D3.5 Development of a Low-Cost Sensing Node with Active Ventilation Fan for Air Pollution Monitoring

Nicolas P. Winkler, Patrick P. Neumann, Harald Kohlhoff, Jakob Erdmann, Erik Schaffernicht, Achim J. Lilienthal2021 · DOI

Abstract

A fully designed low-cost sensing node for air pollution monitoring and calibration results for several low-cost gas sensors are presented. As the state of the art is lacking information on the importance of an active ventilation system, the effect of an active fan is compared to the passive ventilation of a lamellar structured casing. Measurements obtained in an urban outdoor environment show that readings of the low-cost dust sensor (Sharp GP2Y1010AU0F) are distorted by the active ventilation system. While this behavior requires further research, a correlation with temperature and humidity inside the node shown.

Introduction

Air pollution remains the single largest environmental health risk in the EU, contributing to approximately 400,000 premature deaths annually. While high-quality reference stations provide accurate data, their high cost prevents the dense, city-wide deployments necessary for monitoring industrial environments or urban hotspots. Low-cost sensors offer a potential solution for "hyper-local" monitoring, but their reliability is often compromised by environmental factors. This research addresses the hardware integration challenge, specifically investigating whether an active ventilation fan—intended to ensure a fresh air supply—improves or hinders the performance of low-cost optical dust sensors.

Methodology

The sensing node was constructed using a combination of off-the-shelf components and a custom 3D-printed housing.

Hardware Design

The core of the node is an ESP32 microcontroller, which handles data processing and WLAN transmission. The sensor suite includes:

  • Particulate Matter: Sharp GP2Y1010AU0F optical dust sensor.
  • Environmental: Adafruit DHT22 for temperature and humidity.
  • Gases: SPEC electrochemical sensors for Carbon Monoxide (CO) and Indoor Air Quality (IAQ).

The housing utilizes a dual-layer design: a 3D-printed internal chassis protected by a commercially available lamellar casing for passive ventilation.

Figure 1: Labeled diagram of the sensing node components including the fan, sensors, and electronics.

Experimental Setup

To isolate the effect of active ventilation, the fan was programmed to run for two seconds every 30 seconds. Sensor readings were sampled immediately before and after each fan cycle. Field evaluation was conducted over three days in Berlin-Lichterfelde in June 2020, capturing real-world fluctuations in temperature and humidity.

Results and Discussion

The study revealed a significant "fan paradox." While active ventilation is intended to refresh the air sample, it introduced substantial noise into the dust sensor readings.

The Impact of Active Ventilation

Data analysis showed that dust sensor readings taken immediately after the fan cycle exhibited much higher variance compared to those taken before. This suggests that the airflow creates turbulence or pressure changes that interfere with the optical sensing mechanism of the low-cost Sharp sensor.

Figure 5: Time series data showing the correlation between dust sensor readings (before and after fan activation), temperature, and relative humidity.

Thermal and Humidity Correlations

Internal temperature was found to be a major distorting factor. A moderate correlation ($r = 0.28$) was observed between dust sensor variance and internal temperature, which fluctuates significantly with solar heating. Conversely, a strong negative correlation ($r = -0.79$) exists between temperature and humidity, indicating that the internal microclimate is the primary driver of sensor noise.

Gas Sensor Performance

In contrast to the dust sensor, the SPEC gas sensors demonstrated highly linear responses during laboratory calibration, confirming their suitability for monitoring CO and IAQ when properly calibrated.

Conclusion

The research demonstrates that active ventilation, while intuitively beneficial, can negatively impact the accuracy of low-cost optical dust sensors. The distortion likely stems from a combination of mechanical airflow interference and thermal fluctuations within the node housing. Future work will focus on refining the 3D-printed internal structure to shield sensors from direct airflow and developing software-based compensation algorithms to mitigate environmental noise.

Summary updated

Abstract

A fully designed low-cost sensing node for air pollution monitoring and calibration results for several low-cost gas sensors are presented. As the state of the art is lacking information on the importance of an active ventilation system, the effect of an active fan is compared to the passive ventilation of a lamellar structured casing. Measurements obtained in an urban outdoor environment show that readings of the low-cost dust sensor (Sharp GP2Y1010AU0F) are distorted by the active ventilation system. While this behavior requires further research, a correlation with temperature and humidity inside the node shown.
BibTeX
@misc{winkler2021d,
  author = {Nicolas P. Winkler and Patrick P. Neumann and Harald Kohlhoff and Jakob Erdmann and Erik Schaffernicht and Achim J. Lilienthal},
  title = {{D3.5 Development of a Low-Cost Sensing Node with Active Ventilation Fan for Air Pollution Monitoring}},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.5162/smsi2021/d3.5},
}
Figure