Damage Detection for Rotating Blades Using Digital Image Correlation with an AC-SURF Matching Algorithm

Jiawei Gu, Gang Liu, Mengzhu Li2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces an enhanced digital image correlation (DIC) method, AC-SURF, to precisely track the deformation of rotating wind turbine blades. By accurately measuring strain fields, this approach offers a more reliable way to detect blade damage compared to methods relying on displacement or frequency changes, which are often obscured by environmental factors.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Wind turbine blades are critical components that are constantly exposed to harsh environmental conditions, making them susceptible to damage like cracks and fatigue. Traditional methods for monitoring blade health often involve contact sensors, which can be difficult to install, maintain, and may even introduce defects. Non-contact methods like Digital Image Correlation (DIC) offer a promising alternative for full-field, remote monitoring. However, the significant rotation of turbine blades presents a major challenge for standard DIC techniques, leading to decorrelation issues and inaccurate measurements. This paper aims to overcome these limitations by developing a robust DIC method capable of handling large-scale rotations and accurately identifying damage through strain analysis.

Methods

The core of this work is the AC-SURF algorithm, a novel enhancement to Digital Image Correlation (DIC). Here's a breakdown of the key components:

  • SURF Feature Matching: The algorithm begins by using the Speeded Up Robust Features (SURF) algorithm to identify and match distinctive points between reference and deformed images of the blade.
  • Angle Compensation (AC) Strategy: To address the challenge of large rotations, the AC strategy is introduced. This involves an iterative process where the algorithm estimates the rotation angle between images. It then "un-rotates" the deformed image to align it with the reference image, effectively compensating for the large rotational displacement. This iterative compensation allows for accurate estimation of the true rotation angle.
  • Iterative Subpixel Registration: After compensating for rotation, a subpixel registration process is employed using an IC-GN (Iterative Closest Point - Gauss-Newton) algorithm. This refines the displacement measurements to a subpixel level, crucial for accurate strain calculation.
  • Full-Field Deformation and Strain Measurement: Once the precise displacement of key points is determined, this information is propagated to neighboring points to reconstruct the full-field deformation map. From this deformation map, the strain distribution is calculated, which is the primary indicator for damage detection.

The novelty lies in the integration of the AC strategy with SURF-enhanced DIC to robustly handle large rotations, which is a significant hurdle for traditional DIC in rotating machinery.

Datasets

The paper utilizes two types of datasets for evaluation:

  • Simulated Speckle Images: Two simulation tests were conducted using synthetic speckle images.
  • Simulation 1: Focused on simulating large deformation and rotation to test the algorithm's ability to handle complex scenarios.
  • Simulation 2: Used images from the Society for Experimental Mechanics (SEM) crack challenge (Sample13) to simulate crack propagation on a blade surface. These images were then artificially rotated to mimic a rotating blade.
  • Experimental Data:
    • Laboratory Blade Damage Detection Setup: A composite blade with an artificial crack was subjected to static loading. Images were captured during this process.
  • Wind Turbine Model Deformation Monitoring: A scaled wind turbine model with a cracked blade was tested under controlled rotation speeds (15, 20, and 30 r/min). Images were captured during rotation.

The paper does not introduce a new benchmark dataset but rather uses existing simulated and experimental setups to validate its proposed method.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Strain as a Superior Damage Indicator: The study strongly suggests that strain fields are more sensitive and reliable indicators of blade damage than displacement or frequency changes, especially in the presence of environmental noise and complex loading conditions.
  • Robustness to Large Rotations: The AC-SURF algorithm's ability to accurately estimate and compensate for large rotational angles is a critical breakthrough for applying DIC to rotating components like wind turbine blades.
  • Damage Localization via Strain Concentration: The research demonstrates that cracks manifest as distinct strain concentrations on the blade surface. By analyzing the strain curve along the blade's length, the precise location of these cracks can be identified with high accuracy.
  • Limitations of Frequency Analysis: The paper highlights that simple frequency analysis might not be sufficient to detect early-stage cracks in rotating blades, as subtle damage may not significantly alter the overall dynamic characteristics.

Key Results

  • Reduced Measurement Error: The proposed AC-SURF method showed significantly smaller mean biases and standard deviations in displacement measurements compared to the traditional SURF algorithm, particularly in large deformation and rotation scenarios. For instance, in the large deformation case, the RMS error for the proposed method was 0.0016, while the traditional method had errors of 0.0203 and 0.0064 in different directions.
  • Accurate Crack Localization: In the static blade damage test, the strain concentration at the artificial crack was clearly identified, and the strain curve along the blade length accurately pinpointed the crack location (within 1 mm error) under various loading conditions.
  • Effective Damage Detection in Rotating Model: For the rotating wind turbine model, the strain distribution clearly showed localized strain concentrations at the crack location, which became more pronounced with increasing rotational speed. This allowed for the identification of the damaged blade and the approximate location of the crack.
  • Strain-Based Damage Detection Advantage: The study concluded that strain-based damage detection is more advantageous in identifying cracks on rotating blades than methods based on fluctuated displacement or frequency change, which are more susceptible to environmental influences.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Camera Resolution and Field of View: The current study was limited by the camera resolution and field of view, which only allowed for the analysis of a local region of the blade (specifically the blade root). For comprehensive safety evaluation, capturing the entire blade, including the tip, is desirable.
  • Scale Model vs. Real WTBs: While a wind turbine model was used, it's acknowledged that accurately replicating the complex structure and materials of real WTBs in a laboratory setting is challenging. Future work could involve using more advanced scale models or conducting tests in wind tunnels.
  • Environmental Factors and Dynamic Loadings: The paper suggests the need for further research into extracting sensitive damage indicators under various simulated wind blowing and dynamic loadings.
  • Advanced Signal Processing: Exploring advanced signal processing techniques, such as band-pass filtering and time-frequency transformations, could enhance the extraction of more sensitive damage indicators.
  • On-Site Monitoring: The current method was primarily tested in a laboratory setting. Future work should focus on adapting this technology for on-site monitoring of operating wind turbines, potentially using aerial vehicles or cameras mounted on the nacelle.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@misc{gu2022damage,
  author = {Jiawei Gu and Gang Liu and Mengzhu Li},
  title = {{Damage Detection for Rotating Blades Using Digital Image Correlation with an AC-SURF Matching Algorithm}},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.3390/s22218110},
}
Figure