$D_{(s)}(2S)$ and $D^{*}_{(s)}(2S)$ production in nonleptonic $B_{(s)}$ weak decays

Zhi-Jie Sun, Yujing Sun, Zhi-Qing Zhang, You-Ya Yang, Siyang WangarXiv 2025 · DOI · arXiv

This paper, recently published by Zhi-Jie Sun and colleagues, provides a detailed theoretical roadmap for experimentalists hunting for "excited" versions of charmed mesons. By applying the Covariant Light-Front Quark Model (CLFQM), the authors predict the production rates and spin characteristics of $B$ meson decays into the first radially excited states, $D_{(s)}(2S)$ and $D^*_{(s)}(2S)$.

TL;DR

The researchers used a relativistic quark model to predict that $B$ mesons decay into radially excited charmed mesons ($2S$ states) at rates detectable by current experiments ($10^{-5}$ to $10^{-3}$). Despite these excited states being rarer than ground states, they maintain a consistent 90% longitudinal polarization, providing a clear signature for experimental identification.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

In the world of particle physics, we are fairly good at understanding "ground state" mesons—the lowest energy configurations of a quark and an antiquark. However, "radially excited" states (think of them as higher-energy "harmonics" of the ground state) are much harder to pin down.

While experiments like LHCb and Belle II have recently spotted candidates for these $2S$ states, their properties remain "well-determined" only in theory. Different mathematical models—such as the Bethe-Salpeter equation versus various Relativistic Quark Models—often yield conflicting predictions for how often these states should appear in $B$ meson decays. This paper aims to resolve these discrepancies using a robust relativistic framework to provide reliable branching ratios (probabilities) and polarization fractions.

Methods

The authors employ the Covariant Light-Front Quark Model (CLFQM). This approach is particularly powerful because:

  • Relativistic Covariance: It handles the high-speed internal motion of quarks within the mesons more naturally than non-relativistic models.
  • Light-Front Coordinates: By describing the system along the "front" of a light wave, the complex task of calculating hadronic transition matrix elements becomes more manageable.
  • Factorization: They assume the decay can be split into two parts: a "transition form factor" (describing the $B \to D$ change) and a "decay constant" (describing the creation of the accompanying light meson, like a pion or rho).
  • Wave Function Modeling: They use Gaussian-type wave functions to describe the spatial distribution of quarks, specifically accounting for the "node structure" of $2S$ states—where the wave function crosses zero, a key feature of radial excitations.

Datasets

The paper does not use a training dataset in the machine-learning sense. Instead, it relies on high-precision physical constants and previous experimental benchmarks:

  • Input Parameters: Masses and CKM matrix elements (which govern weak force interactions) are taken from the Particle Data Group (PDG) 2024 report.
  • Validation: The model is first tested against known ground-state ($1S$) decays from LHCb, BaBar, and Belle to ensure the framework is calibrated correctly before predicting the unknown $2S$ values.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The "Node Effect": The authors explain why $2S$ states are produced less frequently than $1S$ states. Because the $2S$ wave function has a "node" (it flips from positive to negative), the mathematical integral used to calculate the decay rate undergoes partial cancellation. This results in branching ratios that are generally one order of magnitude smaller than ground-state decays.
  • Model Consensus: The CLFQM results align closely with other Relativistic Quark Models (RQM) but are significantly larger than those predicted by the Bethe-Salpeter (BS) method. This suggests that the BS method might be underestimating the production of excited states.
  • Polarization Stability: A surprising "aha" moment is that the longitudinal polarization fraction ($f_L$) remains dominant at ~90% for both $1S$ and $2S$ states. This implies that the spin-alignment of the resulting particles is governed more by the heavy-quark symmetry than by the specific radial energy level of the meson.

Key Results

  • Branching Ratios: Most predicted decay channels fall between $10^{-5}$ and $10^{-4}$. Some specific channels, like $B^- \to D^0(2S)\rho^-$, are predicted as high as $1.1 \times 10^{-3}$, making them prime targets for immediate experimental search.
  • SU(3) Breaking: The study quantifies the flavor symmetry breaking between $B$ and $B_s$ mesons, finding that the ratios of their form factors range from 0.20 to 1.37, providing a nuanced look at how "strange" quarks affect these transitions.
  • Experimental Feasibility: The authors explicitly state that these predicted rates are within the sensitivity reach of current-generation detectors, potentially clearing up the "uncertainty in measurements" regarding whether certain observed particles are indeed the $2S$ states they are suspected to be.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Scarcity of Data: The biggest limitation is the lack of existing experimental data for $2S$ transition form factors, meaning the model's predictions for excited states cannot yet be fully "proven" against reality.
  • Factorization Limits: The study relies on the "factorization assumption." In certain "neutral" decay channels, non-factorizable effects (like complex gluon exchanges) might play a larger role than accounted for here.
  • Future Directions: The authors suggest that future experiments measuring the specific ratios of $B_s$ to $B_d$ decays will be the "smoking gun" needed to determine which theoretical model (CLFQM vs. BS) is truly correct.

Summary updated

Abstract

Recently, many new excited states of heavy mesons have been discovered in recent experiments, including radially excited states. The production processes of these states from the $B_{(s)}$ meson have drawn significant interest. In this paper, we use the covariant light-front approach to study the nonleptonic $B_{(s)}$ meson decays to the first radially excited states $D_{(s)}(2S)$ and $D^{*}_{(s)}(2S)$. Our results reveal that many channels exhibit large branching ratios in the range $10^{-5}\sim 10^{-4}$, even up to $10^{-3}$ for individual channels, which are detectable by current experiments. Our predictions for the decays $B_{(s)}\to D^{(*)}_{(s)}(2S)(π,ρ,K^{(*)})$ are larger than those given by the Bethe-Salpeter (BS) equation method, but agree well with the relativistic quark mode (RQM) and the relativistic independent quark model (RIQM) calculations. For comparison, we also present the branching ratios of the decays $B_{(s)}\to D^{(*)}_{(s)}(1S)(π,ρ,K^{(*)})$, which are comparable with other theoretical results and the data. Although the branching ratios of the decays $B_{(s)} \to D^{*}_{(s)}(1S)(ρ,K^*)$ are much larger than those of the decays $B_{(s)} \to D^{*}_{(s)}(2S)(ρ,K^*)$, the polarization properties between them are similar, that is, the longitudinal polarization fractions are dominant and can amount roughly to $90\%$.
BibTeX
@misc{sun2025d,
  author = {Zhi-Jie Sun and Yujing Sun and Zhi-Qing Zhang and You-Ya Yang and Siyang Wang},
  title = {{$D\_\{(s)\}(2S)$ and $D^\{*\}\_\{(s)\}(2S)$ production in nonleptonic $B\_\{(s)\}$ weak decays}},
  year = {2025},
  eprint = {2511.13456},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2511.13456},
  howpublished = {arXiv},
}
Figure