Cyber Resilience and Incident Response in Smart Cities: A Systematic Literature Review

Gabriela Ahmadi‐Assalemi, Haider Al‐Khateeb, Gregory Epiphaniou, Carsten MapleSmart 2020 · DOI

TL;DR

This systematic literature review (SLR) analyzes existing research on cyber resilience and digital forensics for Cyber-Physical Systems (CPS) in smart cities. It reveals that while research in this area is growing, it's a relatively new field with a strong focus on detection and analysis, leaving other crucial incident response phases underdeveloped. The review also highlights a significant lack of real-world datasets, hindering robust empirical validation.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The rapid expansion of smart cities, driven by Industry 4.0 and the Internet of Things (IoT), creates complex cyber-physical-natural ecosystems. These systems, while offering numerous benefits, are inherently fragile and susceptible to cyberattacks. Ensuring the resilience of these systems against cyber threats and having effective digital forensic incident response (DFIR) capabilities are critical for the safe and reliable operation of smart cities. However, there's a need to systematically understand the current state of research, identify existing frameworks and systems, and pinpoint gaps in knowledge, particularly concerning how CPS in smart cities can be made more resilient and how DFIR can be effectively implemented.

Methods

The authors conducted a systematic literature review (SLR) following the guidelines proposed by Kitchenham and Charters. This involved a multi-phase process:

  • Planning: Defining the research questions and developing a review protocol.
  • Conducting: Identifying relevant digital libraries (IEEE, ACM DL, Science Direct, Web of Knowledge, Scopus), constructing a comprehensive search string, applying inclusion/exclusion criteria to filter primary studies, and conducting a quality assessment of the selected studies. A snowballing approach was also used to identify additional relevant papers.
  • Reporting: Disseminating the findings.

The selection process involved keyword filtering, title/abstract/conclusion screening, and full-text filtering, ultimately resulting in 52 primary studies for analysis. Quality assessment focused on the study's focus on CPS security, context detail, framework detail, and data reporting.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The paper highlights a lack of available real CPS-generated datasets, with most studies relying on testbeds or simulation software.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Emerging Field: Research on cyber resilience and DFIR for CPS in smart cities is a relatively recent phenomenon, with most studies published after 2011.
  • Detection Dominance: The majority of research focuses on the "detection and analysis" phase of incident response, neglecting other critical stages like containment, eradication, recovery, and post-incident activities.
  • Data Scarcity: A significant hurdle is the lack of real-world CPS-generated datasets, forcing researchers to rely on simulations or testbeds, which may not fully represent real-world complexities.
  • Sectoral Imbalance: Smart infrastructure, mobility, and security sectors receive more research attention than smart healthcare and smart citizen sectors, potentially due to regulatory hurdles, ethical challenges, and data availability issues in the latter.
  • Cross-Sectoral Gap: While the need for cross-sector collaboration in cybersecurity is recognized, there's limited evidence of concrete proposals or applications for improving digital forensics across different smart city sectors.

Key Results

  • Trend Analysis: A clear upward trend in CPS-related research addressing cyber resilience and DFIR in smart cities has been observed, with a significant increase in studies from 2016 onwards.
  • Keyword Frequency: "System," "Security," "Internet of Things," and "Cyber-Physical Systems" were the most frequent keywords, indicating a strong interest in IoT security for CPS. The keyword "framework" also appeared frequently, suggesting an active but emerging area of research.
  • DFIR Stage Focus: 67% of primary studies exclusively focused on cyberattack detection. The "detection and analysis" stage was addressed by a significant majority (67.308%), while "containment, eradication, and recovery" was covered by only 13%. "Preparation" and "post-incident activity" stages were addressed by a smaller proportion of studies.
  • Adversary Type: While external threats are frequently studied, a significant portion of studies (45%) did not sufficiently clarify the threat type. There's an increasing focus on combined internal and external threats.
  • Geographic Distribution: The USA leads in research contributions (23%), followed by Singapore (10%), the UK (8%), and Australia (7%). Asia is the continent with the highest concentration of research (37%).

Limitations and Future Work

  • Limited Datasets: The lack of real CPS-generated datasets is a major limitation, hindering robust validation and comparative experiments. Future work should focus on creating accessible datasets.
  • Under-Researched DFIR Phases: The limited attention to containment, eradication, recovery, and post-incident activities in DFIR presents a significant gap. Future research should explore these phases more thoroughly.
  • Sectoral Focus: Smart healthcare and smart citizen sectors are under-researched. Future work should address these areas, considering their unique challenges.
  • Cross-Sectoral Collaboration: More research is needed on cross-sector proposals and applications to improve digital forensics, fostering collaborative cyber defense practices.
  • Interdisciplinary Approach: The authors advocate for an interdisciplinary approach across smart sectors and aggregated sharing of cyber threat intelligence (CTI) to enhance situational awareness and combat sophisticated cyberattacks.
  • CTI Integration: Future research could focus on applying CTI to model attacks on critical functions and underlying systems, including people, processes, and technologies, to improve protection, detection, and response capabilities.

Summary updated

Abstract

The world is experiencing a rapid growth of smart cities accelerated by Industry 4.0, including the Internet of Things (IoT), and enhanced by the application of emerging innovative technologies which in turn create highly fragile and complex cyber–physical–natural ecosystems. This paper systematically identifies peer-reviewed literature and explicitly investigates empirical primary studies that address cyber resilience and digital forensic incident response (DFIR) aspects of cyber–physical systems (CPSs) in smart cities. Our findings show that CPSs addressing cyber resilience and support for modern DFIR are a recent paradigm. Most of the primary studies are focused on a subset of the incident response process, the “detection and analysis” phase whilst attempts to address other parts of the DFIR process remain limited. Further analysis shows that research focused on smart healthcare and smart citizen were addressed only by a small number of primary studies. Additionally, our findings identify a lack of available real CPS-generated datasets limiting the experiments to mostly testbed type environments or in some cases authors relied on simulation software. Therefore, contributing this systematic literature review (SLR), we used a search protocol providing an evidence-based summary of the key themes and main focus domains investigating cyber resilience and DFIR addressed by CPS frameworks and systems. This SLR also provides scientific evidence of the gaps in the literature for possible future directions for research within the CPS cybersecurity realm. In total, 600 papers were surveyed from which 52 primary studies were included and analysed.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{ahmadiassalemi2020cyber,
  author = {Gabriela Ahmadi‐Assalemi and Haider Al‐Khateeb and Gregory Epiphaniou and Carsten Maple},
  title = {{Cyber Resilience and Incident Response in Smart Cities: A Systematic Literature Review}},
  booktitle = {Smart},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.3390/smartcities3030046},
}
Figure