Dark Matter searches: the nightmare scenario

Gianfranco Bertone, Daniel T. Cumberbatch, Roberto Ruiz de Austri, Roberto TrottaJournal of Cosmology and Astroparticle Physics 2012 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract

This paper explores the implications of a "Nightmare Scenario" in particle physics: a hypothetical future where the Large Hadron Collider (LHC) reaches its design energy and luminosity without discovering any evidence of new physics beyond the Standard Model. Using a Bayesian global scan of the constrained Minimal Supersymmetric Standard Model (cMSSM), we evaluate whether dark matter remains detectable through non-collider experiments. Our analysis demonstrates that even if the LHC yields null results, next-generation ton-scale direct detection experiments provide a robust and potentially conclusive probe of the remaining WIMP parameter space.

Introduction

For decades, Supersymmetry (SUSY) has served as a primary candidate for physics Beyond the Standard Model (BSM), offering an elegant solution to the dark matter problem via the Weakly Interacting Massive Particle (WIMP). The LHC was partially designed to produce these particles in a controlled environment. However, as experimental bounds tighten, the possibility of a null result at the LHC—the "Nightmare Scenario"—must be addressed. This study investigates whether such a scenario would invalidate the WIMP hypothesis or if complementary searches, such as direct underground detection and indirect neutrino telescope observations, could still facilitate a discovery.

Methodology and Statistical Framework

The authors employed a Bayesian global scan of the 8-dimensional cMSSM parameter space using the MultiNest algorithm via the SuperBayeS package. To ensure the robustness of the results against theoretical biases, the study compared two types of priors: "flat priors," which assume all mass scales are equally likely, and "log-priors," which assume all orders of magnitude are equally likely.

Standard Model nuisance parameters and their associated uncertainties used to calibrate the statistical model.

The analysis also accounted for several Standard Model nuisance parameters, such as the top quark mass ($M_t$) and the strong coupling constant ($\alpha_s$), to accurately reflect experimental uncertainties in the global likelihood.

Experimental Constraints and Datasets

The study integrated a wide array of experimental data to constrain the cMSSM parameter space. These include cosmological data (dark matter relic density from WMAP 7-year results), electroweak precision measurements, and rare B-physics decays.

Summary of experimental observables, mean values, and uncertainties used as likelihood constraints in the cMSSM global scan.

Three LHC milestones were modeled to simulate the progression of the Nightmare Scenario: the state of the art in 2011, a 14 TeV run with 1 $fb^{-1}$ of data, and an ultimate high-luminosity run of 14 TeV with 100 $fb^{-1}$.

Key Insights and Results

The Survival of the Funnel Region

As the LHC excludes lower mass ranges for squarks and gluinos, the surviving regions of the cMSSM are increasingly pushed into the "funnel region." In this regime, dark matter particles are relatively heavy and annihilate primarily through a heavy Higgs boson. Consequently, the predicted mass of the dark matter candidate ($m_\chi$) shifts significantly higher, moving toward the 500 GeV – 1 TeV range.

The Complementarity of Direct Detection

While the LHC is highly sensitive to colored particles like squarks, it is less effective at detecting the neutralino (the dark matter candidate) if other SUSY particles are extremely heavy. The most significant finding of this research is that Phase 3 (ton-scale) direct detection experiments (such as LUX-ZEPLIN or Xenon1T) have a 100% probability of probing the cMSSM parameter space that survives a null LHC search. This makes direct detection a definitive backup for the WIMP hypothesis.

Indirect Detection and the Higgs

Indirect detection via the IceCube neutrino telescope (with the DeepCore extension) is expected to probe approximately 17% of the favored parameter space after five years of operation. Furthermore, the mass of the lightest Higgs boson serves as a critical litmus test; the authors noted that if the LHC were to rule out a Higgs boson in the 115–125 GeV range, the cMSSM would be effectively excluded.

Discussion and Conclusions

The probability of encountering the "Nightmare Scenario" is highly dependent on theoretical priors, ranging from ~3% under log-priors to ~36% under flat priors. However, the study concludes that a null result at the LHC does not signal the end of the WIMP search. Instead, it shifts the discovery frontier to ton-scale direct detection experiments, which remain capable of exploring the entirety of the remaining cMSSM space. This synergy between collider and non-collider searches ensures that the quest for dark matter remains viable even in the absence of immediate laboratory production.

Summary updated

Abstract

International audience
BibTeX
@article{bertone2012dark,
  author = {Gianfranco Bertone and Daniel T. Cumberbatch and Roberto Ruiz de Austri and Roberto Trotta},
  title = {{Dark Matter searches: the nightmare scenario}},
  journal = {Journal of Cosmology and Astroparticle Physics},
  year = {2012},
  doi = {10.1088/1475-7516/2012/01/004},
}
Figure