Cytogenetic changes in radiation-induced tumors of the thyroid.

Horst Zitzelsberger, Lars Lehmann, Ludwig Hieber, Heinz‐Ulrich G. Weier, Catherine Janish, Jingly Fung, Thomas Negele, F. Spelsberg, Edmund Lengfelder, Eugene P. Demidchik, Konstatinos Salassidis, Albrecht M. Kellerer, Martin Werner, Manfred BauchingerPubMed 1999

TL;DR

This study investigates the genetic fingerprints left by radiation exposure on thyroid tumors, specifically focusing on childhood thyroid cancers that arose after the Chernobyl disaster. By analyzing chromosomal abnormalities, the researchers identified novel genetic alterations that could be key to understanding how radiation triggers thyroid cancer and potentially lead to new diagnostic or therapeutic targets.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The incidence of thyroid cancer, particularly papillary thyroid carcinoma (PTC), dramatically increased in children exposed to radioiodine from the Chernobyl nuclear accident. While the link between radiation and thyroid cancer is clear, the precise molecular mechanisms driving this transformation remain largely unknown. Understanding these mechanisms is crucial for developing better prevention, diagnosis, and treatment strategies. Previous cytogenetic studies on thyroid tumors primarily focused on adult cases and lacked the resolution to pinpoint specific breakpoints. This paper aims to fill this gap by performing a detailed cytogenetic analysis of radiation-induced childhood thyroid tumors, looking for characteristic chromosomal changes that might reveal the underlying oncogenic pathways.

Methods

The researchers employed a combination of established and advanced cytogenetic techniques:

  • G-banding: This standard technique allows for the visualization of chromosome structure and the identification of large-scale abnormalities like translocations, deletions, and duplications. It was used to analyze the karyotypes of 56 childhood thyroid tumors from Belarus and 8 secondary thyroid tumors that developed after radiotherapy.
  • Spectral Karyotyping (SKY): This powerful technique uses fluorescently labeled probes specific to each chromosome, allowing for the simultaneous visualization and identification of all chromosomes in a cell in distinct colors. SKY was used to analyze a particularly complex tumor case (S48) to unravel intricate rearrangements that were difficult to decipher with G-banding alone.
  • Comparative Genomic Hybridization (CGH): CGH is used to detect copy number variations (gains or losses of DNA segments) across the genome. It was also applied to the complex case S48 to complement SKY and G-banding by identifying regions of amplification or deletion.

Datasets

The study utilized two main sets of tumor samples:

  • Belarussian Childhood Thyroid Tumors: 56 tumors collected from children in Belarus who were exposed to radiation from the Chernobyl accident. These were primarily papillary thyroid carcinomas, with a few benign tumors and cases of thyroiditis.
  • Secondary Thyroid Tumors: 8 tumors from patients who developed thyroid issues after radiotherapy (either radioiodine or external beam radiation). This group served as a comparison to understand general radiation-induced changes versus those specific to childhood exposure.

The study also referenced published literature on cytogenetic abnormalities in adult thyroid tumors without a radiation history for comparative analysis.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Radiation leaves a distinct genetic signature: The study found that radiation-induced thyroid tumors, especially in children, exhibit a higher frequency of complex chromosomal aberrations compared to spontaneous tumors.
  • Novel breakpoints identified: Beyond known "hot spots" for alterations in papillary thyroid carcinomas (like 1q and 10q), this research identified novel chromosomal breakpoints on chromosomes 4q, 5q, 6p, 12q, 13q, and 14q in radiation-exposed tumors. These new locations are significant because they may harbor genes critical for radiation-induced tumorigenesis.
  • Shared abnormalities across different radiation exposures: There was a notable overlap in chromosomal breakpoints between childhood tumors from Belarus and secondary tumors from radiotherapy patients, suggesting common mechanisms of radiation damage.
  • Complex rearrangements in a single case highlight potential hot spots: The detailed analysis of case S48 using SKY and CGH revealed extensive chromosomal changes, particularly affecting chromosomes 1, 2, 9, and 13, pointing to these regions as potential targets for radiation-induced DNA damage.
  • Benign tumors can also show chromosomal changes: While PTC was the predominant tumor type, some benign tumors (adenomas and goiters) also displayed clonal chromosomal abnormalities, suggesting that radiation can initiate changes even in non-cancerous thyroid tissue.

Key Results

  • Clonal structural chromosomal aberrations were detected in 13 out of 56 (23%) Belarussian childhood tumors and in 6 out of 8 (75%) secondary thyroid tumors after radiotherapy.
  • Multiple chromosomal changes within a single cell were frequently observed.
  • The detailed analysis of case S48 revealed a near-triploid karyotype with numerous derivative chromosomes.
  • SKY and CGH analysis of S48 identified chromosomal gains on chromosomes 1p34, 1q21, 2p11.1-pter, 2q11.2-q13, 3q26.2-q26.3, 5q23-q31, 6p21.3-pter, 7q11, 9q13-q33, 12q22-qter, 13q32-qter, 17q11.1-qter, 19, 20, and X, and losses on 1q42, 13q21, and 15q11.1–q14.
  • Novel breakpoints were identified on chromosomes 4q, 5q, 6p, 12q, 13q, and 14q in radiation-induced tumors, in addition to previously known alterations on 1q and 10q.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Limited sample size for specific tumor types: While 56 childhood tumors were analyzed, the number of benign tumors or specific subtypes within the radiation-exposed groups was relatively small, limiting definitive conclusions for those categories.
  • Comparison with "spontaneous" tumors: The study primarily compares radiation-induced tumors with adult thyroid tumors without a radiation history from existing literature. Direct comparison with childhood thyroid tumors that arose spontaneously would strengthen the findings.
  • Positional cloning of genes: The authors suggest that the identified chromosomal aberrations, particularly the novel breakpoints, provide excellent starting points for positional cloning. This would involve pinpointing the specific genes affected by these changes and investigating their role in radiation-induced tumorigenesis.
  • Functional studies: Future work could involve investigating the functional consequences of these identified genetic alterations, for example, by studying gene expression or protein activity in these tumors.
  • Broader application of advanced techniques: While SKY and CGH were applied to a complex case, their broader application to more cases could reveal further intricate details of radiation-induced genomic instability.

Summary updated

Abstract

Thyroid carcinoma incidence is increased significantly after ionizing irradiation; however, the possible mechanisms have not yet been identified. To provide clues for an understanding of the radiation-induced transformation of thyroid epithelium, we analyzed the karyotypes of 56 childhood thyroid tumors that appeared in Belarus after the Chernobyl nuclear accident in 1986. We also studied eight secondary thyroid tumors that developed after radiotherapy. Metaphase preparations obtained from primary cultures were analyzed by G-banding. Clonal structural aberrations were found in 13 of 56 Belarussian cases and in 6 of 8 secondary tumors that developed after radiotherapy. Furthermore, we detected multiple chromosomal aberrations as well as complex rearrangements in some of these tumors and performed a detailed analysis of marker chromosomes from a single case using spectral karyotyping and comparative genomic hybridization in a childhood tumor from Belarus with a near-triploid karyotype. Both comparative genomic hybridization and spectral karyotyping analysis revealed structural alterations affecting identical chromosomes 1, 2, 9, and 13, among others. In addition to the known hot spots of alterations in papillary thyroid carcinomas on chromosomes 1q and 10q, a comprehensive breakpoint analysis in the pooled data set revealed novel breakpoints on chromosomes 4q, 5q, 6p, 12q, 13q, and 14q. The chromosomal aberrations in these tumors may provide suitable starting points for the positional cloning of genes involved in radiation-induced tumorigenesis.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{zitzelsberger1999cytogenetic,
  author = {Horst Zitzelsberger and Lars Lehmann and Ludwig Hieber and Heinz‐Ulrich G. Weier and Catherine Janish and Jingly Fung and Thomas Negele and F. Spelsberg and Edmund Lengfelder and Eugene P. Demidchik and Konstatinos Salassidis and Albrecht M. Kellerer and Martin Werner and Manfred Bauchinger},
  title = {{Cytogenetic changes in radiation-induced tumors of the thyroid.}},
  booktitle = {PubMed},
  year = {1999},
}
Figure