Cyber Teaming and Role Specialization in a Cyber Security Defense Competition

Norbou Buchler, Claire Genevieve La Fleur, Blaine Hoffman, Prashanth Rajivan, Laura R. Marusich, Lewis LightnerFrontiers in Psychology 2018 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper investigates what makes cybersecurity defense teams successful in high-pressure, simulated environments. They found that effective collaboration, experience, and specialized roles within a team are crucial for success, particularly in detecting and mitigating cyberattacks. These findings highlight the importance of team dynamics beyond individual technical skills for robust cybersecurity.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Developing a skilled cybersecurity workforce is a major challenge. While technical prowess is essential, understanding how humans work together in dynamic, adversarial cyber environments is equally critical. Traditional research often focuses on individual vulnerabilities or technical solutions. This paper addresses the gap in understanding the "human dimension" of cybersecurity, specifically how team dynamics, role specialization, and experience contribute to effective cyber defense in realistic, high-stakes scenarios. The authors aim to identify the key factors that differentiate successful cyber defense teams from less effective ones.

Methods

The researchers employed a mixed-methods approach, combining observational data with survey responses from participants in the 12th annual Mid-Atlantic Collegiate Cyber Defense Competition (MACCDC).

  • Observational Assessment of Teamwork (OAT): Embedded observers used a 13-point instrument to evaluate teamwork and leadership behaviors during the competition.
  • Cyber Teamwork Survey: Participants completed a survey to provide insights into team composition, work processes, and their own experience and skill sets.
  • Bayesian Regression Analysis: This statistical technique was used to model the relationship between various team characteristics (skill composition, experience, collaboration) and the teams' performance scores in the competition. Bayesian methods were chosen to provide a more nuanced understanding of uncertainty in the parameter estimates.

Datasets

The study utilized data collected from the 12th annual Mid-Atlantic Collegiate Cyber Defense Competition (MACCDC). This competition involved eight collegiate teams tasked with defending simulated networks against simulated cyberattacks. The data collected included:

  • Performance Scores: Teams were evaluated on four independent dimensions: maintaining services, incident response, scenario injects, and thwarting adversarial activities.
  • Observational Data: Collected via the OAT instrument by embedded observers.
  • Survey Data: Collected from all participants regarding their skills, experience, and team dynamics.

This competition serves as a novel benchmark for evaluating cyber defense team performance in a controlled, yet realistic, environment.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Beyond Individual Skills: The study strongly suggests that technical skills alone are insufficient for effective cyber defense. Team dynamics, collaboration, and experience play a significant role in determining success.
  • The Power of Specialization: Functional role specialization within a team emerged as a key predictor of success. This implies that teams with members who have clearly defined, complementary roles are better equipped to handle complex cyber threats.
  • Experience Matters: Years of experience, both individually and as a team, were found to be positively correlated with performance, particularly in areas like incident response. This aligns with theories of team maturation.
  • Collaboration is Key, But Nuanced: While collaboration was generally found to be beneficial, its unique predictive power varied across different task domains. In some cases, its impact was intertwined with experience and role specialization.
  • Task-Specific Skill Requirements: Different cyber defense tasks (e.g., maintaining services vs. incident response) require different combinations of skills. This highlights the need for adaptable teams with a broad range of capabilities.

Key Results

  • Predictive Factors: Effective collaboration, team experience, and functional role specialization were identified as significant predictors of team success in the MACCDC.
  • Role Specialization and Performance: Teams with a greater number of specialized roles tended to perform better, especially in maintaining services. This suggests that a breadth of skills is beneficial.
  • Experience and Incident Response: More years of experience were a positive predictor of successful incident response.
  • Collaboration and Scenario Injects: Collaboration was a strong predictor of performance on scenario inject tasks, which involved responding to high-priority, time-sensitive tasks.
  • Red Team Defense: Interestingly, the study's measures did not uniquely predict performance against the "Red Team" (adversarial attacks), suggesting other factors might be at play in this specific domain.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Generalizability: The study acknowledges that conclusions drawn from a single competition might be context-specific. Future work aims to replicate these findings in other simulated environments and with different types of cyber defense tasks.
  • Measure Nuances: The authors noted that their measure of collaboration did not uniquely predict performance when other factors like experience and role specialization were included, suggesting potential overlap or the need for more refined measurement.
  • Directive Leadership: The study suggests that directive leadership might compensate for lower functional team cognition, indicating a potential area for future research into leadership styles in cyber defense.
  • Functional Team Cognition: The authors propose a "functional team cognition framework" based on team members' knowledge of each other's skills and how these relate to work processes. Future research will focus on operationalizing and testing this framework.
  • Skill Depth vs. Breadth: While breadth of skills (more roles) was beneficial for some tasks, the study also hints at the importance of skill depth for others (e.g., incident response with fewer roles). Further exploration of this trade-off is warranted.

Summary updated

Abstract

A critical requirement for developing a cyber capable workforce is to understand how to challenge, assess, and rapidly develop human cyber skill-sets in realistic cyber operational environments. Fortunately, cyber team competitions make use of simulated operational environments with scoring criteria of task performance that objectively define overall team effectiveness, thus providing the means and context for observation and analysis of cyber teaming. Such competitions allow researchers to address the key determinants that make a cyber defense team more or less effective in responding to and mitigating cyber attacks. For this purpose, we analyzed data collected at the 12th annual Mid-Atlantic Collegiate Cyber Defense Competition (MACCDC, http://www.maccdc.org), where eight teams were evaluated along four independent scoring dimensions: maintaining services, incident response, scenario injects, and thwarting adversarial activities. Data collected from the 13-point OAT (Observational Assessment of Teamwork) instrument by embedded observers and a cyber teamwork survey completed by all participants were used to assess teamwork and leadership behaviors and team composition and work processes, respectively. The scores from the competition were used as an outcome measure in our analysis to extract key features of team process, structure, leadership, and skill-sets in relation to effective cyber defense. We used Bayesian regression to relate scored performance during the competition to team skill composition, team experience level, and an observational construct of team collaboration. Our results indicate that effective collaboration, experience, and functional role-specialization within the teams are important factors that determine the success of these teams in the competition and are important observational predictors of the timely detection and effective mitigation of ongoing cyber attacks. These results support theories of team maturation and the development of functional team cognition applied to mastering cybersecurity.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{buchler2018cyber,
  author = {Norbou Buchler and Claire Genevieve La Fleur and Blaine Hoffman and Prashanth Rajivan and Laura R. Marusich and Lewis Lightner},
  title = {{Cyber Teaming and Role Specialization in a Cyber Security Defense Competition}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Psychology},
  year = {2018},
  doi = {10.3389/fpsyg.2018.02133},
}
Figure