gap between design and implementation by leveraging curated security databases that vary in their platform specificity and perspective.
The framework utilizes three core MITRE collections:
- CVE (Common Vulnerabilities and Exposures): Records of specific historical vulnerabilities.
- CWE (Common Weakness Enumeration): A taxonomy of software and hardware weakness types.
- CAPEC (Common Attack Pattern Enumeration and Classification): Descriptions of attacker methodologies.
By focusing on these, CYBOK avoids the need for specific versioning data (CPE) which is typically unavailable during early design.
Case Study: Unmanned Aerial System (UAS)
The framework was validated using a UAS case study. CYBOK successfully identified specific risks like "String Format Overflow" (CAPEC-67) in radio modules and "Protocol Manipulation" (CAPEC-272) in communication lines. Crucially, the tool demonstrated how an attacker could pivot from a non-critical imagery radio module to the primary flight application processor, providing concrete evidence of systemic risk.
Conclusion and Future Work
CYBOK enables "what-if" security analysis, allowing designers to evaluate the security impact of hardware or protocol choices before procurement. However, challenges remain regarding keyword sensitivity—where results depend on the fidelity of designer input—and the potential for "data explosion" from massive vulnerability databases. Future efforts will focus on quantitative risk scoring and improved result filtering to prioritize mission-critical threats.
Summary updated