Abstract
We study the influence of jet structure on the curvature effect in a GRB-lightcurve. Using a simple model of jet emissivity, we numerically calculate lightcurves for a short flash from a relativistic outflow having various profiles of the Lorentz factor and outflowing energy density (gaussian, core+power-law). We find that for "on-beam" viewing geometry, with the line of sight passing through the bright core of the outflow, the shape of the lightcurve practically does not depend on the jet structure, initially following the temporal slope $2+\delta$, where $\delta$ is the spectral index. When the viewing angle is larger than the core, the light curve decaying slope is shallower. We discuss the implications of our results for the Swift data.
Introduction: The Curvature Effect Challenge
When a relativistic jet in a Gamma-Ray Burst (GRB) suddenly ceases emission—a "turn-off"—the observer does not perceive an instantaneous drop in flux. Due to the curvature of the emitting surface, light from the edges of the jet travels a longer path than light from the center, creating a delayed "tail" in the lightcurve known as the curvature effect.
Standard analytical theory predicts that this decay should follow a specific power-law slope: $\alpha = 2 + \delta$, where $\delta$ is the spectral index. However, observations from the Swift satellite revealed rapid X-ray decays that often deviated from this prediction. This study investigates whether the internal structure of the jet—the angular distribution of the Lorentz factor ($\Gamma$) and energy density ($\epsilon$)—is responsible for these discrepancies.
Modeling Jet Structure
To explore these effects, we utilized a 3D numerical code to simulate lightcurves for a "short flash" across four distinct jet profiles:
- Gaussian: Both $\epsilon$ and $\Gamma$ decrease following a Gaussian profile from the jet axis.
- e-Gaussian: Only $\epsilon$ follows a Gaussian profile; $\Gamma$ is constant.
- Core + Power Law (CPL): Profiles feature a flat core transitioning into a power-law decay at larger angles.
- e-CPL: Only $\epsilon$ follows the CPL profile; $\Gamma$ is constant.
Key Findings
Robustness of the $2+\delta$ Law
A primary finding is the resilience of the $2+\delta$ slope for "on-beam" observers (those looking through the jet's bright core). As shown in the bottom panels of Figure 1, the initial decay slope for on-axis observers ($\theta_{obs} = 0$) consistently matches the analytical prediction ($\alpha \approx 3.3$ for the chosen $\delta = 1.3$), regardless of the underlying jet structure. This suggests that the early curvature effect is relatively insensitive to the global jet geometry.
Off-Beam Shallowness and Rebrightening
For observers positioned at angles larger than the core width ($\theta_{obs} > \theta_c$), the lightcurve behavior changes significantly:
- Shallower Decay: The decay slope becomes notably shallower than the standard $2+\delta$ prediction. This provides a potential explanation for Swift observations showing slower-than-expected X-ray decays.
- Rebrightening Bumps: In models where the Lorentz factor varies with angle (Gaussian and CPL), the lightcurves can exhibit a "rebrightening" or plateau at late times. This occurs because as the observer's line of sight probes further out into the jet, the decreasing $\Gamma$ can lead to a temporary increase in the Doppler factor, slowing the flux decay or creating a small bump.
Conclusion
The internal structure of GRB jets significantly influences the curvature effect, particularly for off-axis observers. While the standard $2+\delta$ decay is a robust signature for on-beam viewing, structural variations can explain the diverse range of decay slopes and late-time features, such as plateaus and flares, seen in Swift X-ray afterglows. These results provide a framework for interpreting the complex temporal behavior of GRB emission.
Summary updated