Daisy quorum drives for the genetic restoration of wild populations

John Min, Charleston Noble, Devora Najjar, Kevin M. EsveltbioRxiv 2017 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces "daisy quorum" gene drive systems, a novel approach designed for localized and reversible genetic modification of wild populations. These systems aim to enable communities to control their local environments while providing a built-in mechanism to restore original genetics, addressing key concerns about the uncontrolled spread and permanence of gene drive technologies.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Gene drive systems, particularly those based on CRISPR technology, hold immense potential for applications in public health, conservation, and agriculture by enabling targeted genetic alterations in wild populations. However, the standard gene drive model is self-sustaining and designed to spread globally, raising significant concerns about unintended consequences, irreversible ecological changes, and the lack of community control. This global spread severely limits gene drive utility to only a few high-priority applications. The paper addresses the critical need for gene drive systems that are:

  1. Locally confined: Restricted to the political boundaries of consenting communities.
  2. Genetically reversible: Capable of restoring the population to its original genetic state.

Existing "daisy drive" systems offer some degree of self-limitation by gradually losing their driving advantage over generations. However, they don't inherently provide a mechanism for complete reversal or a "quorum" to decide on local alteration. This paper proposes a solution that combines the localized spread of daisy drives with a "quorum" mechanism based on underdominance to achieve both local control and reversibility.

Methods

The core innovation lies in the "daisy quorum" drive system, which integrates two key concepts:

  • Daisy Drive: This mechanism uses a chain of linked genetic elements. Each element drives the next, but the drive advantage diminishes with each generation as elements are lost. This limits the spread and duration of the drive.
  • Underdominance: This is a genetic phenomenon where heterozygotes (organisms with two different versions of a gene) are less fit than homozygotes (organisms with two identical versions). In the context of daisy quorum, this creates a "quorum" effect. Once the daisy elements are lost, the system becomes frequency-dependent: if the engineered variant is locally abundant, it's more likely to reproduce and become fixed; if the wild-type is abundant, it's favored. This acts as a local "vote" on whether the population should remain altered.

The proposed implementation uses CRISPR-Cas9 technology to swap specific haploinsufficient genes (genes where only one copy is insufficient for viability) with recoded versions. This swapping is engineered to be lethal to heterozygotes, creating the underdominance effect. The system also incorporates guide RNAs to target these genes and ensure the drive spreads efficiently.

The paper also outlines strategies for daisy restoration drives, which can be adapted to overwrite unwanted global gene drives and then restore the population to wild-type genetics. This involves using a daisy quorum system with an overwriting element that targets the unwanted sequence.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The paper focuses on a theoretical proposal and experimental design for a novel gene drive system.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Community-Centric Gene Drive: The concept of "daisy quorum" empowers local communities to make decisions about their environment, aligning with principles of consent and self-determination.
  • Built-in Reversibility: The underdominance "quorum" mechanism is a crucial innovation, providing a natural way to reverse engineered changes if needed, addressing a major safety concern.
  • Bridging Local and Global Concerns: By combining localized spread (daisy drive) with a local decision-making mechanism (quorum), the system offers a way to harness gene drive benefits without the risks of uncontrolled global spread.
  • Pre-registration as a Scientific Norm: The authors strongly advocate for pre-registration of gene drive research plans, emphasizing transparency, community evaluation, and the acceleration of scientific progress. They frame their manuscript as an example of this practice.
  • Restoration as a Safety Net: The proposed "daisy restoration drive" offers a powerful tool to counteract accidental or malicious releases of global gene drives, acting as a technological safeguard.

Key Results

This paper is primarily a theoretical proposal and a description of intended experimental plans. Therefore, there are no quantitative experimental results presented. The key "results" are conceptual:

  • The proposal of a "daisy quorum" drive system that theoretically meets the criteria of local confinement and genetic reversibility.
  • The conceptual framework for engineering this system using CRISPR to swap haploinsufficient genes and create underdominance.
  • The detailed outline of experimental plans for testing this system in C. brenneri nematodes, including safeguards and methods for monitoring spread and stability.
  • The conceptual design for "daisy restoration drives" capable of reversing engineered changes.

Limitations and Future Work

Limitations:

  • Engineering Complexity: The authors acknowledge that constructing these systems involves multiple moving parts and requires precise genetic engineering. They suggest strategies to overcome challenges like achieving simultaneous quadruple replacement of genes.
  • Fitness Costs: Recoding ribosomal genes might lead to unacceptably high fitness costs, though they cite evidence from other organisms suggesting this is surmountable.
  • Off-target Effects and Recombination: While CRISPR is generally reliable, there's a potential risk of off-target effects or recombination events, especially in large populations. The authors suggest minimizing sequence similarity between elements to mitigate this.
  • Experimental Validation: The proposed systems have not yet been experimentally tested. The paper outlines the intended experiments but does not present results.

Future Work:

  • Experimental Implementation: The immediate future work involves building and testing daisy quorum drive systems in C. brenneri nematodes.
  • Scaling to Other Organisms: If successful, the authors plan to adapt these systems for other organisms.
  • Refining Restoration Drives: Further development of sequence-divergent guide RNAs will be crucial for building powerful daisy restoration drive systems.
  • Long-term Stability Studies: Extensive studies in large populations will be necessary to measure the risk of recombination and assess evolutionary stability.
  • Policy and Regulation: The authors are actively engaging with journals, funders, policymakers, and IP holders to shape the scientific incentives around gene drive research to encourage open sharing.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract An ideal gene drive system to alter wild populations would 1) exclusively affect organisms within the political boundaries of consenting communities, and 2) be capable of restoring any engineered population to its original genetic state. Here we describe ‘daisy quorum’ drive systems that meet these criteria by combining daisy drive with underdominance. A daisy quorum drive system is predicted to spread through a population until all of its daisy elements have been lost, at which point its fitness becomes frequency-dependent: mostly altered populations become fixed for the desired change, while engineered genes at low frequency are swiftly eliminated by natural selection. The result is an engineered population surrounded by wild-type organisms with limited mixing at the boundary. Releasing large numbers of wild-type organisms or a few bearing a population suppression element can reduce the engineered population below the quorum, triggering elimination of all engineered sequences. In principle, the technology can restore any drive-amenable population carrying engineered genes to wild-type genetics. Daisy quorum systems may enable efficient, community-supported, and genetically reversible ecological engineering. Summary Local communities should be able to control their own environments without forcing those choices on others. Ideally, each community could reversibly alter local wild organisms in ways that cannot spread beyond their own boundaries, and any engineered population could be restored to its original genetic state. We've invented a 'daisy quorum' drive system that appears to meet these criteria. “Daisy” refers to a daisy drive, which typically uses a daisy-chain of linked genes to spread a change through a local population while losing links every generation until it stops spreading. “Quorum” reflects the system's ability to “vote” on whether a local population should be altered or not: once all daisy elements are lost, it favors replication by the altered version or the original depending on which is more abundant in the local area. Put together, they result in a change that first spreads through a local population, then either becomes locally prevalent is eliminating, inhibiting mixing at the boundary. All organisms in the target population are altered, but changes are unable to spread much beyond that area due to being greatly outnumbered by wild-type organisms and consequently less able to replicate. We haven't yet performed any experiments involving daisy quorum systems. Rather, we’re describing what we intend to do, including the safeguards we will use and our assessment of risks, in the hope that others will evaluate our plans and tell us if there's anything wrong that we missed. We hope that all researchers working on gene drive systems - and other technologies that could impact the shared environment - will similarly pre-register their plans. Sharing plans can reduce needless duplication, accelerate progress, and make the proposed work safer for everyone.
BibTeX
@misc{min2017daisy,
  author = {John Min and Charleston Noble and Devora Najjar and Kevin M. Esvelt},
  title = {{Daisy quorum drives for the genetic restoration of wild populations}},
  year = {2017},
  doi = {10.1101/115618},
  howpublished = {bioRxiv},
}
Figure