Cytotoxic lymphocytes are dysregulated in multisystem inflammatory syndrome in children

Noam D. Beckmann, Phillip Comella, Esther Cheng, Lauren Lepow, Aviva G. Beckmann, Konstantinos Mouskas, Nicole W. Simons, Gabriel E. Hoffman, Nancy Francoeur, Diane M. Del Valle, Gurpawan Kang, Emily Moya, Lillian Wilkins, Jessica Le Bérichel, Christie Chang, Robert Marvin, Sharlene Calorossi, Alona Lansky, Laura Walker, Nancy Yi, Alex W. Yu, Matthew Hartnett, Melody Eaton, Sandra Hatem, Hajra Jamal, Alara Akyatan, Alexandra Tabachnikova, Lora E. Liharska, Liam Cotter, Brian Fennessey, Akhil Vaid, Guillermo Barturen, Scott R. Tyler, Hardik Shah, Ying‐Chih Wang, Shwetha Hara Sridhar, Juan Soto, Swaroop Bose, Kent Madrid, Ethan Ellis, Elyze Merzier, Konstantinos Vlachos, Nataly Fishman, Manying Tin, Melissa Smith, Hui Xie, Manishkumar Patel, Kimberly Argueta, Jocelyn Harris, Neha Karekar, Craig Batchelor, Jose Lacunza, Mahlet Yishak, Kevin Tuballes, Leisha Scott, Arvind Kumar, Suraj K. Jaladanki, Ryan C. Thompson, Evan Clark, Bojan Losic, Jun Zhu, Wenhui Wang, Andrew Kasarskis, Benjamin S. Glicksberg, Girish N. Nadkarni, Dusan Bogunovic, Cordelia Elaiho, Sandeep Gangadharan, George Ofori‐Amanfo, Kasey Alesso-Carra, Kenan Onel, Karen M. Wilson, Carmen Argmann, Marta E. Alarcón‐Riquelme, Thomas U. Marron, Adeeb Rahman, Seunghee Kim‐Schulze, Sacha Gnjatic, Bruce D. Gelb, Miriam Mérad, Robert Sebra, Eric E. Schadt, Alexander W. CharneymedRxiv 2020 · DOI

Abstract

Multisystem inflammatory syndrome in children (MIS-C) presents with fever, inflammation, and multiple organ involvement in individuals under 21 years following severe acute respiratory syndrome coronavirus 2 (SARS-CoV-2) infection. To identify genes, pathways, and cell types driving MIS-C, we sequenced the blood transcriptomes of MIS-C cases, pediatric cases of coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID-19), and healthy controls. We define a MIS-C transcriptional signature partially shared with the transcriptional response to SARS-CoV-2 infection and with the signature of Kawasaki disease, a clinically similar condition. By projecting the MIS-C signature onto a co-expression network, we identified disease gene modules and found genes downregulated in MIS-C clustered in a module enriched for the transcriptional signatures of exhausted CD8+ T-cells and CD56dim CD57+ NK cells. Bayesian network analyses revealed nine key regulators of this module, including TBX21, a central coordinator of exhausted CD8+ T-cell differentiation. Together, these findings suggest a dysregulated cytotoxic lymphocyte response to SARS-CoV-2 infection in MIS-C.

Introduction

In the wake of the COVID-19 pandemic, a severe and mysterious condition emerged in the pediatric population: Multisystem Inflammatory Syndrome in Children (MIS-C). Appearing weeks after a mild or even asymptomatic SARS-CoV-2 infection, MIS-C manifests as a delayed, hyper-inflammatory "storm" affecting multiple organ systems. Clinically, the condition mimics Kawasaki Disease (KD), leading to significant debate regarding whether MIS-C is a variant of KD or a unique form of viral-triggered autoimmunity.

Because MIS-C is rare and develops rapidly, capturing its molecular architecture has proven challenging. This research seeks to define the specific genes, pathways, and immune cell types that drive MIS-C pathogenesis, distinguishing it from both acute COVID-19 and traditional autoimmune conditions.

Methodology

The researchers employed a multi-layered transcriptomic approach to dissect the immune response in MIS-C patients. The study utilized whole-blood RNA sequencing (RNA-seq) from a primary cohort of 30 samples, including 8 MIS-C cases, 7 pediatric COVID-19 cases (with longitudinal sampling), and 4 healthy controls.

To interpret the complex bulk RNA data, the team used several advanced computational tools:

  • Cell Type Deconvolution (CIBERSORTx): This allowed the researchers to mathematically estimate the proportions of different immune cell types within the blood samples.
  • Weighted Gene Co-expression Network Analysis (WGCNA): This method grouped genes into functional "modules" to identify collective biological behaviors rather than isolated gene changes.
  • Bayesian Network Analysis: By projecting their findings onto a massive regulatory network (derived from a cohort of 1,030 individuals), the team identified "key drivers"—master regulator genes that appear to control the disease state.

The MIS-C Transcriptional Signature

The study identified a distinct MIS-C signature consisting of 2,043 genes (815 upregulated and 1,228 downregulated). The upregulated pathways were dominated by innate immune responses and regulated exocytosis. However, the most significant findings lay in the downregulated genes, specifically those clustered in the "skyblue" module.

The Role of Cytotoxic Lymphocytes

The "skyblue" module was found to be uniquely and severely downregulated in MIS-C patients. This module is highly enriched for the transcriptional signatures of exhausted CD8+ T-cells and CD56dim CD57+ NK cells.

In many chronic infections, T-cell exhaustion is viewed as a failure of the immune system. However, in the context of an acute, hyper-inflammatory storm, "mature exhaustion" acts as a critical molecular rheostat. It serves as a physiological brake that tempers the immune response to prevent host tissue damage. The findings suggest that in MIS-C, this brake is missing. The failure of these cytotoxic lymphocytes to transition into a mature exhausted state allows the inflammatory response to proceed unchecked, leading to the systemic damage characteristic of the syndrome.

Comparison with Kawasaki Disease and Autoimmunity

While MIS-C shares clinical features with Kawasaki Disease, the transcriptomic data reveals a nuanced relationship. Both conditions share the downregulation of the skyblue module, suggesting a common failure in cytotoxic lymphocyte regulation. However, they diverge in other areas; for instance, MIS-C showed a much more prominent activation of platelet and coagulation pathways (the "paleturquoise" module).

Notably, MIS-C showed almost no transcriptomic overlap with classic autoimmune diseases such as Lupus or Rheumatoid Arthritis. This suggests that MIS-C is not a traditional autoimmune breakdown but rather a unique, virus-triggered hyper-inflammatory path.

Key Regulatory Drivers

Through Bayesian network analysis, the researchers identified nine master regulators of the dysregulated skyblue module. The most prominent among these is TBX21 (which encodes the protein T-bet). TBX21 is a well-known biological switch for T-cell differentiation. Its significant downregulation in MIS-C indicates a fundamental failure in the transition of cytotoxic cells to the intermediate or terminal states required to resolve the inflammatory response.

Conclusion and Limitations

This study provides a molecular framework for understanding MIS-C as a disorder of immune regulation, specifically involving the failure of cytotoxic lymphocytes to reach a protective state of exhaustion.

Despite these insights, the authors note several limitations. The rarity of MIS-C resulted in a small sample size (8 cases), and the healthy control group consisted of adults due to the difficulties of pediatric recruitment during the pandemic. Additionally, the pediatric COVID-19 comparison group had various underlying comorbidities.

Future research and therapeutic strategies may focus on pathways that can induce T-cell exhaustion or target the TBX21 regulatory network to quench the inflammatory fire of MIS-C.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract Multisystem inflammatory syndrome in children (MIS-C) presents with fever, inflammation and multiple organ involvement in individuals under 21 years following severe acute respiratory syndrome coronavirus 2 (SARS-CoV-2) infection. To identify genes, pathways and cell types driving MIS-C, we sequenced the blood transcriptomes of MIS-C cases, pediatric cases of coronavirus disease 2019, and healthy controls. We define a MIS-C transcriptional signature partially shared with the transcriptional response to SARS-CoV-2 infection and with the signature of Kawasaki disease, a clinically similar condition. By projecting the MIS-C signature onto a co-expression network, we identified disease gene modules and found genes downregulated in MIS-C clustered in a module enriched for the transcriptional signatures of exhausted CD8 + T-cells and CD56 dim CD57 + NK cells. Bayesian network analyses revealed nine key regulators of this module, including TBX21 , a central coordinator of exhausted CD8 + T-cell differentiation. Together, these findings suggest dysregulated cytotoxic lymphocyte response to SARS-Cov-2 infection in MIS-C.
BibTeX
@misc{beckmann2020cytotoxic,
  author = {Noam D. Beckmann and Phillip Comella and Esther Cheng and Lauren Lepow and Aviva G. Beckmann and Konstantinos Mouskas and Nicole W. Simons and Gabriel E. Hoffman and Nancy Francoeur and Diane M. Del Valle and Gurpawan Kang and Emily Moya and Lillian Wilkins and Jessica Le Bérichel and Christie Chang and Robert Marvin and Sharlene Calorossi and Alona Lansky and Laura Walker and Nancy Yi and Alex W. Yu and Matthew Hartnett and Melody Eaton and Sandra Hatem and Hajra Jamal and Alara Akyatan and Alexandra Tabachnikova and Lora E. Liharska and Liam Cotter and Brian Fennessey and Akhil Vaid and Guillermo Barturen and Scott R. Tyler and Hardik Shah and Ying‐Chih Wang and Shwetha Hara Sridhar and Juan Soto and Swaroop Bose and Kent Madrid and Ethan Ellis and Elyze Merzier and Konstantinos Vlachos and Nataly Fishman and Manying Tin and Melissa Smith and Hui Xie and Manishkumar Patel and Kimberly Argueta and Jocelyn Harris and Neha Karekar and Craig Batchelor and Jose Lacunza and Mahlet Yishak and Kevin Tuballes and Leisha Scott and Arvind Kumar and Suraj K. Jaladanki and Ryan C. Thompson and Evan Clark and Bojan Losic and Jun Zhu and Wenhui Wang and Andrew Kasarskis and Benjamin S. Glicksberg and Girish N. Nadkarni and Dusan Bogunovic and Cordelia Elaiho and Sandeep Gangadharan and George Ofori‐Amanfo and Kasey Alesso-Carra and Kenan Onel and Karen M. Wilson and Carmen Argmann and Marta E. Alarcón‐Riquelme and Thomas U. Marron and Adeeb Rahman and Seunghee Kim‐Schulze and Sacha Gnjatic and Bruce D. Gelb and Miriam Mérad and Robert Sebra and Eric E. Schadt and Alexander W. Charney and Alexander W. Charney},
  title = {{Cytotoxic lymphocytes are dysregulated in multisystem inflammatory syndrome in children}},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.1101/2020.08.29.20182899},
  howpublished = {medRxiv},
}
Figure