Daisy-chain gene drives for the alteration of local populations

Charleston Noble, John Min, Jason Olejarz, Joanna Buchthal, Alejandro Chavez, Andrea L. Smidler, Erika A. DeBenedictis, George M. Church, Martin A. Nowak, Kevin M. EsveltbioRxiv 2016 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces "daisy-chain gene drives," a novel CRISPR-based system designed for localized genetic modification of wild populations. By arranging gene drive elements in a sequential, interdependent chain, these drives can achieve potent genetic effects locally while inherently limiting their potential for global spread, addressing key ethical and safety concerns associated with traditional gene drives.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Gene drives, particularly those based on CRISPR technology, hold immense promise for tackling ecological challenges like disease vector control and invasive species management. However, their self-propagating nature poses a significant risk of unintended global spread, creating substantial ethical, regulatory, and public acceptance hurdles. This global spread potential makes field trials and widespread deployment extremely difficult. Existing localized drive strategies often require releasing large numbers of modified organisms, which can be impractical. The authors address the critical need for gene drive systems that can exert strong local effects without the risk of uncontrolled global dissemination, thereby enabling safer testing and more community-driven applications.

Methods

The core innovation is the "daisy-chain" architecture. Instead of a single gene drive element, this system comprises multiple elements arranged sequentially, where each element drives the next in the chain. This creates an interdependent cascade. The authors developed a deterministic model to simulate the evolutionary dynamics of these daisy-chain systems, considering factors like fitness costs associated with drive elements and homing efficiency. They also designed and tested a set of highly active, sequence-divergent guide RNAs (sgRNAs) to ensure the stability and safety of the drive constructs, specifically to prevent recombination events that could convert the chain into a self-sustaining global drive ("necklace").

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study relies on theoretical modeling and experimental validation of guide RNA activity in cell culture.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Localized Control is Achievable: The daisy-chain design inherently limits spread. As elements at the "base" of the chain are lost through natural selection, the drive cascade breaks down, preventing global dissemination.
  • Potency Without Global Risk: Daisy drives can achieve effects comparable to global drives but are confined to the release population, making them suitable for local interventions.
  • Modular Design for Flexibility: The system is modular, allowing for the addition of more elements to increase drive potency or the incorporation of various "payloads" for different applications.
  • Importance of sgRNA Design: Developing highly active and minimally homologous sgRNAs is crucial for preventing unwanted recombination events that could destabilize the daisy-chain and lead to global spread.
  • Community Empowerment: Localized drives empower communities to make decisions about altering their own ecosystems, fostering a more ethical and participatory approach to genetic engineering.

Key Results

  • Effective Local Spread: Simulations showed that daisy drives can drive a payload to near-fixation in a local population with relatively small release sizes, especially with longer chains and higher homing efficiencies.
  • Sensitivity to Parameters: The success of a daisy drive is sensitive to release frequency, homing efficiency, and payload fitness cost. Larger release sizes or higher homing efficiencies are needed for more costly payloads.
  • Chain Length Matters: Increasing the number of elements in the daisy chain significantly enhances drive potency and speed. A five-element chain can achieve 99% frequency in under 20 generations with a 10% payload cost, released at frequencies as low as 3%.
  • sgRNA Activity: The researchers identified 15 novel sgRNAs with activities comparable to standard versions, crucial for building stable, multiplexed daisy drive systems.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Technological Limitations: Current technological limitations, particularly the risk of recombination events creating a "necklace" drive, necessitate careful sgRNA design to ensure stability.
  • Fitness Costs: While models account for fitness costs, real-world impacts on organism fitness and population dynamics require further investigation.
  • Animal Model Studies: The authors emphasize the need for future studies to examine the stability of these daisy drive systems in large populations of animal models.
  • Orthogonal CRISPR Systems: The use of orthogonal Cas9 systems is proposed as a way to further enhance resistance to necklace formation, but this presents challenges in promoter selection and expression.
  • Reversible Control: The paper suggests potential architectures for reversible population control, such as male-linked sterile-daughter traits, which warrant further exploration.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract RNA-guided gene drive elements could address many ecological problems by altering the traits of wild organisms, but the likelihood of global spread tremendously complicates ethical development and use. Here we detail a localized form of CRISPR-based gene drive composed of genetic elements arranged in a daisy-chain such that each element drives the next. “Daisy drive” systems can duplicate any effect achievable using an equivalent global drive system, but their capacity to spread is limited by the successive loss of non-driving elements from the base of the chain. Releasing daisy drive organisms constituting a small fraction of the local wild population can drive a useful genetic element to local fixation for a wide range of fitness parameters without resulting in global spread. We additionally report numerous highly active guide RNA sequences sharing minimal homology that may enable evolutionary stable daisy drive as well as global CRISPR-based gene drive. Daisy drives could simplify decision-making and promote ethical use by enabling local communities to decide whether, when, and how to alter local ecosystems. Author’s Summary ‘Global’ gene drive systems based on CRISPR are likely to spread to every population of the target species, hampering safe and ethical use. ‘Daisy drive’ systems offer a way to alter the traits of only local populations in a temporary manner. Because they can exactly duplicate the activity of any global CRISPR-based drive at a local level, daisy drives may enable safe field trials and empower local communities to make decisions concerning their own shared environments. For more details and an animation intended for a general audience, see the summary at Sculpting Evolution .
BibTeX
@misc{noble2016daisy,
  author = {Charleston Noble and John Min and Jason Olejarz and Joanna Buchthal and Alejandro Chavez and Andrea L. Smidler and Erika A. DeBenedictis and George M. Church and Martin A. Nowak and Kevin M. Esvelt},
  title = {{Daisy-chain gene drives for the alteration of local populations}},
  year = {2016},
  doi = {10.1101/057307},
  howpublished = {bioRxiv},
}

Loading related content...

Figure